Keyword
MLB
2001 ALL-STAR GAME
Rosters: AL | NL
Stats: AL | NL
Voting: AL | NL
Lineup Analysis

  Scores
  Schedules
  Standings
  Statistics
  Transactions
  Injuries
  Players
  Message Board
  Minor Leagues
  MLB en espaņol


 
The Roster
  Peter Gammons
  Joe Morgan
  Rob Neyer
  Jayson Stark
 
Fantasy
  Player News
  Correspondents
 
Broadcast
  ESPN Radio
  Video Highlights
  Audio Highlights
 
SportsMall
  Shop@ESPN.com
  NikeTown
  TeamStore


Sport Sections

Wednesday, July 11
Feedback: Another San Francisco (re)treat



Even though the Giants did not play close to their best ball in the first half of the season, most fans believe the team can reverse its fortune because the club has proven to be a second-half club in years past. The consensus, however: Unless the Giants get another bat, the only postseason action San Francisco will see this fall is on TV. Here are some edited responses:


As unclutch as they come
Without a legit RBI guy the Giants are going nowhere, fast. GM Brian Sabean must focus his efforts on solving that problem if the Giants are going to contend during the second half. One of the main reasons for the overworked bullpen is the lack of production with runnners in scoring position. This puts much stress on a pitching staff as well as on the emotional health of the team.

Bud Adler
San Jose, Calif.


Make a good move
I am unable to understand why San Francisco hasn't taken a more aggressive approach in pursuing another bat. It is obvious that the loss of Ellis Burks has hurt the team's overall offense (a fact that makes Barry Bonds' home run total in the first half even more remarkable). I would like to see the team go after someone like Fred McGriff, although he is probably headed to the Cubs, or Scott Rollin. The pitching will be fine once Livan Hernandez gets back on track. J.T. Snow needs to find a new home, as does Marvin Benard. Signing these players to multi-year deals has turned out to be a bad move.

Connor
Denver, Colo.


A team of Dustiny?
I'm afraid this won't be the Giants year. They let Burks get away and then failed to replace him. Giving Benard $11 million wasn't the best use of money, and the Giants don't seem interested in re-signing Bonds. Dusty Baker will naturally squeeze the most from his players. What could Baker do with a $75-100 million payroll?

Chris
Portland, Ore.


Don't give up on Livan
Livan is a disappointment so far, but come on, cut the guy some slack for having a major family crisis to deal with. I know that only counts for so much, but the guy is only human after all -- a little compassion for what the guy went through would be nice. When Livan first took the field for the Giants against the Cardinals a few seasons back, I was there, and watching him become a 17-game winnerer last year was wonderful. His fundamentals are still solid, but I think his head just isn't wrapped around the game right now.

Gregg Giles
San Francisco


Standing small
All you have to do is walk Rich Aurilia, Barry Bonds and Jeff Kent and you can shut out the Giants every time. The last game against Milwaukee before the All-Star break was disgusting. The Giants loaded the bases three times in extra innings and couldn't push a run across. Dusty Baker may be good with players but he can't manage. Why didn't he pinch hit for Robb Nen against the Brewers. Was he playing for a tie? My little league manager could have figured that one out.

Darrin Berger
San Francisco


Hitting help wanted
I feel the one thing the Giants are missing is another bat. Someone who can produce behind Kent. That would make Aurilia, Bonds, Kent and someone good a tough part of the lineup. I have only seen a few games where everything is working at the same time -- pitching, hitting and defense. If we get more of those games against the teams in our division, then I think we can sneak up on everyone. We are still in the division race and the wild-card race, and I feel we will be in the playoffs this year and succeed.

Joe
Redwood City, Calif.


Hocus-focus
The Giants seem to have a smart front office and that should help them; but Dusty Baker over the course of the last 10 months has done peculiar things. For his sake I hope it all does't catch up with him; Jeff Kent is finally hitting and I think they got too used to him carrying them offensively (from past seasons) and fell into the same non-idealistic funk with Barry Bonds' streak this season. The team has to concentrate (especially the rest of the offensive players) and not let the HR record attempt sway them from their challenge.

Prof. Primbud
New York City


Hummm, baby!
The Giants are a team that had a downer of a first half but, just like last year, are beginning to put things together at the break. Since Calvin Murray took over in center and Ramon Martinez at third base, the defense is MUCH improved. Also JT Snow will be coming back and that adds a gold glove to the infield as well. The offense needs a boost. I doubt Snow will hit .200 with 5 homers all year so he should help. The pitching has been terrible from Livan Hernandez, and Mark Gardiner so that should improve as well. Even with all these problems, San Francisco is still only 5.5 games out of first and 3.5 out of the wild card. The Giants are a ship which has patched up its leaks and will sail into the playoffs right by the Diamondbacks and the Dodgers.

Chris
San Francisco


Walk this way
How can anyone in San Francisco be surprised that Bonds is getting walked now? Mark McGwire got walked so many times it was pathetic, and he had Jim Edmonds hitting next to him in the lineup. The way Bonds smashes the ball, I don't understand why so many teams pitch to him. Why? Well, in '98, teams didn't want the roof lights busted out so they usually walked Mac. Yes, he struck out alot too. But so far this year, every time Bonds is at the plate, here comes an 85-mph high fastball or, even worse, an "OOps," the hanging curve. You know what happens to those -- even dented balls float.

D. Baker
Lexington, Tenn.


The epitome of futility
The Giants' record belies how bad they've actually played. The Giants cannot hit in the clutch, and I'm tempted to say they can't hit period. With the lack of prospects in the minor leagues, GM Brian Sabean can't do anything to address this need. I'm rooting for the Giants to make the postseason again, but barring a major trade by Sabean, it ain't gonna happen.

Scott
San Francisco


What a difference a year makes
The Giants, like the Mets, are on a downfall.

Joe Kleips
Las Vegas, Nev.


Dump Bonds
The only way the Giants will win anything more than a division title is to get rid of Barry Bonds. He sucks up way too much energy in the clubhouse with his 'holier than thou' attitude. If GM Brian Sabean could work out a trade for Bonds, he'd be a TRUE genius. Get some players that will grind out those elusive one run victories. With Barry, you get close to nothing when the game is on the line. Everyone knows that! It's ALWAYS been about Barry. Never the team.

Joe
Burlingame, Calif.


Hits and misses
Is there a team at any level of professional baseball getting less offense from its infield corner positions than the Giants? Dead bats and gloves of stone anchor the infield (granted, J.T. Snow is a notable exception on defense). Yet, the front office blithely bypasses Ken Caminiti, who reportedly wanted to play by the Bay. To be sure, he's not the long-term solution, but he's better by far than garbage cornermen like Guzman, Crespo, Snow, Martinez, and the dearly departed Russ Davis. Are the Giants completely obtuse when it comes to offense? We finally have an improvement in center field, only to find that both first and third base have gone to hell. Yet all we hear from Brian Sabean is that the Giants need more relief pitching. How about a decent bat?

Daryl Wilson
Philadelphia


What a letdown … so far
The Giants have really disappointed me this season. Why haven't they traded Mark Gardner? He isn't a quality pitcher, and he should have been shipped to the minors long ago. And Hernandez has been a major bust this season. The G-men or Baker Boys need to come together before the Dodgers or D-backs say thanks and take the NL West crown. The Giants have money: Spend a little bit on Bonds to keep him in Frisco and get some pitching!

Mark Bowdoin
Idaho Falls, Idaho


Say hey, can we all just get along?
The Giants are not the same team as last year. They are not a TEAM. There is a lot of tension in the dugout and in the clubhouse. First and foremost, they need to start acting like a team and stop blaming each other. Sabean needs to grab his nuts and make a trade for a catcher and a third baseman. Santiago is dead tired. His average is sinking like the Titanic. And we have no offense from either corner. They need to become a team again, and moves need to be made before L.A. or the D-Backs run away with the West.

Carrill
San Francisco


Summer of our discontent
Forty-five years and counting … counting excuses, a San Francisco baseball tradition. Let's not forget that the last Giants world championship was a fluke. Improbable event after improbable event. A tremendous run to close the season, Bobby Thompson's home run, beating the heavily favored Indians, gimme a break. Pure luck in all its glory for all to see and remember, emphasis on remember, because that's what Giants fans will have to do. Is there anyone out there that was old enough to drive a car when the Giants last won a World Series?

Anyone with any sense wishes Bob Lurie had allowed this team to go to Toronto. Then maybe the expansion Blue Jays could have been established in San Francisco instead of Toronto, AND then San Francisco would have a World Series trophy(s) that don't predate the Kennedy Administration (not Terry Kennedy, either).

Excuse in 1995: Bad ball park, no ticket sales, no revenue, no world championships.
Excuse in 2001: We have no money because we're paying for our new ball park. PacBell Park has provided plenty of ticket sales, plenty of fan revenue, but no real cash to spend, no world championship.
Excuse in 2006: We need to renovate our ball park, and now we have no money to spend, no world chmpionship.

Excuses are like … aw nevermind! It hasn't happened, it isn't happenin', and it won't happen. The Cubs, the Red Sox, and the Indians (maybe even the Senators) will each win a World Series before the Giants.

Todd Barsanti
Rancho Cordova, Calif.



 ESPN Tools
Email story
 
Most sent stories