Marc Stein

NBA
Scores
Schedule
Standings
Statistics
Transactions
Depth Charts
Injuries
Players
Message Board
NBA en espanol
FEATURES
Daily Glance
Power Rankings
NBA Insider


CLUBHOUSE


ESPN MALL
TeamStore
ESPN Auctions
SPORT SECTIONS
Monday, January 13
 
One man's electronic All-Star ballot

By Marc Stein
ESPN.com

Editor's note: As part of "The Stein Line" every Monday, ESPN.com senior NBA writer Marc Stein takes you around the league for the latest news in "Coast to Coast."

All-Star balloting ended Sunday, and the guess here is that at least a few souls out there still like to fill out their punch cards without regard to fan allegiances. Meaning that some folks vote for the players whose play deserves it most, just to be snobbish.

How might one of those ballots look?

Jamal Mashburn
Jamal Mashburn deserves to start at forward for the East, not Vince Carter.
Haven't turned one in since college, after graduating to the media industry full-time, but this is how our ballot would have looked, adhering to the strictest of voting standards and going by the positions as they're listed.

  • East starters: Jason Kidd and Tracy McGrady at guard; Jermaine O'Neal and Jamal Mashburn at forward; Ben Wallace at center.

  • West starters: Steve Francis and Kobe Bryant at guard; Dirk Nowitzki and Kevin Garnett at forward; Shaquille O'Neal at center.

  • East rationale: Vince Carter made an offseason trip to China, so those Mandarin ballots clearly aren't just helping Yao Ming. In spite of all the bashing, Carter also still has lots of fans in Toronto who haven't forgotten his loyalty to the NBA's future in Canada by signing a long-term contract extension. So maybe it isn't surprising that Carter ranks No. 1 in fan voting, and it is the fans' game. No outrage, then.

    Discerning voters, however, would never go for a guy who has played 10 games all season, so there is no room for Vinsanity here. Or for Grant Hill, who has (gingerly) appeared in 27 games.

    The forward spots go instead to O'Neal and Mashburn; Jermaine for bouncing back as a 20-and-10 guy after a rough World Championships, and Mashburn for rebounding from a serious illness to carry his suddenly Baron Davis-less club. Kidd and McGrady are no-brainers at guard, although it would have made things easier if T-Mac appeared on the ballot as a forward. Wallace, likewise, has to be the center, even though he's really a forward as well.

    Next up, for coaches and media gnats who like to interject their own picks, is sorting out the East jumble at guard. To fill out the rosters, coaches are required to pick two recognized guards, two forwards and a center -- with two wild-card picks without regard to position. Safe to say guards are bound to fill those extra spots with so many big names vying for props, love and respect.

    Listed at guard on the ballot, and listed alphabetically, are these contenders in the coach vote: Ray Allen, Baron Davis, Ricky Davis, Richard Hamilton, Allan Houston, Allen Iverson, Eddie Jones, Paul Pierce, Jalen Rose and Jerry Stackhouse. That list doesn't even include the legendary Michael Jordan, who'll either need a league exemption or a late rush in fan balloting to beat out all those lads, and ballot omission Ron Artest.

  • West rationale: The choices ain't easy at any of the positions. Stephon Marbury, Steve Nash and Gary Payton (in spite of the Sonics' slump) are all feasible starters at guard, but Francis and Bryant have done just enough to nick those spots with us.

    The choices are toughest at forward, where you have to nit-pick about free-throw shooting to find justification for settling on Nowitzki and Garnett over Tim Duncan and Chris Webber. The Kings deserve a starter, but the Mavericks do, too, possessing the league's best record. So it's Nowitzki edging past Webber and Garnett holding off Duncan, since KG gets even less help on a nightly basis than TD.

    At center, there will be no loud quarrel here when Yao is elected, since he has been productive and durable in the face of unyielding scrutiny and without a break from basketball since, like, 1999. Plus, he actually got a taunting technical last week, to our delight. But Shaq is still Shaq, and Shaq has played two-thirds of the Lakers' games. Enough, in other words, to average 27-and-11 with little lift and extra heft because of that recovering big toe.

    The reserves? The coaches don't have to turn in their picks for a couple of more weeks, and we'll hold off, too. That way we'll be working from the same list they are, after the starters are announced Jan. 23, while allowing for injuries and strong closing arguments over the next two weeks.

    And now the race for X-and-O privileges
    Who will be coaching all of the above?

    Dallas' Don Nelson is ineligible because he coached the West last February, so Sacramento's Rick Adelman is a lock to get the job this February. The coach whose team has the best record in the conference gets the gig, but the rules say a coach can't serve two years in a row.

    That rules out the Nets' Byron Scott in the East, narrowing the competition to Indiana's Isiah Thomas against Detroit's Rick Carlisle. The same Thomas, remember, who was the Pacers' choice, over Larry Bird assistant Carlisle, to replace Bird entering the 2000-01 season.

    Not that Carlisle is even looking for revenge, after winning Coach of the Year honors as a Detroit rookie, but a home-and-home with the Pacers on Jan. 18 and Jan. 20 will give the Pistons a chance to pass them for the Central Division lead.

    Of course, if the Pacers hold on and Isiah winds up coaching his old "buddy" MJ, then we'll have our juicy story.

    Stojakovic kicks his shooting slump
    It was largely to keep pace with the Kings -- forget the Lakers -- that the Mavericks went overseas and kept lobbying until they persuaded France's Antoine Rigaudeau to finally give the NBA a try at 31.

    Peja Stojakovic
    Kings opponents should take heed: Peja Stojakovic is heating up.
    The Kings were the league's deepest team last season and have only gotten deeper, adding Keon Clark, Jim Jackson and Damon Jones. The Mavericks know, by comparison, that their bench isn't on par. Not with Eduardo Najera and Popeye Jones sub-par physically and Sacramento so deep now that Hedo Turkoglu -- a starter in the conference finals for the injured Peja Stojakovic -- has barely played lately.

    Speaking of Stojakovic, it looks as though he's finally recovering from the ankle/heel woes that have plagued him for nearly eight months. Peja scored 21 first-half points in Thursday's rout at New Jersey and followed that up with games of 27 and 30 (against Minnesota and Memphis) on 22-for-36 shooting.

    "You know he's not a 41-percent shooter from the floor and he's not 31 percent from 3," Kings coach Rick Adelman said after the unexpectedly easy win in Jersey. "If people want to play him that way, so be it, because Peja's going to start making shots. I just hope this game kick-starts him into making a real good run."

    Gentry: Brand's still the best in face-to-face swatting
    A flip-flop at the top of the NBA's shot-blocking leaders shouldn't be all that surprising. Elton Brand is 6-8. Shawn Bradley is 7-6. With that sizable height advantage, Bradley has finally passed Brand, 2.91 blocks per game to Brand's 2.88.

    As a consolation, though, Brand still awoke Sunday ahead of Tim Duncan (2.86), Ben Wallace (2.82) and Theo Ratliff (2.74).

    "That's because Elton's probably the best on-the-ball shot-blocker in the league," said Clippers coach Alvin Gentry. "Those other guys like Bradley and Ratliff, they're weak-side shot-blockers. They block more shots by guys who drive past someone else than the guy they're guarding."

    Pacers not worried about O'Neal's knee
    The questions Donnie Walsh can expect this week are Gary Payton-related. The Sonics are imploding and GP is at the heart of the discontent (surprise!), and Walsh's Pacers discussed the possibility of trading for The Glove with Seattle over the summer.

    Payton does not want to move East, and really doesn't want to leave the only town he has ever known, but he's a free agent come July and isn't about to get what he wants -- in terms of money or title odds -- from the Sonics. Seattle would certainly consider any proposal that didn't hamper its future cap flexibility, which potentially makes Payton the most talented player available between now and the Feb. 20 trade deadline.

    Back to the Pacers, and rewinding to last week's question, Walsh was asked if the Pacers were being unnecessarily risky by allowing Jermaine O'Neal to return from a nasty-looking knee twist after just four games off. Especially with a roster deep enough to generate Payton trade speculation and likewise sustain an injury or two.

    "We found that the knee did not have any structural damage to it," Walsh said. "It seems to be getting better. He has stayed out of practice, but when you see him in the games, I don't see it hindering him."

    Marc Stein is the senior NBA writer for ESPN.com. To e-mail him, click here.





  •  More from ESPN...
    Slams and Dunks: Shooting two
    Even with Shaq, NBA players ...
    Stein: Warriors' little big man
    Warriors super sub Earl ...

    The Stein Line
    Senior NBA writer Marc Stein ...

    Marc Stein Archive



     ESPN Tools
    Email story
     
    Most sent
     
    Print story
     
    Daily email