Keyword
MLB
Scores
Schedule
Pitching Probables
Standings
Statistics
Transactions
Injuries
Players
Free Agents
Offseason Moves
Message Board
Minor Leagues
MLB en espanol
CLUBHOUSE


THE ROSTER
Peter Gammons
Rob Neyer
Jayson Stark
Jim Caple
John Sickels
SHOP@ESPN.COM
NikeTown
TeamStore
ESPN Auctions
SPORT SECTIONS
Tuesday, January 15
 
Users: Braves outfield impressive, but not best

ESPN.com

Gary Sheffield
Sheffield

A.Jones
A. Jones

C.Jones
C. Jones

Chipper Jones in left, Andruw Jones in center, Gary Sheffield in right. Yes, the Braves will trot out a star-studded outfield in 2002. But is it the best in baseball?

We asked ESPN.com users for your thoughts and boy, did you give 'em to us. Put it this way: There pretty much wasn't an outfield trio that didn't get at least some support.

But while a lot of users admitted that the Braves' outfield is now made up of three All-Star caliber players, many fans -- especially those of the Red Sox, Cardinals and Cubs -- weren't about to anoint Jones-Jones-Sheffield as the best just yet.

Here is a sampling of your responses:


Without a doubt the greatest outfield of the modern era was just assembled. Hats off to the Braves organization for pulling (off) this deal. The only question about this outfield is the defensive abilties of Chipper in left field.

Chris Dread
Toronto, Ontario


An All-Star outfield -- every game of the year! ... Too bad the Braves infield is only mediocre on a good day -- otherwise, with this outfield and their vaunted staff, they could run away with the league.

David Renner
Columbus, Ohio

“ The New York Mets' outfield of Jay Payton, Benny Agbayani, and Roger Cedeno is by far the best outfield in baseball. Best at what? I have no idea. ”
— Will Amos,
Houston


The best outfield in Major League Baseball today belongs to the Boston Red Sox: Manny Ramirez in left field, Johnny Damon in center and Trot Nixon in right. They have the perfect mix of speed, defense and offense. This is the best outfield the Sox have fielded since the days of Jim Rice, Dwight Evans and Fred Lynn.

John DeFelice
Reno, Nev.


I think the Cubs have the best outfield in baseball when you consider all five tools. (Corey) Patterson is excellent defensively, and is nearly as good as A. Jones but without the flash. (Moises) Alou and (Sammy) Sosa are proven capable outfielders, while C. Jones is an unknown and may become a defensive liability.

Brian Schwartz
Story City, Iowa


How about (Shannon) Stewart, (Jose) Cruz, (Raul) Mondesi? You have the best leadoff hitter in the game, the only 30/30 man in the AL, and Mondesi with one of the best arms in the game.

Mohamed Chams
London, Ontario


Let's not forget the Angels' outfield: Garret Anderson in left, Darin Erstad in center, Tim Salmon in right. ... Remember this is an outfield that found Edmonds expendable.

Greg Contreras
Redondo Beach, Calif.


I choose Seattle. Three great players, no head-cases, and Ichiro is the best in the league.

Michael Beauchamp
Charlestown, R.I.


While I am biased, anyone would be hard-pressed to challenge the idea that the new Braves' outfield is the best in baseball. Assuming Andruw Jones reaches his potential offensively, we are looking at a combined outfield production of .320, 130, 330. ... In Chicago, Patterson isn't ready. In St. Louis, (Placido) Polanco lacks consistent power. And in Seattle, (Ruben) Sierra needs to retire and (Mike) Cameron is no Andruw Jones. I rest my case.

Spencer Hubbard
Decatur, Ga.

“ Chipper, Andruw Jones, and Sheffield a great outfield? Well, Andruw will be great in center. Chipper needs some experience out in left. And Sheffield, in a new clubhouse? Let's give them some time and see. As far as I am concerned, I hope Andruw plays a lot of left-center field, if you know what I mean. ”
— Richard Spanier,
Atlanta


Barry Bonds, Reggie Sanders and anybody else!

Stefan Podell
San Francisco


Offensively, is there a better outfield of the Texas Rangers? (Juan) Gonzalez, (Carl) Everett and (Rusty) Greer all can hit for average and power. They may be the slowest and (most) defensively challenged outfield, but offensively nobody can touch them.

Bill Laurence
Austin, Texas


Alou-Patterson-Sosa. Name one attribute that you need that this group doesn't have. You can't.

Dan Wagner
Irving, Texas


Yeah, the Braves' outfield is OK. But does it really compare to the Red Sox trio of Manny Ramirez, Johnny Damon, and Trot Nixon? Heck no. The Braves have a couple of bashers, but Nixon and Damon are five-tool players to complement the slugger Ramirez. They may play the 7, 8 ,9 positions, but they are ideal for the 1, 2, and 3 spots in anybody's lineup.

Jim Wulfson
Brookline, Mass.


Sierra/McLemore, Cameron, Ichiro. Two current All-Stars, an MVP, and a former All-Star. Put Cammy in left-center, Ichiro in right-center and play five infielders with McLemore in the middle.

Jeff Jager
Seattle


Are we talking offense or defense here? Chipper Jones in left? It remains to be seen if he can even play that position. Sierra in left? Patterson in center? Give me a break. Why not mention the Giants' new outfield -- Bonds-Shinjo-Sanders? A lot less question marks than those you threw up there.

Mark Wasacz
San Francisco

“ I would definitely say St. Louis still has the best outfield in the major leagues. With players like Edmonds, Drew and Polanco, they give you the most complete outfield offensively and defensively. The Braves' outfield looks great on paper, but their numbers are great at the plate and not on the field. ”
— Dan Kellner,
Monroe Township, N.J.


Any three players the Yankees put out there become the best outfield!

Zach Riedl
Rochester, N.Y.


In two years, the outfield people will be talking about: the Astros ... (Richard) Hidalgo, (Lance) Berkman and (Daryl) Ward.

Fred Larivee
Wyckoff, N.J.


Mark it down. The superstar outfield of the future will be Ken Griffey Jr., Adam Dunn and Austin Kearns. The Big Red Machine will be reborn starting in 2003!

Mike Baum
Columbus, Ohio


Who cares about the best outfield? No one can hold a candle to the infield of Piazza, Vaughn, Alomar, Ordoņez, Alfonzo.

Doug Rowan
New York, N.Y.



 More from ESPN...
Dodgers trade Sheffield to Braves for Jordan, pitcher Perez
Braves acquire Gary Sheffield ...

Neyer: Sheffield trade analysis
Atlanta added a much-needed ...

 ESPN Tools
Email story
 
Most sent
 
Print story