WASHINGTON -- Taking on baseball's steroids problem once
again, Congress kept the finger-pointing and tough questioning to a
minimum. Maybe that's because the people under the most scrutiny
this time -- Miguel Tejada, Barry Bonds, Roger Clemens -- were
nowhere to be seen.
Commissioner Bud Selig and union leader Donald Fehr accepted
responsibility for the sport's drug boom and the author of the
Mitchell report defended his findings in the same wood-paneled
House hearing room that hosted a far longer and far more
contentious session in March 2005.
It didn't take long for the focus to shift to players Tuesday.
The hearing opened with word that Congress wants Tejada, the
2002 AL MVP, investigated for lying to federal authorities. The
first witness, former Senate majority leader George Mitchell,
testified he believes a former trainer's allegations that he
injected seven-time Cy Young Award winner Clemens with steroids and
human growth hormone. And Selig told lawmakers that Bonds'
San Francisco Giants should have reported concerns about the home run
king's personal trainer.
The 4-hour, 15-minute session before the House Oversight and
Government Reform Committee also exposed what might be the latest
drugs abused by the sport's stars: Ritalin and Adderall, stimulants
better known as treatments for hyperactive kids. According to data
provided to the committee by MLB and the union, a copy of which was
obtained by The Associated Press, there were 35 "Therapeutic Use
Exemptions" for drugs in 2006, of which 28 were for ADD and ADHD
medications. In 2007, the exemptions skyrocketed to 111, of which
103 were for ADD and ADHD.
"It seems to be a little bit odd, said Dr. Gary Wadler,
chairman of committee that determines the World Anti-Doping
Agency's banned-substances list. "I'm the guy who made the issue
three years ago about amphetamines, and baseball said they didn't
have a problem with greenies."
One of Mitchell's recommendations was that baseball needs an
independent agency to handle drug testing, and the data about ADD
drugs supports that, Wadler said.
"This demands an explanation. There's something fundamentally
wrong them going from 28 to 103," Wadler said. "If we had this
percentage increase in the general population, it would be on the
evening news as a national epidemic. It's an outrageous number."
Overall, though, Selig and Fehr found a far friendlier audience
than they did on March 17, 2005, when they were chastised and
grilled by the same committee for a lax steroids program. That
11-hour hearing is best remembered for Mark McGwire's infamous and
oft-repeated phrase, "I'm not here to talk about the past," and
Rafael Palmeiro's finger-wagging denial of steroid use only months
before failing a drug test.
"I'm proud of the progress we've made. I never delude myself,
because I know there's always more work to be done," Selig said
after Tuesday's hearing. "But when you think of where we were
three years ago to where we are ... I appreciated the response from
In the aftermath of the 2005 hearing, baseball and the union
agreed to toughen their drug policy, including harsher penalties,
more testing and a ban on amphetamines.
In his opening statement, Selig vowed to do more, including
testing top prospects before the amateur draft. He also reiterated
a willingness to test for human growth hormone "when a valid,
commercially available and practical test for HGH becomes reality,
regardless of whether the test is based on blood or urine."
Fehr, in turn, said the union has agreed to "allow players to
be suspended for HGH use based on evidence other than a positive
He and Selig said they met in December to discuss the Mitchell
report's recommendations and plan to meet again.
"I hope we have all of this completed before spring training,"
Not every exchange with the lawmakers was easy.
"This scandal happened under your watch. I want that to sink
in. It did," Maryland Democrat Elijah Cummings told Selig and
Fehr, frequent adversaries seated side-by-side at the witness table
after Mitchell finished. "Do you accept responsibility for this
scandal or do you think there was nothing you could do to prevent
Fehr paused for several seconds.
"Did we or did I appreciate the depth of the problem? ... The
answer is 'No,'" Fehr replied. "It's a failure that we didn't,
and it's a failure that I didn't."
Selig then followed, starting by saying he's agonized over the
"Do I wish we could have reacted quicker? Should we have? One
could make the case," the commissioner said. "All of us have to
take responsibility, starting with me."
Before any testimony, committee chairman Henry Waxman announced
he and ranking Republican Tom Davis asked the Justice Department to
look into whether Tejada lied to committee staffers when questioned
in connection to Palmeiro's perjury case in 2005.
"Tejada told the committee that he never used illegal
performance-enhancing drugs and that he had no knowledge of other
players using or even talking about steroids," Waxman said.
"Well, the Mitchell report, however, directly contradicts key
elements of Mr. Tejada's testimony."
Palmeiro said his positive test might have resulted from a B-12
vitamin injection given to him by Tejada -- at the time, a teammate
on the Baltimore Orioles -- and the committee concluded there was
insufficient evidence to refer Palmeiro's case to the Justice
In the Mitchell Report, Adam Piatt, Tejada's former teammate
with the Oakland Athletics, said he provided Tejada with steroids
and HGH in 2003. Mitchell also included copies of checks allegedly
written by Tejada to Piatt in March 2003 for $3,100 and $3,200.
"We will review and respond to the letter from Chairman Waxman
and Rep. Davis," Justice Department spokesman Peter Carr said.
Late in the day came news that Tejada's older brother, Freddy,
was killed in a motorcycle accident in the Dominican Republic,
according to the Aguilas Cibaenas, the shortstop's winter league
team. Tejada, scheduled to play Tuesday night, wasn't at the
ballpark and could not immediately be reached for comment.
Waxman raised Bonds' name during Selig's appearance, asking the
commissioner whether the Giants should have reported their concerns
about Bonds' trainer, Greg Anderson, and the slugger's alleged
steroid use to the commissioner's office.
"Of course," Selig responded.
Pressed by Waxman about whether Giants general manager Brian
Sabean violated baseball rules by not doing so, Selig said: "It's
a matter that I have under review," perhaps hinting that Sabean or
other team officials could face discipline.
Waxman also expressed concern that, according to the report,
Giants owner Peter Magowan's lawyer called Mitchell to say Magowan
"misspoke" about Bonds' possible use of steroids.
"This incident shows why it's important for baseball's
management to take the problem of steroids seriously. It's possible
that the BALCO scandal could have been averted if Brian Sabean and
Peter Magowan acted in a responsible fashion," Waxman said.
"Instead, they seemed more intent on protecting Bonds."
Magowan issued a statement that did not directly address the
Bonds-Anderson issue, saying instead the Giants "pledge to embrace
every necessary reform to address" the steroids problem.
Since last month's release of the Mitchell report, the focus
largely has been on Clemens, who has been asked to testify at a
Feb. 13 hearing, along with his former trainer, Brian McNamee.
Clemens has vehemently denied McNamee's allegations.
"You continue to feel comfortable with Mr. McNamee's
credibility?" Waxman asked.
"We believe that the statements provided to us were truthful,"
Mitchell said, adding McNamee was interviewed three times.