Keyword
MLB
  Scores
  Schedules
  Standings
  Statistics
  Transactions
  Injuries
  Players
  Message Board
  Minor Leagues
  MLB en espaņol


 
The Roster
  Peter Gammons
  Joe Morgan
  Rob Neyer
  Jayson Stark
 
Fantasy
  Player News
  Correspondents
 
Broadcast
  ESPN Radio
  Video Highlights
  Audio Highlights
 
SportsMall
  Shop@ESPN.com
  NikeTown
  TeamStore


Sport Sections

Wednesday, July 11
Updated: July 17, 6:41 PM ET
Feedback: Desperately seeking arms



Even the most contrarian Indians fans couldn't come up with much to criticize about our statement in the Tribe's midseason report that the team's starting pitching has been poor thus far. It would take a rhetorical wizard with the skills of Johnny Cochran, combined with a statistician with the skills of the Florida electoral board to concoct such an argument. Not surprisingly, most of your responses echoed our sentiments on that issue. A selection of your responses.


Arms holding team hostage
Yeah that's says it all. The Tribe can bat, no question. Can they play 'D'? You bet. Probally won't find a more solid defense than this one out there. Is their bullpen good enough to get you through close games? Probally not the best in the league but pretty solid. How about the starting pitching? Well I probably wouldn't count on this starting rotation to knock down milk bottles for a free stuffed animal at my local carnival, let alone count on them to get me deep into the playoffs.

Scott
Cleveland, OH

Your analysis is pretty well on target. Not bad for a site that predicted Jacob Cruz to blossom this year in Cleveland. Hart and Shapiro need to act decisively before July 31 to reshape the pitching staff. Branyan, Cordero, Cordova (when will his trade value be higher) and, yes, even Omar Vizquel and Kenny Lofton could be packaged to bring a quality starter and some more bullpen help. Don't forget that the Indians' minor league organization pitching rich, especially at the Double-A level. They should try out a few of these young, live arms. Couldn't be any worse than the 2 or 3 innings they have been getting from their "veteran" starters. Finally, Nagy needs to retire. Insurance will pay for most of Nagy's remaining contract and that money will be freed up for a serious run at signing Juan Gonzalez for 4 or more years.

RTE
Columbus, OH

Ask John Hart if he wouldn't mind leaving the team half a season early. Then go out and buy some starting pitching.

Mo
Chicago, IL

You got it right! The Indians pitching is terrible. The poor bullpen is being overworked because of the starters' inability to go more than four or five innings. We need to stop trading the farm for these pitchers, and grow our own. Let these young ones pitch the rest of the season, and let those old, tired used up starters they have now, pitch in Triple-A. That way, they may get a few wins, and get their confidence back. Wouldn't hurt for the defense to have a few fewer errors per game either. It must hurt to be a pitcher, and have your defense muck up the field with all those errors, where if the plays were made, they could have gotten out of the inning. The whole team needs to look at what they are here getting paid for. Winning! If they are not here to win, they need to go. They do have a winning record, but maybe not for long.

Philip Williams
Mansfield, OH

Your analysis on the Indians first half is right on but a bit too simplistic. Everybody knew going into the season that they'd hit and not pitch. Tell me something about the new clubhouse now that Burks is in and Sandy is out? How are the players, the coaching staff and the fans preparing for John Hart's departure? Is there a big deal in the near future to hopefully send him off with a World Series parade? Get a quality starter (Astacio?) to put some presure on the rest of the staff and let's watch them battle their way into the playoffs and once again knock off the Mariners.

Matt
Chicago, IL

We miss you, Steve Karsay
The trade for John Rocker, which could only be justified as a budget saver, hurt their pitching prospects as much as anything. Steve Karsay came into spring training prepared to be a starter. Had he stayed in the AL he certainly would have deserved an All-Star team appearance, and he could have taken them a long way towards solving their starting pitching problems. With very good bullpen depth, they could have afforded to make this move. It also may have given them a good chance to sign Karsay again next year.

Jonathan Friedman
Arecibo, Puerto Rico

I thought the Rocker trade was a step in the wrong direction. I would have used Karsay and Reed for Al Leiter or Reed with the Mets. I find it hard to beleive that "The Braintrust" has yet to trade for or sign a dominant starter or at least a bonafide No. 2.

Thomas A. Tatum
Akron, OH

Colon's the real culprit -- and he's fat
It's hard to argue with too much of the report. I would swap Finley and Colon in terms of levels of disappointment, though. Everybody knew that it was possible for Finley to have problems in his 38th year of life, but Colon was supposed to have his "breakout" year this season; all he's breaking out of are his pants. His belly and mind are both soft, and he will never dominate the game until he mentally shifts to become the true ace his skills would allow him to be.

Jeff Urbanski
Columbus, OH

I agree that until the Indians can come up with some good starting pitching they will not see late Oct. ball games. They should have forgetten about Rocker and tried to get some good starting pitching. If Nagy, Burba, and Finley can't get their act together, than it's time to bring on the rest of the young arms from Double and Triple-A teams. They have some good arms down at those two levels. Some are ready for the majors and you might as well lose with youth rather than the older guys. Look at the White Sox pitching staff. Good young arms that are getting the job done.

Bob Ehrhardt
Cedar Falls, IA

Time for Lofton to go
Kenny Lofton has to be a major dissapointment so far this year. He is batting .237 and his on base percentage is a dismal .302. He does, however, lead the league in arguing with the home-plate umpire. Also, the coaching staff deserves a D+ for the first half. Dick Pole (the pitching coach) has done little to develop pitchers such as Bartolo Colon and Charlie Manuel has been outcoached in several games this year. The front office has not been much better. They traded Steve Karsay and Steve Reed for John Rocker. Both Karsay and Reed are in the final year of their contracts and Rocker is locked up for a few years. There bullpen was one of the strongest in Baseball. Why would you mess with it?

John Rinehart
Lincoln, NE

It is nice to see a review of the season that is right on. The only missing is the note that if Kenny Lofton continues to hit in the mid .200s the Tribe will be hurting.

Dan Scalabrino
Cleveland, OH

I'm not saying they're old, but...
...I think half the team will retire once they start getting their Social Security checks.

David Sippel
St. Paul, MN



 ESPN Tools
Email story
 
Most sent stories