Len Pasquarelli

Keyword
NFL
Scores
Schedules
Standings
Statistics
Transactions
Injuries
Players
Message Board
NFL en español
CLUBHOUSE


SHOP@ESPN.COM
NikeTown
TeamStore
ESPN Auctions
SPORT SECTIONS
Wednesday, December 12
 
NFC third-quarter report card

By Len Pasquarelli
ESPN.com

In the din of a raucous Green Bay locker room last Sunday evening, with his teammates in full celebratory mode after their critical victory over the Chicago Bears, quarterback Brett Favre paused to deliver a dose of reality.

PASQUARELLI'S ALL-NFC TEAM
OFFENSE
Pos. Player Team
WR David Boston Cardinals
LT Tra Thomas Eagles
LG Ray Brown 49ers
C Olin Kreutz Bears
RG Leonard Davis Cardinals
RT Mark Tauscher Packers
TE Ernie Conwell Rams
WR Terrell Owens 49ers
QB Kurt Warner Rams
RB Ahman Green Packers
FB Bob Christian Falcons
DEFENSE
Pos. Player Team
LE Michael Strahan Giants
LT Ted Washington Bears
RT Dan Wilkinson Redskins
RE Phillip Daniels Bears
SLB LaVar Arrington Redskins
MLB Brian Urlacher Bears
WLB Nate Wayne Packers
CB Aeneas Williams Rams
SS Sammy Knight Saints
FS Darren Sharper Packers
CB Doug Evans Panthers
SPECIAL TEAMS
Pos. Player Team
K John Carney Saints
P Todd Sauerbrun Panthers
KR Steve Smith Panthers
PR Brian Mitchell Eagles
"Yeah, we're pretty good, I guess," acknowledged the unquestioned Leader of the Pack. "But we still have a ways to go. The good thing is, we've still got a month to keep improving. We've still got time to get beyond 'pretty good' and see if we can be something special."

Fact is, while the incomparable Favre was assessing his own team, he could have been describing the status of many NFC teams as the schedule turns to the home stretch. Once again, ESPN.com has awarded only one "A" grade to an NFC team in its third divisional report card of the season, and that went to the St. Louis Rams. Since the last report at the midway point of the year, though, several teams improved their standing and now four teams rate in the "B" category.

Those four "B" teams could go boom or bust in the final month as the clubs jockey for playoff position and higher seeds in the NFC postseason bracket. As things now stand, it appears that five of the six playoff berths are all but wrapped up, with the final wild-card spot being contested. But even some standout teams, like Chicago and San Francisco, face tough schedules over the final month of the slate.

"It's certainly no time now to let down," said Chicago center Olin Kreutz after Sunday's loss. "You know the old saying about how the strong survive? It's truer now than ever. No one can afford any slippage at this point in the season. There's still a lot up for grabs."

Here is how ESPN.com rates the NFC teams heading into the final month:

Arizona Cardinals (5-7)
Does anyone outside the Valley of the Sun, with the possible exception of all the cornerbacks David Boston has been torching of late, realize that the Cardinals third-year wide receiver is on pace to post the fourth-most receiving yards in NFL history? Some good things are starting to happen for good-guy coach Dave McGinnis and, with the resurrection of quarterback Jake Plummer, there is actually something to build on for 2002. The young talent is beginning to develop, and our vote for offensive rookie of the year is going to guard Leonard Davis, but the Cardinals still have much work to do. A good sign is that the team didn't quit early, when losses were mounting, and it appeared that this would be another lost year. McGinnis needs a quality runner and some defensive help.
Grade: C-plus.

Atlanta Falcons (6-6)
Pending new owner Arthur Blank, a guy who knows a thing or two about home improvement, will purchase the consummate fixer-upper franchise. All the hammers and nails in every Home Depot store, though, won't be sufficient hardware to refurbish a team that suddenly has reverted to form. The attention paid to an allegedly improved offensive line has evaporated, since Atlanta can neither run the ball nor protect its quarterbacks. Starting tailback Maurice Smith has 130 yards in his last four games and is averaging less than 2.0 yards per attempt. The Atlanta quarterbacks have been sacked an average of once every 8.2 "dropbacks," the worst ratio in the league. The good news is that three of the last four games are on the road, where Atlanta has played far better than at home.
Grade: C-minus.

Carolina Panthers (1-12)
The past four defeats in an ignominious 12-game losing streak have been by a total of 11 points, less than a field goal per game, and this team has come to define frustration. Five times the Panthers have lost games in which they led entering the final two minutes. Owner Jerry Richardson might need an exorcist more than he does a new coach, although he is likely to have the latter by the start of the 2002 season. It's hard to imagine that, at age 61, George Seifert has the patience necessary to embark on what could be a two- or three-year rebuilding project. It appears ownership will seek a younger head coach, possibly from the college ranks, to take on the task. The one plus, albeit a miniscule one, is that Carolina had a decent 2001 draft and that rookie quarterback Chris Weinke has a year to build on.
Grade: D.

Chicago Bears (9-3)
Some of the skeptics still suggest the Bears are still the byproduct of converged good fortune this year but to make that claim is to diminish the chemistry forged by the club and the ability to make almost every game a close one. That said, a team has to win a "hump" game before it truly matures, and last Sunday's loss at Green Bay represented the latest failure to stand up and prove the Bears' mettle. Chicago has rebounded nicely from every defeat this year, and it must bounce back from the Packers loss with a win over Tampa Bay this week. Another slip and the critics gain an even louder voice, which would not be good for the future of coach Dick Jauron, still not endorsed by general manager Jerry Angelo for the '02 season. And, yeah, we'll say it again: Chicago must get more vertical in the passing game.
Grade: B.

Dallas Cowboys (4-8)
OK, we confess, the four victories notched by the Cowboys this season really are about double what we thought the club could achieve. Maybe owner Jerry Jones can convince league officials to put the Washington Redskins on the schedule every week. From a pure talent standpoint, Dallas still has plenty of holes, and some of the solid veterans holding things together will be cut loose after the season in moves that will further deplete the quality. But give coach Dave Campo credit for getting the Cowboys to play hard almost every week out, for surviving the revolving door situation at quarterback, and for beginning to develop a few good youngsters like tailback Troy Hambrick. There could be a couple more wins on the schedule in the final month and if the Pokes win six contests, it's quite an accomplishment.
Grade: C-minus.

Detroit Lions (0-12)
Getting a little bored from those weekly, but apparently requisite, television shots of president and general manager Matt Millen agonizing in the owner's box every time the Lions experience a tragic gaffe? Yeah, so are we. Maybe it's time for Millen to strap on the pads and go back to the playing field, huh? Every opponent cautions during the week of preparation that the Lions are a better team than their record, and that can't help but be the case, but there remains a notable bagel in the left-hand column of the win-loss ledger book. Like the Panthers, the Lions seem to invent new ways to lose, such as having munchkin-sized corner Jimmy Wyrick trying to cover Tampa Bay wide receiver Keyshawn Johnson on the deciding play in last week's loss to the Bucs. Little wonder Millen has a weekly Excedrin headache.
Grade: F.

Green Bay Packers (9-3)
This is a team that continues to demonstrate that, if you have three or four premier playmakers on both sides of the ball, that's enough to win consistently in a league that's as diluted as this one is right now. Brett Favre still makes some maddening decisions, like the last minute interception he threw in an inexplicable loss to Atlanta, but he remains one of the greatest clutch performers in league history. The "X factor" for the Packers is becoming tailback Ahman Green, arguably the best all-around back in the after Marshall Faulk. Defensive coordinator Ed Donatell has done a superb job of putting young standouts like weakside linebacker Nate Wayne and safety Darren Sharper into position to make plays, and has gotten the most of out several veteran roleplayers like tackle Gilbert Brown.
Grade: B.

THINGS TO WATCH
1. Given their winless status, the Lions have become quite a novelty item, and the kind of morbid curiosity that draws people to stop every time they see a roadside accident will continue to mount with every defeat. No team, of course, has ever gone 0-16 but the Lions have a real shot. For the record, their remaining schedule is: Minnesota (Dec. 16), at Pittsburgh (Dec. 23), Chicago (Dec. 30) and Dallas (Jan. 6). It will also be interesting to monitor the performances of rookie quarterback Mike McMahon, because how he plays could well determine the future of the injured incumbent, Charlie Batch, in Detroit.

2. Now that he's caught his first touchdown pass of the season, can Keyshawn Johnson spark a Tampa Bay passing attack that has to contribute more down the stretch, at least if the Bucs are to continue the annual second-half surge for a playoff spot? Also keep an ear to the ground for all the rumors about the fate of coach Tony Dungy and the possibility of Bill Parcells coming out of retirement to take over the team. It's better than even money that Dungy survives, and Parcells isn't as interested in the Tampa Bay job as some reports purport.

3. Could either Rick Mirer or Tim Rattay take the 49ers to the playoffs? Here's hoping the 49ers don't have to find out. But given the wobbly condition of Jeff Garcia, who has been playing with knee and elbow injuries, there is a chance that one of the 49ers backups could be called on at some point down the stretch. While on the subject of bruised quarterbacks, it never hurts to monitor the status of Kurt Warner's right thumb. The St. Louis star clearly has lost some of his accuracy on the deep ball as the thumb problem continues. If he bangs his thumb off some defender's helmet, the Rams could be forced to survive with journeyman Jamie Martin.

4. The battle for the third and final wild card spot figures to be a real doozy. And unlike in some past years, the No. 6 seed in the conference could actually have a chance to be competitive in the playoffs, especially if it's New Orleans or Tampa Bay. There are some head-to-head battles that will involve the candidates for the final spot, beginning with New Orleans at Tampa Bay on Dec. 23, and those could make for some terrific matchups.

5. How offensive coordinator John Shoop reacts to the criticism of the Chicago Bears horizontal passing game could determine how well this surprising team finishes. And, even more essential, it could determine whether head coach Dick Jauron is back for the 2002 season. A few weeks ago, Shoop was roundly criticized both locally and nationally for his conservative leanings, and he came out the following week against Tampa Bay and loosened the reins. In the wake of Sunday's loss at Green Bay, he is being again castigated. Who do the Bears face on Sunday? Tampa Bay. Maybe it would be wise for the maligned Shoop to revisit the game plan from the first meeting.
— Len Pasquarelli

Minnesota Vikings (5-7)
In the midst of the ongoing circus sideshow typically hosted by wideout Randy Moss, the ringleader with a terminal case of foot-in-mouth disease, there have been some flashes of the old Vikings explosiveness over the past month. And, uh, no, we're not speaking of the sideline contretemps that seem to mark most Minnesota games. This remains a dangerous club and one capable of being a spoiler in the final month of the season. Still the weekly question that must be asked is whether the explosive Vikings will show up or be supplanted by their implosive evil look-alikes. Coach Dennis Green will be back in 2002, according to owner Red McCombs, and maybe it's time he actually address the defensive holes that have existed for years. Failure to do so could mean he won't be around for 2003.
Grade: D-plus.

New Orleans Saints (7-5)
Winners of three of their last five games, the Saints have catapulted back into the NFC wild card chase and face a monumental game next Monday night when they host a St. Louis Rams team despised by most New Orleans players and coach Jim Haslett. The keys to the turnaround have been the improved play of quarterback Aaron Brooks and wide receiver Joe Horn, who have regained the swagger that marked their breakout '01 seasons. It was only about a month ago that teammates were whispering that Brooks should maybe be replaced in favor of Jeff Blake, and the second-year starter responded with a five-game stretch in which he averaged more than 300 passing yards. The defense has stepped up its game, now leads the league in sacks again, and middle linebacker Charlie Clemons has been a catalyst.
Grade: C-plus.

New York Giants (5-7)
Coach Jim Fassel has run out of guarantees, the players are out of excuses, and it appears the Giants are out of the playoffs just one year after representing the NFC in the Super Bowl. There have been defensive lapses, for sure, like the shaky play of corner Jason Sehorn. But much of the onus is on an offense that is slow, old upfront, and terribly predictable. When is the last time you heard anyone mention the name of offensive coordinator Sean Payton, a onetime hot commodity on the rumor mill, as a head coach candidate? There have been some games when Tiki Barber looks good but his tailback partner, Ron Dayne, has been a bust. And defenses have figured out that quarterback Kerry Collins is in such a funk, he couldn't read a kindergarten primer much less a two-deep zone coverage.
Grade: C-minus.

Philadelphia Eagles (8-4)
With the exception of the ugly stumble against the Washington Redskins, the real Eagles team that was supposed to challenge to go deep into the playoffs, finally has stood up and played to its potential. Philadelphia has won five of its last six outings, with the victories by an average of 19.6 points, and truly is on a roll. If the Eagles can avenge that loss to the Skins on Sunday in Washington, they will have all but wrapped up the division. Although there still are times when quarterback Donovan McNabb struggles with his accuracy (anyone ever see this guy hit a running back in stride on a swing pass?), and wide receiver Todd Pinkston is mired in a bad funk, the offense is getting enough and running the ball more effectively with Duce Staley. On the defensive end, the Eagles still use every blitz in the book.
Grade: B-minus.

St. Louis Rams (10-2)
They have met the enemy and it is them, the only team seemingly capable of knocking off the Rams being the Rams themselves, who too often treat turnovers as just part of the consequence for the way they play offense. Opponents take home from the weird Monday night loss to Tampa Bay, and from the fact St. Louis is just 5-5 in its last 10 home games, but the Rams remain the gold standard right now against whom everyone else is measured. As long as quarterback Kurt Warner (thumb) and tailback Marshall Faulk (knee) can gut through the pain, few teams have the personnel wherewithal to hang with the St. Louis offense. And on defense, rookie coordinator Lovie Smith continues to hone aggressive game plans, and get the most out of a unit that really has very few Pro Bowl caliber performers.
Grade: A.

San Francisco 49ers (9-3)
For virtually the entire season, the 49ers have overachieved, but now they face a dangerous stretch. Coming off a loss at St. Louis last week, San Francisco now has three crucial tests this month: home games against Miami on Sunday and Philadelphia on Dec. 23, and then a game at New Orleans in the regular-season finale. And exacerbating the situation is that quarterback Jeff Garcia is hobbled right now, with knee and elbow injuries, and having to cut back a bit on his throwing schedule. The stretch run is going to be a true test of just how far the Niners have progressed this year, especially on defense. This is a team that moves the ball versus just about everybody it plays. But the young defense, with seven starters gleaned from the past two drafts, still has some uneven moments.
Grade: B.

Tampa Bay Buccaneers (7-5)
Yeah, once again, they're b-a-a-a-c-k. Left for dead just a month ago, the Bucs have rallied again in late season, keyed by their upset win at St. Louis two weeks ago. But as Tampa Bay demonstrated in Sunday's nail-biter victory over winless Detroit, this still is a team that doesn't score enough points, is getting precious little from its alleged power running game, and is capable of perilous streaks of schizophrenia on both sides of the ball. For now, the Bucs hold the final wild card spot in the NFC, but they face a Bataan Death March of a schedule. After visiting Chicago this week, the Bucs conclude with three straight homes games, but they are against New Orleans, Baltimore and Philadelphia. Someone is going to have to stick a stake through the Bucs' hearts, but this could be the year they fall shy.
Grade: C-plus.

Washington Redskins (6-6)
Despite the fact some veterans still haven't bought into the methods of coach Marty Schottenheimer, the Redskins have won five of six games, and are truly in the thick of the NFC wild card race. The staff finally took the governor off the quarterback position and Tony Banks has throw the deep ball particularly well, especially to rookie wide receiver Rod Gardner. There was always enough quality on defense to get by but now veterans like corner Champ Bailey, who slumped badly in the first half of the year, are playing significantly better. An overlooked key on offense was the insertion of guard Ben Colemen into the lineup. His play at guard has helped open up huge creases for tailback Stephen Davis, one of the NFL's best power runners, and again the focal point of the offense.
Grade: C-minus.

Len Pasquarelli is a senior NFL writer for ESPN.com.







 More from ESPN...
Clayton: AFC third-quarter report card
The Patriots and Steelers are ...
Rookie Report: Third-quarter grades
A torrid stretch of games has ...

Question of the Week: Super Cinderella?
Favorites don't always make ...

If the season ended today...
See who'd be in the playoffs ...

Pasquarelli: NFC's midseason grades
The Rams are the only NFC ...

Pasquarelli: NFC's first-quarter report card
The Bears, Packers, Rams and ...

Len Pasquarelli Archive

 ESPN Tools
Email story
 
Most sent
 
Print story