Keyword
MLB
2001 ALL-STAR GAME
Rosters: AL | NL
Stats: AL | NL
Voting: AL | NL
Lineup Analysis

  Scores
  Schedules
  Standings
  Statistics
  Transactions
  Injuries
  Players
  Message Board
  Minor Leagues
  MLB en espaņol


 
The Roster
  Peter Gammons
  Joe Morgan
  Rob Neyer
  Jayson Stark
 
Fantasy
  Player News
  Correspondents
 
Broadcast
  ESPN Radio
  Video Highlights
  Audio Highlights
 
SportsMall
  Shop@ESPN.com
  NikeTown
  TeamStore


Sport Sections

Thursday, July 12
Feedback: Fans want Ilitch, Smith out



Wings clipped by management
It is time to get rid of Randy Smith. He is part of the problem and what is the deal with spending a lot of money of the Red Wings and ignoring the Tigers. Keep Gardner. I like him but let's shake up this team and spend a little money and get some quality guys. I would also like to see the Tigers go after some experienced players to help all the young guys on the team such as when Rickey Henderson was available at the beginning of the season or Ken Caminiti a few weeks ago. A major shake up is in order. We have the ability to win and to be very good we just need to be aggressive and not let up.

Kelly Duling
Toledo, Ohio

Stock up on pitchers
Ridiculous. We need pitching -- period. Trotting out Mlicki and Willie Blair is borderline offensive. Trade Clark now that he's hitting decently -- although still striking out more than he hits. Maybe Atlanta or San Diego would part with one of their youngsters that has a good arm and decent head. Two decent starters and one who should be doing better (Holt) isn't even close to good enough. Make a run again at .500 this year and position for next.

Kyle Karinen
Olympia, Wash.

Tigers watching others succeed
It has been a very exasperating season so far, and I really don't see anything that will change over the second half of the season. I am really at a loss as to why the Tigers can't put a competitive team on the field. Over the past 10 years, the Tigers have stunk every year. However, teams like Minnesota, Chicago Cubs, and Philadelphia have been just as bad as the Tigers have been, but they seem to be able to put together winning teams. Why can't the Tigers do that? Detroit doesn't seem to be able to develop good players from their farm system to give the fans something to look forward to. Weaver was supposed to have a break out year this season, but he isn't much better than the rest of the pitching staff. Juan Encarcion was supposed to be a five-star player just a year ago. Why hasn't he developed beyond being an average player? I have been a Tiger fan for 39 years, and will probably always follow them, however, it is getting very difficult ...

Steve Lorow
Fern Park, Fla.

Too many no-name losses
I live near Detroit and usually watch some of the Tigers games on TV. I pay attention to the team and try to be a good fan. I just can't stand how bad this team is every year. They show so much promise against some of the better teams in the league, then blow easy games to teams like Kansas City and other no name teams. I think if the Tigers ever do get any better, no premiere players will trust the Tigers to stay in the hunt every year.

Josh Kalil
Ferndale, Mich.

Crickets at Comerica
I speak for all Tiger players when I say this: GET YOUR BUTTS IN THE SEATS AT COMERICA. You wonder why we struggle? We have no suppport! Oh there are fans, but they never want to express their emotions. What, we have three sellouts this year? That's pathetic. If we had true fans, then I think we would be better. A true fan follows the team even when they struggle and, of course, when they are soaring unlike we have been for the last five years.

Shane O'Connor
Minden City, Mich.

A call for arms
We need a completely new pitching staff. Enough said!

Ken
Melbourne, Fla.

What's the plan?
Randy Smith has done everything possible to convince us that we should be patient while he trades away the young players like Kapler and Cordero for Juan GONE. Now they are telling us that youth is the answer. WE HAVE NO PLAN.

Brian D.
Boise, Idaho

Enough is enough!
Another year, another sub .500 team. How much more of this should we as Tiger fans endure? Given a "five-year plan" by Randy Smith, things could not have gotten worse after the worst team in Tigers history finished a horrendous 1996. But now, after a trade that gave away prospects for a whiny prima donna, and watching other lead Tiger players (Bubba Trammell, Travis Fryman, Luis Gonzalez, Phil Nevin) prosper outside of Detroit, it's no longer only the product on the field. It's the men in charge.

It was good to see McHale go to Tampa Bay, now as fans we can only hope that GM Randy Smith is the next to go. His idiotic trades and other questionable moves have sent the once proud franchise into a tailspin. Mike Ilitch seems to care only about the Red Wings, and continues to bait the fans around, only to trim the payroll and all but neglect the team. Phil Garner has made many questionable calls in games, playing sub-par players instead of the guys that can handle the day to day job.

I speak for many diehard Tiger fans when i say enough is enough. It has been seven years since a .500 season, and I can't endure another "five-year plan." Smith needs to go, and Ilitch needs to really show that he is a dedicated owner, or sell the team to someone who will make them a winner. The team is only as good as what's out there, and unfortunately, there's not much to be proud of.

Nate
Naperville, Ill.

Blame Garner
Please do not look at Phil Garner as some type of hero for his "inspirational speech" he gave. It is his fault they are where they are now. He does not know how to keep a good lineup in the game. I cannot believe how many times in the middle of a winning a streak or when someone is hot, that he sits them (i.e. Clark, Higginson, Easley, Fick). How many times does (Derek) Jeter and (Paul) O'Neill and (Scott) Brosius sit. A good manager plays with what he knows works. Garner doesn't, he's ignorant.

Larry Lorenzo
Toledo, Ohio

Wanted: Front-office personnel
When you look at the incredible talent that Detroit has, it makes you wonder why they are so sorry this year. Tony Clark, Bobby Higginson, Fick, Macias, Halter, Encarnacion, Matt Anderson, and Inge all have incredible upside. What is missing is starting pitching. I fully agree with you on Todd Jones; he has embarrassed himself this year. But even his six blown saves reversed barely get the Tigers to .500 ball. I am afraid that the Tigers will trade Clark and or Higginson and this would be a shame. Someone help this team!

Guy Ingram
Ahens, Ga.

Who's managing management?
Trading Luis Gonzalez for Karim Garcia sure looks like a good trade now, doesn't it? Karim Garcia! Anyways, moves like this have been a frustration of mine for years. The ability of players to flourish and to draw free agents as well as good management decisions have been as common in Detroit as a Cecil Fielder stolen base. I don't know what it is with Motown and guys named Gonzalez, but perhaps the only deal worse than Luis, was Juan. They tried their best to keep him, but to no avail, and they lost a handful of prospects and trust in management along with it. Changes need to be made to keep the good players they currently have as well as to draw some other big names and they need to made soon. The Tigers and the city of Detroit are one of baseball greatest traditions and I look forward to the day when the "Old English D" will flourish again.

Brian Zielke
Lake Jackson, Texas

Playing favorites
Unfortunately, the grade is correct for the Tigers first half. The most frustrating part of this half may be nothing the Tigers did on the field but what owner Mike Ilitch did off the field. Ilitch told Tigers fans that there wasn't any money to be spent for good athletes to come to Detroit, yet he shells out big money for Dominik Hasek and Luc Robitaille to come to his beloved Red Wings. Until Ilitch rights his wrongs and sells the team, the Tigers and their fans will have to continue to accept mediocrity as the best Mike Ilitch can do!

Aaron Burtch
Shelby Township, Mich.



 ESPN Tools
Email story
 
Most sent stories