Spring Training

Jayson Stark

Keyword
MLB
Scores
Schedule
Pitching Probables
Standings
Statistics
Transactions
Injuries
Players
Free Agents
Offseason Moves
All-Time Stats
Message Board
Minor Leagues
MLB en espanol
CLUBHOUSE


THE ROSTER
Peter Gammons
Rob Neyer
Jayson Stark
Jim Caple
John Sickels
SHOP@ESPN.COM
TeamStore
ESPN Auctions
SPORT SECTIONS
Monday, March 4
 
Reds offer their side of the story

By Jayson Stark
ESPN.com

SARASOTA, Fla. -- If you just sat back from afar and watched the headlines flying by last week, you might have thought the Cincinnati Reds were America's most dysfunctional family since Malcolm in the Middle.

Among the descriptions three former Reds gave of their old team last week were these:

No leadership. No chemistry. Different rules for different players. Management that looked the other way. And an unhappy superstar named Griffey who divided this team more than he led it.

Ken Griffey Jr.
Junior and the Reds are looking for better results this season.

So you might figure that when the Reds were finished digesting all that, they were just relieved nobody called them al Qaeda sympathizers. It's a funny thing, though. The Cincinnati Reds who haven't left, the ones who still wander the fields around Ed Smith Stadium, sure don't look or sound like the Team in Turmoil they've been portrayed as being.

Just listen to the current Reds talk about themselves:

  • From the manager, Bob Boone: "This is a real together team. Obviously, the people who aren't around it certainly are going to listen to all the things being said and maybe have different opinions. But I really don't care about that. ... The attitude and the chemistry and the togetherness, I'm very satisfied. No problems at all. It's almost a little scary."

  • From first baseman Sean Casey: "The atmosphere here is great. It really is. We have a great group of guys, and it's funny because you hear so many negative things being said. But if you bring anybody here to be a fly on the wall in that clubhouse, you'd leave saying, 'That's one of the best clubhouses in the big leagues.'"

    So let's see now. Either this is one of the best clubhouses in the big leagues, or it's a clubhouse splintered into disastrous cliques. Either this group is tighter than Britney Spears' leotards, or it's a group that should give spin-doctor lessons to Enron.

    You decide. But how do you decide? It isn't easy. In one corner, you have former Reds coach Ron Oester and two former players, Pokey Reese and Dmitri Young, firing away. In the other, you have the current Reds, either trying to diffuse this "controversy" or ignore it.

    It has become a classic example of a modern American story that continues to feed on itself -- at least until the rest of the world tires of it and moves on.

    "People are going to write, people are going to say, people are going to dig, people are going to ask questions," Boone said. "This story can stay alive as long as the media really wants it to stay alive, and we have no control over that. All we have control over is the team of 2002 and what we're all about."

    And all we have control over here at ESPN.com is our obligation to inform you folks out in cyberspace by separating the sirloin from the baloney as best we can. So after our visit to Reds camp, we figured the best thing we could do was try to address the biggest of these issues, one by one.

    Chemistry class
    Chemistry is a funny thing. You can't plan it. You can't trade for it. It happens, or it doesn't. No one claims the Reds were a euphoric bunch of people last year. But they also lost 96 games.

    So if they had chemistry problems, were they typical of teams worn down by losing, or were they something more?

  • The point: "When the Reds stretch," Oester told ESPN, "you've got two or three guys over here, you've got three or four guys over here, you've got four or five guys over here. There's groups. There's cliques. I think every team has that. Everyone has cliques. But I think it showed more on the Reds because there were some people not too happy with other people, with other teammates on that team doing what they did instead of doing things as a team."

  • The counterpoint: "Yeah, there are cliques," said pitcher Scott Williamson. "There are going to be cliques everywhere you go. I mean, there were cliques in '99, when we won 96 games. I don't think that has anything to do with losing, though. ... We had cliques, but I think that's true in life. Don't you? Everyone has their own little cliques. ... I don't see anything wrong with it. As long as when you go out on the field, I don't see any cliques on the field when we play."

    “ I've got the people here I want. If you're going to ask about that stuff, the people that are talking aren't here. Are they? ”
    — Bob Boone,
    Reds manager

    But Reese (now a Pirate) and Young (now a Tiger) suggested those cliques weren't normal cliques, that they date back to the arrival of Junior Griffey two years ago.

    "It's 25 of us, not one," Reese told Cincinnati Enquirer columnist Tim Sullivan. "I know he's Ken Griffey Jr., but somebody should have said, 'We're all in this together.'"

    "Once Junior got there, the team broke off into cliques," Young told Booth Newspapers' Tigers beat man, Danny Knobler. "There were the guys who basically kissed his butt, and then the guys who didn't care about the materialistic stuff."

    But Casey dismissed all this talk as a simple case of people looking for excuses.

    "I think whenever you lose, whenever you lose 96 games, it makes for a long year," Casey said. "And when that happens, you start looking for reasons: 'Well, there were cliques, there was this, there was that.' The bottom line is, we didn't win. ...

    "We had a lot of injuries. We had a young staff. I don't think we had the starting lineup we were supposed to have but about four or five (games) the whole year. That makes for 96 losses, not ... cliques in the clubhouse. You can make all the excuses you want to make, but we just didn't win last year. That's all it comes down to."

    This makes for fascinating talk. But the fact is, it's talk about last year. Asked if he felt he needed to address any of last year's left-over issues with this year's team, Boone answered with a succinct: "No."

    But he did add, very noticeably: "I've got the people here I want. If you're going to ask about that stuff, the people that are talking aren't here. Are they?"

    The Griffey rules
    It wasn't so long ago that Junior Griffey was a Jordanesque figure -- the game's most magnetic player, the smiling face of baseball's future. But that seems like a millennium ago now. (Hey wait, it was a millennium ago.)

    Today -- in part through his own brooding, in part because of injuries, death threats and tales told by his detractors -- Griffey has morphed, sadly, into a puzzling, beleaguered and increasingly private star who wears his unhappiness where he once wore his still-golden smile.

    Ken Griffey Jr.
    Center Field
    Cincinnati Reds
    Profile
    2001 SEASON STATISTICS
    GM HR RBI R SB AVG
    111 22 65 57 2 .286

    Let's just say that nothing in the words of Oester, Reese or Young last week did anything to alter that portrait.

    "Junior Griffey, when I used to see him in Seattle, he was always having fun," Oester said. "He always had a smile on his face out in center field. Somehow, that got lost. I don't know what happened. I don't know if it was the pressure of coming over to his hometown and playing. I don't know if it was his injury last year, but I think he lost his love for playing the game a little bit. He's a great guy. You talk to him, and he's a super guy (but) he's very sensitive. He's a very, very sensitive person."

    Griffey also seems to have trouble communicating his true thoughts to the public and to those around him. Even when he kids around, Young said, his teammates sometimes take it the wrong way.

    "You've got your accomplishments, and that's good," Young said. "But he'll throw them in your face. You sit here and joke around, and he'll go, 'How many home runs have you got? How much money do you make?' I didn't know it was about that."

    Griffey isn't speaking to ESPN. But he told an entourage of New York reporters last week that he isn't the selfish troublemaker he's being made out to be. If he was, why would he have offered to redo his contract to help the Reds sign Young and Reese?

    "I'm only getting paid on 57 percent of my contract because I've deferred the rest," Griffey said. "And I've offered to defer more. If I wasn't a team guy, I would have asked for my money up front and not deferred anything. If you're going to be honest, you'd have to say, 'He's done everything a team guy could do.' But I'm a bad guy? That doesn't make any sense. I can't worry about it."

    But Oester, who constantly professed his affection for Griffey, said Junior doesn't even realize he sometimes does things that rub his teammates the wrong way.

    "Junior just needs to associate himself with the team a little bit more," Oester said. "In the clubhouse, he's fine as far as kidding around and talking. But things out on the field like stretching, I don't think he's ever had to be in a stretch with a team before. And I think that needs to happen on a team. I think the more you do things together as a team, the more you're going to feel like a team, and have fun with the guys that are on your team. And Junior just wasn't used to that.

    "I don't blame Junior ... but I think he's learned. I think you need to go to Junior and say, 'I need you on the field for stretches. Whether you stretch or not, it doesn't matter. You know how to get yourself ready for a game. But just be out there with the guys and stay around after you hit and shag with the guys, with the team.' I think (if they'd done that) everything would have been OK."

    But Boone's response is also hard to disagree with.

    "First of all, some of the guys who are talking you should check out and see what their attendance record was," the manager said, clearly referring to Young and Reese. "But that's irrelevant. I mean, Junior wasn't there for some stretches, but what a lot of people didn't know was that he had special issues with his hamstring. He did a lot of his (rehabbing) when we were on the field stretching. He was working in the training room with a physical therapist. My concern is how do you get everybody ready to play the games? Junior's ready to play the game every day."

    But Boone also says: "You know, unless you walk in Junior's shoes, I don't think you really (ought to) criticize him. He lives a little different life, with all the attention that's on him. What I know about Junior is that he's the ultimate gamer. He played through a lot of things last year that normal people wouldn't play through, that people don't know about. ... The only thing we really care about is when the bell rings and it's time to go out and play. That's what's important, and he does that to the max."

    Sharpen your axes
    Two winters ago, Ron Oester was offered the Reds' managerial job -- but asked for more money in what he thought was the beginning of a simple contract negotiation. Instead, the Reds turned around and offered the job to Boone, then kept an unhappy Oester around as part of Boone's coaching staff.

    It was a mix that didn't work, that couldn't work. Oester was fired after the season and took a job as a minor-league instructor with the Phillies. Now, it's no surprise that he has serious issues with the management back in Cincinnati.

    "When I said the other day in the paper that it wasn't one or two guys they were going to have to get rid of, that it was going to take six or seven and clean house and a big broom, I didn't mean the players," Oester told ESPN. "What I meant was from the top on down, from the front office on down.

    "They've got some guys over there that just worry about their jobs, just worry about themselves, that are not worried about what it takes to win. They're 'yes men.' ... I think over there, it's just everybody's trying to cover their rear end. It's a joke."

    Reds GM Jim Bowden declined an invitation to address those charges. But without responding directly to Oester, Boone raised questions about the credibility of all three of the Reds' critics -- all of whom had reasons to be angry with their former team.

    "I dare say you could go to probably any business in the country -- and certainly any sports franchise -- and if you want to go get ex-, disgruntled employees to talk about the company, it's not too tough," Boone said. "For us, I've got the people here I want, coaching-wise and playing-wise. And the fact is, the attitude and the chemistry here is phenomenal -- maybe one of the best I've ever been on.

    "So for us," the manager said, "it's really water off a duck's back ... I'd just consider the source. I know who we kept and I know who we didn't keep -- so you figure it out."

    It isn't tough to figure out the people he's referring to. It's trickier trying to figure out who is right and wrong. But ultimately, once this story goes the way of Monica-gate, that won't be the Reds' job. Their job is finding a way to get past this soap opera and play.

    Fascinatingly, Boone thinks this experience could help them more than it hurts.

    "This is a very together team," the manager said again. "And you're going to see how together it is -- because all of the allegations, all of the supposed crises here, it's laughable to us in the clubhouse. I mean, it's laughabele. This is a very together team. If anything, it's going to bring us closer together."

    Hmmm. If it does, think the Reds will vote Reese, Young and Oester a World Series share?

    Jayson Stark is a Senior Writer at ESPN.com.





  •  More from ESPN...
    Reese stands by Griffey comments
    Pokey Reese was surprised by ...

    Griffey says he just wants to 'fit in'
    Ken Griffey Jr. is stung by ...

    Oester has strong words for Griffey, Larkin
    Ken Griffey Jr.'s habit of ...

    Pokey rips Griffey: Junior hurt team chemistry
    Infielder Pokey Reese thinks ...

    Spring Training coverage

    Jayson Stark archive

     ESPN Tools
    Email story
     
    Most sent
     
    Print story