How is it possible that the Braves were given a rating of two baseballs out of four? This was a common criticism from readers who wrote in to comment on our midseason report. Others included analysis on why the Braves had underachieved, or overachieved, depending on your point of view. But overall, almost everyone who wrote believes that the Braves are about to put together an incredible second half of the season. Here's a sampling of your responses.
Why do you hate us so?
What is the rationale for giving the Braves a grade of two baseballs when the Phillies, who are just one game ahead of them in the NL East, are given four? Moreover, how can you justify giving the Marlins (.489 winning pct, 7.5 games out of first) the same grade as the Braves? Are you grading based upon actual performance or some nebulous "potential" based on the biases of the writer?
Kevin King
Atlanta, GA
I think that the grade of two baseballs is a little harsh. They are only two-and-a-half games behind last year, and they are missing forty percent of their starting staff. I agree completely with the weak performances in their lineup, but I think that their strong play in June should have given them a higher rating. Maybe you could find an extra baseball in your grading bag for them; I suggest Texas, they don't even deserve one ball, all they'll do with it is give up more runs.
Rich Finn
Riverside, IL
Disappointments are turning it around
While all the Braves listed were disapointments, all have performed better lately. Javy is still struggling because it appears he just can't quit trying to pull everything. When he goes with pitches he's driving them, if not it seems to pop-upville. Caminiti could now be the godsend. I think we'll see Chipper at short against righthanders for awhile as an experiment, Brogna at first and Cammi at third. I think you have to give DeRosa an honest shot at playing everyday though, the guy is hitting over .400. Wes Helms is the guy who could very easily be left out in the cold, and he's played better than his fate will bring.
Jim
Caldwell, ID
Team needs improvement
I am a die-hard Braves fan but I'll be the first to tell you that they are not going to win the World Series with the team that they have. I think they will win their division and get past the first round but lose in the NLCS. I just don't understand how John Schuerholz thinks that this team can win it all with Veras leading off (.252 avg .326 obp), Brogna/Helms at first (5 homers, 30 rbis), and, granted they have been playing well of late but Brian Jordan and B.J. Surhoff are 6 and 7 hitters, not 5 and 2 hitters. How do the Braves expect other teams to pitch to Chipper when the person on deck has never hit 30 homers or batted .300 in a full season? One of the things that has baffled me the most this season is that Bobby Cox will not put Javy Lopez in the 5 hole. Now, realistically I believe in my heart that if Caminiti can play first exclusively and Veras starts hitting this lineup could cause some havoc.
Chad Simmons
Enterprise, AL
Javy a have-not
Biggest disappointment has to be Javy Lopez. He is not hitting, period. He is an average defender, solid but not spectacular. For him to be a true asset to the Braves, he needs to produce, something he is not doing. His current season, combined with his last two, are sure driving his value down as he approaches free agency.
Peter Friberg
San Diego, CA
The Braves' first half was one of the worst I've witnesed since '91. They've gotten hugely unlucky with their last few "major" moves, e.g. Bret Boone, Ryan Klesko, Reggie Sanders, Jermaine Dye, just to name a few. They need a first basemen who can at least pretend he can hit for power. Brogna isn't doing much at all. My advice would either to move Caminiti there, Javy there, or maybe even Chipper there to make up for it. Javy won't be there next year, at least as their catcher. He's had a horrible year hitting, and calls a slow game from behind the plate. That's why Maddux won't use him. He has potential, and has shown it the last few years, when he lays off the sliders and curveballs in the dirt. The same for Andruw Jones. He swings at more junk than anyone I've ever seen. If they can just get more disciplined from the plate, and make a couple roster moves for some more power in left and first, they'll be off to their 10th straight division title.
Nate Schroeder
Marion, IN
The Braves an underdog?
Given the injuries and the slow start the Braves had this year along with the added pressure of everyone saying that this will be the year the Braves finally fail to make the play-offs, I think the Braves have stood tall. The hitting is really coming around, and they are back to there methodical winning ways again. This team has that underdog look to them much like in 1991. I tell you honestly, they are the dark horse, no one will even see them coming.
JB Mahaffey
Bristol, TN
The joke is on the fairweather fans
Record wise, I can't be too upset with where the Braves are. As you noted, they have had holes somewhere all season ... either with the seemingly team-wide hitting slump or lackluster pitching. Another thing though is something they have no control over, and that is the fans. Atlanta fans seemed to be ready to cash in the chips on the playoffs, at least until the fine June the Braves put together. We get to enjoy watching the likes of Maddux pitching, Burkett surprising everyone, and Chipper having another great year. Look for the Braves to have a brilliant second half, especially if Smoltz and Millwood can make solid comebacks.
Rob
Moultrie, GA
Power bat needed
Like you said, I don't think the Braves are the team they have been in the past, but I think they are beginning to come together and play winning baseball. They do need more production from players like Lopez, Brongna, and Surhoff. I wish they would go out and get a good power hitter for the middle of the lineup, why they got rid of the Big Cat is beyond me. I have no doubts that they will win their division, the Phillies are good, but are very inconsistant. I just think that we need a big bat in the 4 spot and then Chipper can take control.
Larry Peterson
Eastman, GA
Comebacks are the key
I agree basically with your assessement. However it seems that the greatest unknown is the potential riding in the return of Smoltz and Millwood. These players have an established quality, and if it is near that when they return, the Braves could make it to the NL championship series.
Thomas Asada-Grant
Sakado, Saitama, Japan
Easy on my boy B.J.
I agree that the Braves struggled at first but they are coming around. But to go out and dog Brian Jordan like that is crazy. Have you not seen the numbers he has put up here lately? It's all about change, it takes time.
Brian West
Wichita, KS
| |
|