• Archive:  
Updated: July 20, 2010, 9:09 AM ET

Fielder worth his weight in a trade

Kruk By John Kruk
As the trade deadline approaches -- 11 days and counting -- there still are questions about whether the Brewers will deal Prince Fielder or whether he is even worth the risk for those teams considering calling up Milwaukee about a trade.

Although there likely are a couple of suitors, the Texas Rangers would ultimately create the perfect storm.

[+] EnlargePrince Fielder
AP Photo/Gregory SmithPrince Fielder hit his 23rd homer Monday night. A bunch of teams would like to have that kind of clout in the lineup.

If Texas can handle its ownership issues, it should make an aggressive push for Fielder. In addition to the prized slugger, the Rangers would have Vladimir Guerrero, Josh Hamilton and Nelson Cruz in the middle of their lineup. Plus, Cliff Lee now stands at the top of their rotation. Watch out Yankees! If Texas can get Fielder, it will be a serious problem for a lot of teams.

A few teams that don't need him? The Mets, Braves and Yankees.

However, there are a few other teams, aside from the Rangers, that I think would benefit from Fielder's presence: the Rockies, Rays, Giants and Dodgers. Even though Rockies first baseman Todd Helton is back after spending 15 days on the DL, he is not superior to Fielder. At one point, Tampa Bay was rumored to be pursuing Fielder, but it won't be going anywhere near his hefty price tag despite an underproducing Carlos Pena. Buster Posey, whom San Francisco has used both at first base and behind the plate, is producing at a high level for the Giants. But if San Francisco were to add Fielder, it could really do some damage because it would have legitimate power in its lineup coupled with exceptional pitching. Dodgers first baseman James Loney is a good hitter, but he doesn't provide a lot of power. If Los Angeles can pick up Fielder, it would essentially solve one of their biggest issues.

Doubters say Fielder's size is a risk, but his father, Cecil Fielder, was a big man, and Prince has always been big. I met Prince when he was 12 years old. Cecil and I were playing in a charity softball outing, and Prince came with him. He was a big kid then. He will always be a big kid. I remember when I first got signed, I was 170 pounds and then I hurt my knee in A-ball and shot up to 200 pounds. Eventually, I played at 215 pounds, and I was overweight for my size. In Prince's case, this is not an abnormal thing for him. He's a big guy, but he's still very agile around the bases. He's similar to Ryan Howard, in that he's a big guy but they both carry their weight well and they actually have good feet. The only area where the pair differs is that Howard is a bit more consistent.

People keep asking if Price Fielder is worth the risk, but I don't think he's a risk at all. He's a proven major league power hitter. He's not a great first baseman, but he's better than most and he can still get around the bases. Fielder will go from first to third, he can score from second on a single, and there's something to be said about having a father who was a major league player. He's been in clubhouses his entire life, and the baseball diamond is where he thrives.

John Kruk is an analyst for "Baseball Tonight"

Baseball Tonight Live

"Baseball Tonight" analysts, ESPN.com writers and SweetSpot Network bloggers chatted and gave their in-game opinions throughout the day's games -- all in Baseball Tonight Live.

Touch 'Em All

Who went deep? Keep track of all the home runs hit each day on "Baseball Tonight" and the Baseball Tonight Clubhouse page. For more, check out the Home Run Tracker page.


You must be signed in to post a comment

Already have an account?