Mechelle Voepel

W COLLEGE BB
Scores
Schedules
Rankings
Standings
Statistics
Message Board
ESPN MALL
TeamStore
ESPN Auctions
SPORT SECTIONS
Saturday, February 22
Updated: March 2, 12:58 PM ET
 
Wade-ing through some growing pains

By Mechelle Voepel
Special to ESPN.com

The State Farm Wade Trophy is going through some growing pains. I just hope it goes through them quickly, because there are some problems that need to be fixed with this award.

It has been given since 1978, and was formerly under the jurisdiction of the National Association for Girls and Women in Sport. The late Margaret Wade, coach of three-time AIAW champion Delta State, always wanted her namesake trophy to be awarded through the Women's Basketball Coaches Association.

And the WBCA, under CEO Beth Bass, was able to negotiate control, if you will, of the Wade Trophy in 2001. Bass signed on State Farm as a sponsor, and the winner is now announced by ESPN. That's all good.

Last Friday, though, things with the Wade Trophy started getting a little screwy.

The WBCA released what it said was its list of 13 final candidates for the award. There were at least two surprising omissions: South Carolina's Jocelyn Penn and Kansas State's Kendra Wecker.

When I called Wade selection committee chair Billie Moore that night to ask about the list, she did not know it had been sent out, nor was she certain who was on it.

How does that happen? I'm not trying to embarrass people, and I do want to say Moore was very polite and tried to answer the questions. But if you're calling an award the "Heisman'' of your sport, you'd think the selection committee chair would have been kept abreast of such an announcement and not been put in an awkward position. Did the WBCA assume no one would ask about it?

Further, if the chair wasn't entirely sure who was on the list, then who exactly did decide that? There are 11 committee members, only one of whom is currently a Division I head coach, Mississippi State's Sharon Fanning.

Now, back to the omissions. There are three players on the list from the SEC, and somehow Penn isn't one of them. Even though she leads the league in steals (3.8), is second in scoring (24.5), second in field-goal percentage (62.1) and tied for fourth in rebounding 8.0.

Then there's Wecker, one of the top candidates for Big 12 player of the year. She leads the league in scoring (19.6), is fourth in rebounding (8.4), 10th in assists (3.7) and 10th in steals (1.85).

Wecker's versatility is such that she has made 46 3-pointers this season and has more rebounds (227) than every player on the Wade list except her teammate, Nicole Ohlde (239).

Ohlde, incidentally, is the only person on the list from the Big 12, a conference that currently has three teams in the Associated Press' top 10.

Like most people, I'd guess the Wade is between Duke's Alana Beard and UConn's Diana Taurasi, both juniors -- although the award has been senior-dominated.

Had Stanford's Nicole Powell not gotten off to the late start because of her back injury, she'd be mentioned just as often as the other two. As far as I'm concerned, though, she probably should be anyway.

I don't think Penn nor Wecker had any chance of winning the award this year. But it seems wrong that they aren't on the list. While we're at it, here are some more questions:

  • Vanderbilt's Chantelle Anderson is on the list, but an argument could be made that she's not even having the best season on her own team. Anderson's numbers: 17.2 points, 5.3 rebounds. Jenni Benningfield's numbers: 16.6 points, 8.0 rebounds. Benningfield has 22 more assists and 16 fewer turnovers. And she's at 57.8 percent from the field to Anderson's 63.7, even though Benningfield isn't just shooting from close in. She's a modest 3-point threat, having made 18 of 49. I know Anderson has battled toe problems, and I'm certainly not trying to stir up anything between the teammates. I just wonder if the selection committee looked at Benningfield's numbers.

  • Now let's compare players from the same major conference. Should Duke's Iciss Tillis (14.9 ppg, 7.4 ppg) be on the list over Georgia Tech's Sonja Mallory, who's third in the ACC in scoring (16.9) and first in rebounding (9.4) and blocked shots (1.65)?

  • Let's compare players in the same mid-major conference. Drake's Carla Bennett is a good player and has nice numbers: 15.8 points and 8.5 rebounds. But her team is 13-10 overall and tied for third place in the Missouri Valley at 8-6. Meanwhile, Creighton's Christy Neneman is averaging 17.1 points, 5.8 rebounds, 3.9 assists and 1.87 steals for a team that's 17-6 and in second place in the Valley at 10-4. And Neneman was the league MVP last year as a sophomore. Bottom line: Did the selection committee do its homework? If so, has there been adequate communication between the members? As mentioned, it doesn't seem like there has been enough of that between the committee and the WBCA.

    And there's something else: Those who give the award also need to decide if it's really supposed to be for the "best college player.'' Because the truth is, it hasn't lived up to that designation for much of the past decade. Consider these players who never won the Wade Trophy: Chamique Holdsclaw, Tamika Catchings, Lisa Leslie, Sheryl Swoopes and Dawn Staley.

    No, I'm not making that up. None of them won it. Can you imagine a greater indictment of this award if it's really supposed to be for the best player?

    Meanwhile, all five did win the Naismith Award. The Wade was really stuck on going just to seniors, but even that doesn't explain the above omissions.

    There's always going to be disagreements about awards in any sport. But the Wade Trophy should be a major honor not only to win, but to be nominated for. These things can't be airtight, but they don't need these kind of holes.

    This can all be resolved. Maybe the WBCA should step back for a second, look at the structure and reaffirm exactly what it wants the Wade Trophy to be. The kids who play college basketball and the memory of Margaret Wade deserve that.

    Mechelle Voepel is a regular contributor to ESPN.com's women's basketball coverage. She can be reached at mvoepel@kcstar.com.






  •  More from ESPN...
    Wade Watch: The top contenders
    The Wade Trophy honors the ...

    Lieberman: Taurasi tops Wade Watch
    There are dozens of great ...

    Wade Trophy officials have 13 candidates in mind
    The WBCA is considering 13 ...

    Mechelle Voepel Archive

     ESPN Tools
    Email story
     
    Most sent
     
    Print story
     
    Daily email