National Notebook

NBA
Scores
Schedule
Standings
Statistics
Transactions
Depth Charts
Injuries
Players
Message Board
NBA en espanol
FEATURES
Daily Glance
Power Rankings
NBA Insider


CLUBHOUSE


ESPN MALL
TeamStore
ESPN Auctions
SPORT SECTIONS
Tuesday, January 29
Updated: February 8, 3:24 PM ET
 
Brand among those dissed for wrong reason

By Marc Stein
Special to ESPN.com

Sometimes, those all-knowing coaches don't do any better than the supposedly know-nothing fans.
Elton Brand
Webber and Brand were joined together on this play, and now in All-Star selections.

Check the box marked TUESDAY as one of those times.

That's the day Western Conference coaches made a mistake no less egregious than anything the world's populace did in fan balloting. They selected Chris Webber as a Western Conference reserve, over poor Elton Brand.

Wrong answer.

You read right. Chris Webber should not be on Don Nelson's bench, much as we want to see Chris Webber on Don Nelson's bench -- because scribes everywhere generally welcome stories that write themselves. But not this one. At the risk of taking some fun out of what isn't supposed to be a life-or-death game, Webber shouldn't be gorging on cheesesteaks any more than the fans' ill-advised choice at starting guard: Steve Francis.

Injuries, people. Injuries. You have to factor in games missed when making these picks, whether you're a fan or a coach. At least you should factor health in, if you're a responsible voter.

Because the numbers, as they say, don't fib. Sacramento's Webber has missed more than half of his team's games: 23 of 43. Houston's Francis has missed almost that many: 19 of 44. That's why these two, both unquestioned All-Stars if talent was the sole consideration, should have been omitted. Doesn't matter that both can claim a place among the league's top 20 names without debate.

Webber has indeed been a monster lately, powering the Kings on a tidy 13-1 surge after missing the first 20 games with that nasty ankle sprain. Better without Webber? As Rick Adelman says: "Ridiculous. The guy is All-Pro. C'mon." Sacramento was thrilled to start the season 15-5 sans CWebb but knows it has to have him playing this way to have any real chance of unseating the Lakers.

Fact remains, though, that Webber has missed more games than he has played. Brand has missed zero games with the Clippers and has asserted himself as yet another legit power forward in the conference that already had Webber, Tim Duncan, Kevin Garnett, Dirk Nowitzki, Karl Malone and Rasheed Wallace. At a mere 6-8, Brand leads the league in offensive rebounds per game (4.3) and averages 18 and 11 overall.

The only solace is that Brand is the only clear-cut victim.

Francis, like Webber, can't really be considered an All-Star this term after missing nearly half of Houston's schedule -- much as the wondrous Stevie, one of our faves, deserves a sympathy vote for gutting through these scary migraines. But at least Francis' presence in Philly won't be excluding anyone too worthy.

Szczerbiak
Szczerbiak

Minnesota's Wally Szczerbiak got in anyway, giving the deserving T-Wolves two All-Stars. Dallas' Steve Nash and Seattle's Gary Payton were also no-brainer picks unaffected by Francis' starter status. The other leading guards -- Denver's Nick Van Exel and Phoenix's Stephon Marbury -- have caused too many problems to merit a spot, with their trade demands and/or punches at shootaround. While Utah's John Stockton is another sensible backcourt contender, Mailman did make the roster to carry the senior citizens' torch. And since the Kings deserve two All-Stars no less than the Mavs or Wolves, we'll concede that Webber isn't all the way out of order a reserve pick alongside Predrag Stojakovic. Vlade Divac is probably Sacramento's only other viable candidate, but West coaches made a very fine distinction by tabbing Nowitzki as the West's backup center -- since Nowitzki has played more five than four this season.

In the name of equality, we apply the same Webber/Francis injury stance to the Leastern Conference. Milwaukee's Glenn Robinson and Washington's Richard Hamilton were looking like certain All-Stars around Christmas. Yet they have also since missed huge chunks of the schedule because of groin afflictions. So we scratch Dog and Rip, just as we do with another Westie who usually makes it: Dallas' Michael Finley, also felled by hammy issues.

Add up all of the above and, from here, Joe Public didn't do too badly. Jason Kidd should be starting in the East, of course, and Dikembe Mutombo wouldn't beat out Jermaine O'Neal or Alonzo Mourning on our ballot, but there are no blatant Florida election travesties like we had last February. Remember when Miami's Mourning and Orlando's Grant Hill were voted in as starters a year ago, having combined to play four games?

This time, the long-term injury victims who've barely played -- Denver's Antonio McDyess, Charlotte's Jamal Mashburn and Hill -- were wisely bypassed by the fans. Maybe we don't give the voters sufficient credit. Maybe we give the coaches too much.

Or maybe we'll shut up now and thank the coaches for this mistake. Nellie, after all, has already started writing those reunion stories for us. Seems that he's looking forward to CWebb's presence as much as the grubby scribes are.

"It's going to be fun to see my old buddy Chris Webber," the beaming West coach says. "I'll get a chance to coach him under different circumstances."

Doesn't have to be the right circumstances to make for good copy.

Around The League

  • In selecting seven reserves, coaches in each conference were required to pick two forwards, two guards and one center. The difference this season: Teams were recently notified by league memo that they could be flexible with players they considered to be multi-position guys. Prime examples: Nowitzki, listed as a forward, could be chosen by the coaches as a West center since he has played so much five. Paul Pierce, listed as a guard, was likewise eligible as an East forward. The measure helped ensure that the best available players filled out the East and West rosters -- as opposed to, say, West coaches being forced to pick Divac or David Robinson as a backup to Shaquille O'Neal just because they were listed on the All-Star ballot as true centers.

    Davis
    Davis

  • Lots of us were wrong about what No. 23 could do at 38. At the 41-game pole, Michael Jordan's playoff fantasy is still quite real -- and now Richard Hamilton is coming back from injury. Just don't forget, amid all the told-you-sos to us hacks, that Jordan and the Wiz were also wrong in November. Washington thought Jordan could win without Hubert Davis, and it's Davis -- next in line after MJ, granted -- who has helped keep the Wiz from crumbling with Rip sidelined. Davis was so far out of favor when the season began that North Carolina legend Dean Smith considered buzzing Jordan to remind the world's most famous Tar Heel (even if Mike was no longer in management) that Davis is one of his one.

    Reminders are no longer needed with Davis sporting a solid 8-8 record as a starter and moving up to fifth in the league in 3-point percentage at .457. The Wiz was 2-6 before Davis was recalled from injury-list exile and finally taken off the trading block. If Jordan can continue his playoff march over the next 41 games, with this team, it might be the most amazing achievement yet in his glittering career. But a crucial boost for His Airness, maybe more than the satisfaction of force-feeding crow to all of us, is knowing now that Davis can be a big help, even when Davis shifts back to backup duty to accommodate Rip's return.

  • It's no coincidence Memphis ended its seven-game losing skid Monday night. Jason Williams sat out with two ingrown toenails and Le Grizz, rid of the guy who has been dragging them down lately, heaped more road misery on Brand and Alvin Gentry. The draft-day trade for Pau Gasol looks better than anyone envisioned, even with Shareef Abdur-Rahim's surprise inclusion on the East's All-Star roster, so the Grizz get kudos for that bold move. But it's clear that they worsened the Mike Bibby-for-Williams ticket ploy by signing JWill to that $43-million contract extension before the season. With all that cheddar, Williams' motivation appears to be gone -- and has been since his "We suck" diatribe. The Grizz won three games after that, but had been backsliding badly ... and largely because of Williams. It was hard to choose last week's low point: Losing by 38 to Portland or by three to Chicago. Rookie of the Year favorite Gasol, Shane Battier and Sidney Lowe deserve better from JWill for their grit in the face of long-term injuries to Lorenzen Wright and Michael Dickerson.

    Marc Stein, who covers the NBA for The Dallas Morning News, is a regular contributor to ESPN.com.





  •  More from ESPN...
    Pierce, Nowitzki, Mourning among All-Star reserves
    Paul Pierce of the Boston ...

    Carter upstages Shaq, MJ in All-Star voting
    Vince Carter was the leading ...

    May: Logical choices for reserves
    From Payton to Jermaine to ...

    Aldridge: While waiting for all-star reserves...
    Picking the other all-stars ...

    Marc Stein Archive



     ESPN Tools
    Email story
     
    Most sent
     
    Print story
     
    Daily email