|
Tom Tippett is the founder of Diamond Mind Baseball, a highly-realistic strategy-oriented computer baseball game. Click on their site for more baseball articles.
Having watched your favorite team play a bunch of games this past season,
you probably have a good feel for the positions where they need help and
the positions where they're set for the 2002 season.
But it's not as easy to keep up with all of the teams around the league,
so we thought it would be helpful to rank the offensive contributions
each team received from the players who manned each position this year.
American League rankings
Let's start with the American League. The numbers in the following table
show how each team ranked in on-base percentage plus slugging percentage
(OPS) at each position. If a player moved around, his stats are divided
among those positions based on what he did when playing each of those
positions. And it's important to point out that the stats upon which these
rankings are based were not park adjusted.
Team P C 1B 2B 3B SS LF CF RF DH PH
ANA 3 11 14 6 1 7 5 13 8 14 7
BAL 9 13 6 12 12 10 10 12 14 12 2
BOS 4 2 11 11 13 11 2 3 6 2 14
CHA 11 7 8 3 7 4 3 8 2 11 13
CLE 8 8 2 2 8 14 8 10 1 3 5
DET 13 9 13 10 6 5 4 11 13 6 8
KCA 7 12 4 14 14 13 12 2 7 10 11
MIN 1 4 9 8 3 6 9 7 9 5 3
NYA 14 3 12 5 4 2 14 1 10 13 4
OAK 12 5 1 7 2 3 13 9 4 8 12
SEA 10 6 5 1 9 8 11 5 3 1 1
TBA 6 10 10 9 11 12 6 14 11 9 10
TEX 5 1 7 4 5 1 7 4 12 4 9
TOR 2 14 3 13 10 9 1 6 5 7 6
Before we move on, let's take a moment to go over how to read this table.
Each column ranks the teams from top (1) to bottom (14) based on OPS by
the players at that position. Reading across, you can get a snapshot of
how a team ranked at each position.
For example, the NYA line tells us that the Yankees ranked 14th (dead
last) in the league in offensive production by its pitchers (big deal)
and left fielders (still think the Knoblauch move was a good one?). The
AL champs were 13th in production from the DH position. And only 12th
at first base despite a nice comeback season from Tino Martinez.
(Unfortunately for Tino fans, there are a lot of good-hitting first basemen in the league, and Tino's bat couldn't match that of Giambi or Thome or Delgado or Sweeney. Or Olerud or Palmeiro or Mientkiewicz or Konerko. Or even Daubach, McGriff or the Segui/Conine tandem in Baltimore.) On the plus side, New York received top-five contributions from their center fielders, shortstops, catchers,
third basemen, and second basemen. And their pinch hitters were strong.
This table makes it clear that even the best teams have weaknesses. Even
the record-setting Mariners were in the bottom half of the league offensively
at third, short and left. Granted, they weren't in the bottom half by
much, but it's still fair to say that a third of their lineup was average
at best. In baseball, you're in very good shape when your worst
regulars are average major-league performers or close to it. (This, by
the way, is one of the cases where park adjustments would have made a
difference in the rankings, since Safeco Field lowered batting averages
by 16 points and scoring by 11 percent.)
A few other things that jumped out at me:
Seattle's success was due in part to their tremendous pinch hitting.
Their substitute batsmen contributed a .286 average, a .371 on-base percentage,
and 15 extra-base hits for an .871 OPS. Surprisingly, the Orioles led
the league a pinch .297 batting average and .398 on-base percentage. They
fell behind the M's in OPS only because they contributed only three extra-base
hits off the bench. The Red Sox were woeful in this category -- a .147
average and a 5:1 strikeout to walk ratio. If memory serves, Boston didn't
get its first pinch hit of the season until early June.
Boston's infield was pathetic, with no position finishing in the top
ten. That's tough to do in a 14-team league. If not for Mike Sweeney at
first, Kansas City would have challenged the Red Sox for this dubious
distinction.
Anaheim was last at both 1B and DH. Mo Vaughn would have looked good
in either role.
If you're looking for balance, check out the Twins and the White Sox.
Minnesota was in the top nine across the board, including pitcher and
pinch hitter. Meanwhile, the White Sox received good contributions from
every position except DH, and if Frank Thomas had been healthy (and happy)
all year, they would have been in the top 8 at every position. And the
Rangers were in good shape everywhere but RF, so it's no surprise that
many writers have speculated about Texas making a run at re-signing Juan
Gonzalez this winter.
A couple of years ago, Omar Vizquel was an asset for Cleveland at the
plate, but he "helped" the Indians sink to the basement in SS
hitting this year.
Tampa Bay was in the bottom half at every position except left field,
and they only have an aging Greg Vaughn to thank for that. Vaughn was
the DH more often than he was in left, but he did his best work while
playing in the outfield -- .900 OPS in 200 atbats as a LF, .674 in 283
atbats at DH.
National League rankings
Over in the National League, the picture looks like this:
Team P C 1B 2B 3B SS LF CF RF DH PH
ARI 11 11 5 8 12 9 2 10 8 2 1
ATL 14 6 15 12 1 13 16 8 9 8 5
CHN 4 14 8 11 10 6 9 14 1 5 3
CIN 9 8 7 14 6 11 8 3 13 3 7
COL 1 4 1 4 7 2 10 4 2 10 13
FLO 13 3 9 13 8 8 4 7 11 6 15
HOU 15 12 2 3 11 7 5 2 7 7 6
LAN 7 2 12 10 13 14 3 13 3 9 12
MIL 12 9 3 5 14 5 12 5 10 16 14
MON 5 13 10 2 16 4 15 16 6 14 16
NYN 16 1 13 9 9 12 13 11 16 1 8
PHI 3 15 11 7 4 3 11 15 4 13 4
PIT 10 7 16 16 3 16 6 9 15 4 11
SDN 6 5 4 15 2 15 14 6 14 15 9
SFN 2 10 14 1 15 1 1 12 12 11 2
SLN 8 16 6 6 5 10 7 1 5 12 10
Some observations:
The world-champion Diamondbacks didn't exactly tear it up offensively.
They didn't get much from their catchers, third basemen (Matt Williams'
injury was a factor here), or center fielders. And this was in a good
hitter's park. Luis Gonzalez was the only starter who got his team into
the top four at his position. Arizona's pinch hitters got a lot of ink
this year because they belted 14 homers. They also led the league in OPS,
but they didn't lead the majors in that category, as Seattle's was higher
by 37 points (.871 to .834).
Andruw Jones is regarded as a great young talent and was recently rewarded
with a $75 million contract extension, but seven other teams got more
offensive production from their center fielders this year. Jones is, of
course, a superior defensive player, but he's yet to take his place in
the top tier offensively.
Surprisingly, the Florida Marlins were among the most balanced teams.
With Luis Castillo having an off year, they finished only 13th at second
base, and they didn't get a whole lot out of right field. But Derrek Lee
bounced back from a very slow start to help the Florida first-sackers
finish ninth, and every other field position was in the top half of the
league. One could easily imagine Lee and Castillo rebounding to create
a team with a very solid offense from top to bottom in 2002.
On the other end of the balance continuum is a team at the other end
of the country, the Giants. Thanks to Barry Bonds, Jeff Kent, and Rich
Aurilia, San Francisco led the league at three positions. But their stars
didn't get anywhere near enough help, and the club finished in the bottom
five at five other positions. And to think that some opposing managers
were criticized for not pitching to Barry.
Ken Griffey was playing on one leg for much of the season, and while
it definitely hurt him defensively, he still led his team to a third-place
finish in the offensive rankings at his position. When Griffey wasn't
playing CF, Michael Tucker did a nice job (.869 OPS) and Ruben Rivera
was okay. Adam Dunn arrived on the scene too late to salvage a decent
ranking for the team at the corner outfield positions.
You can't see this in the table, but the Astros had five positions -- first, second, and all three outfield spots -- where the team compiled
an on-base percentage in the .380s and .390s. That's very impressive,
even in Enron Field, because Enron boosts scoring by producing more triples
and homers, but it doesn't affect batting averages very much.
The Dodgers were 10th or worse at all four infield positions. With
Eric Karros nursing a bad back and Adrian Beltre missing a lot of time
due to abdominal surgery, it's no surprise that the corner positions suffered.
But the shortstops were horrible (offensively) and Mark Grudzielanek was
respectable at second but still in the bottom half.
Amid contraction rumors, fans in Pittsburgh and other places may be
salivating over the possibility of getting Vladimir Guerrero via free
agency or a dispersal draft of some sort. And I'd love to have him, too.
But it's worth pointing out that five other NL teams (plus two in the
AL) got more production from their right fielders than Montreal did this
year.
Yes, the Mets' outfield really was as bad as everyone thought it would
be. More surprising is the fact that their infield didn't make up for
it, with all four positions falling in the bottom half. I would have figured
that at least one guy from the group of Robin Ventura, Edgardo Alfonzo,
and Todd Ziele would have made it into the top eight, but it didn't happen.
In what might be an omen for the future, the Mets got more out of the
DH position than any other team in the majors. Because the Mets play in
a non-DH league, their ranking at the position is based on a very limited
number of at-bats, so it's not all that meaningful. But most of those at-bats
went to a guy named Mike Piazza, and it's not hard to imagine Mr. Piazza
catching for a few more years and then finishing out his career as a DH.
Major league rankings
I'll wrap up by ranking all thirty teams in one group:
Team P C 1B 2B 3B SS LF CF RF DH PH
ANA 4 24 25 17 3 11 14 24 21 28 12
BAL 24 29 11 26 27 19 25 22 30 22 4
BOS 8 4 17 22 28 22 9 5 19 3 30
CHA 26 16 13 7 19 6 12 16 7 21 27
CLE 22 17 3 2 20 26 19 20 4 4 8
DET 29 20 22 21 17 9 13 21 29 15 16
KCA 21 25 6 30 29 25 28 4 20 20 24
MIN 1 9 14 19 7 10 21 13 23 13 6
NYA 30 5 21 15 14 3 30 3 24 23 7
OAK 28 13 2 18 6 4 29 19 16 17 26
SEA 25 15 10 1 21 17 27 11 12 2 1
TBA 16 23 16 20 26 23 15 30 25 19 23
TEX 10 3 12 10 16 1 18 8 26 6 19
TOR 2 30 5 27 24 18 8 12 17 16 10
ARI 17 19 9 12 18 16 2 18 10 5 2
ATL 20 10 29 23 1 27 26 15 11 12 11
CHN 7 26 19 16 13 13 11 27 1 9 5
CIN 14 12 18 25 9 21 10 6 18 7 14
COL 3 7 1 6 10 5 16 7 2 18 22
FLO 19 6 20 24 11 15 4 14 14 10 28
HOU 23 21 4 5 15 14 5 2 9 11 13
LAN 12 2 26 14 22 28 3 26 3 14 21
MIL 18 14 7 8 23 12 20 9 13 30 25
MON 9 22 23 4 30 8 24 29 8 27 29
NYN 27 1 27 13 12 24 22 23 28 1 15
PHI 6 27 24 11 5 7 17 28 5 26 9
PIT 15 11 30 29 4 30 6 17 27 8 20
SDN 11 8 8 28 2 29 23 10 22 29 17
SFN 5 18 28 3 25 2 1 25 15 24 3
SLN 13 28 15 9 8 20 7 1 6 25 18
Obviously, the rankings at pitcher and designated hitter don't mean too
much on a cross-league basis because of the differences in the number
of plate appearances at these positions. I was tempted to leave those
positions out of this table, but decided to keep them because they have
at least some curiosity value.
Though it won't come as a surprise to anyone, I'll finish with a list
of the guys who were most responsible for putting their teams at the top
of the rankings at each position, leaving out the AL pitchers and the
NL designated hitters.
Pos Team Player(s)
P Col Mike Hampton
C NYN Mike Piazza
1B Col Todd Helton
2B Sea Bret Boone
3B Atl Chipper Jones
SS Tex Alex Rodriguez
LF SF Barry Bonds
CF SL Jim Edmonds
RF ChN Sammy Sosa
DH Sea Edgar Martinez
PH Sea Mark McLemore, Ed Sprague, and several others
| |
|