Ivan Maisel

COLLEGE FOOTBALL
2002-03 Bowls
Scoreboard
Schedules
Rankings
Standings
Statistics
Transactions
Message Board
Teams
Recruiting
CONFERENCES


ESPN MALL
TeamStore
ESPN Auctions
SPORT SECTIONS
Sunday, December 8
Updated: December 9, 6:59 PM ET
 
No debate this year -- the BCS got it right

By Ivan Maisel
ESPN.com

After two seasons in which the BCS formula produced a controversial national championship game, everyone with an emotional stake in college football should recognize that in this season, on this Sunday, the system worked. Undefeated Miami will play undefeated Ohio State in the Tostitos Fiesta Bowl on Jan. 3.

Miami celebrates a trip to the Fiesta Bowl against Ohio State.
The complainers of the last two years stretched from sea to shining sea. Miami felt cheated in 2000, when Florida State played Oklahoma. Oregon was cheated last year, when Nebraska played Miami. Now everyone must admit that the BCS has given us a game that, in days of yore, would not have been possible. Under the old system of bowls, Miami would have bunkered itself at home and waited for a victim to travel south. Ohio State would have played Washington State in the Rose Bowl, and the national championship ring companies would have had double the normal amount of business.

Before the conference commissioners tear a rotator cuff patting themselves on the back, they need to be reminded that over the last four years, they have succeeded about as often as they have failed. For college football coaches, .500 records over four years can easily result in job loss. The BCS has three more years left on its contract, and some are whispering that a one-game, post-bowl playoff has a chance.

The BCS did not develop into the panacea that its fans hoped it would be. It works about as often as it doesn't, which makes it the equivalent of the heat in my attic.

The selections by the remaining bowls carried their usual amount of politicking, bootlicking and high-sticking. All any fans really care about is the quality of the matchups. Here again, the BCS delivered.

Once the FedEx Orange Bowl decided to take Iowa, the lone question remained whether the Rose Bowl would take USC for a rematch against Washington State and deny the nation a matchup of top-five teams in either New Orleans (USC-Georgia) or Miami (USC-Iowa).

The Rose Bowl felt comfortable enough with Oklahoma that it passed on the Trojans. The Nokia Sugar Bowl, scheduled to pick next, didn't get the chance. The Orange Bowl cut in line and seized upon USC by exercising the "preferred pick" that it may use once over the four-year BCS contract because it pays $900,000 more into the BCS pool than does the Sugar Bowl.

For most of the last month, it seemed improbable that the Orange Bowl would take the Trojans, whose fans haven't the need to escape to South Florida in the dead of winter.

However, Orange Bowl officials understood that they could fill their stadium three times over with Hawkeye fans. The result is, for all intents and purposes, a 61st-anniversary restaging of the only Rose Bowl to be played on the East Coast. Because of wartime fears on the Pacific Coast in the wake of Pearl Harbor, Oregon State traveled to Duke and won, 20-16, in Durham, N.C., on Jan. 1, 1942.

"If you're a member institution in the Big Ten or Pac-10," Iowa coach Kirk Ferentz said, "your goal is always to play in the Rose Bowl. Things have changed in college football."

What the Florida State-Georgia game in the Sugar Bowl lacks as compelling theater, it appears to make up for in compelling story line. Pairing the Bulldogs' second-year coach Mark Richt, against his boss of 15 seasons, Bobby Bowden, is interesting if only because the Seminoles have slipped on offense since Richt departed as quarterback coach and offensive coordinator.

Don't mistake it for having the emotional pull of a "Bowden Bowl," the father-son battles between Bobby's Florida State teams and the Clemson teams coached by his son Tommy. Richt said earlier this season that he hadn't spoken to Bobby Bowden since the summer.

Oklahoma and Washington State is an interesting game because Oklahoma's defense is as fast and physical as the Cougars' offense is quick and prolific. When those teams are on the sideline, which is to say, when Oklahoma has the ball, feel free to go replenish the snack dish.

Ivan Maisel is a senior writer for ESPN.com. E-mail him at ivan.maisel@espn3.com.







 More from ESPN...
Miami-Ohio State pairing official as BCS puzzle set
The BCS pairings were set ...

The Junction Boys
ESPN's second movie airs Dec. ...

Ivan Maisel Archive

 ESPN Tools
Email story
 
Most sent
 
Print story
 
Daily email