Cutler was playing it cool in his first interview at the podium
when fellow rookies Brandon Marshall and Tony Scheffler began
heckling him from the side. Cutler tried to keep from laughing and
"I'm excited," Cutler said. "And a little nervous."
The Cutler Era has officially started. Coach Mike Shanahan ended
the speculation Monday by elevating the rookie to starting
quarterback for the rest of the year, sending Jake Plummer to the
"He's our future, he's our present," Shanahan said.
Cutler, the 11th pick out of Vanderbilt in the draft last April,
hasn't taken a snap since the preseason. But Shanahan is hoping a
quarterback change can ignite the Broncos' struggling offense. The
team is 7-4, but ranks 26th in the league with 171 yards passing
"There's a lot of pressure on a first-year quarterback, no
question about it," Shanahan said. "I think this kid can handle
it. I think he gives us the best chance to win."
His teammates figure it's worth the chance.
"With the losing streak we're on, it doesn't hurt to try,"
receiver Javon Walker said. "If he does [well], we'll ride it all
the way out. If not, obviously he's our quarterback of the
A quarterback switch worked in Dallas when Tony Romo took over
for Drew Bledsoe. The Cowboys have gone 4-1 with Romo as the
starter. San Diego is leading the AFC West behind first-year
starter Philip Rivers.
When asked if the situations were comparable, Shanahan was
"No," he said.
"Matt and Vince have to go out there and really win games,"
said Cutler, who's the first rookie quarterback to start for Denver
since Tommy Maddox on Dec. 12, 1992, at Buffalo. Maddox started for
an injured John Elway. "We've got a good team. We've got leaders
on this team. I need to go out there and do my part."
Cutler had an impressive preseason for Denver, throwing for 561
yards, third best in the NFL. Romo led the league with 833 yards
passing in exhibition play. Cutler's passer rating of 108.3 led the
league in the preseason.
"Preseason is preseason. I don't put a lot of stock in it,"
Cutler said. "This is a different animal. We're playing for real
Cutler is the latest in a ine of Broncos quarterbacks attempting
to become the 'next John Elway.' He knows the comparisons will be
Not that Cutler would want Elway's rookie debut. The Hall of
Famer was 1-of-8 for 14 yards and one interception against
Pittsburgh on Sept. 4, 1983. Denver did win 14-10.
Shanahan thinks Cutler's situation is different from what Elway
"You look at a quarterback [in Elway] that really didn't have,
at least in my opinion, a great supporting cast," Shanahan said.
"All the pressure was on the quarterback. I think it's almost
impossible for a guy to come in his first year without a supporting
cast and be successful."
The Broncos have the supporting cast. This is the same basic
team that went to the AFC championship game last year.
"Sometimes things like this are a wakeup that everyone's got to
look at themselves in the mirror and say, 'What can we do
better?"' safety John Lynch said. "Everyone's got to do their job
In his first practice as the starter, Cutler was pumped up,
sending several passes over the heads of receivers. There was no
question he had extra velocity on his throws.
"Everyone's saying he's a young Brett Favre," said Walker, who
played with Favre in Green Bay. "You can see that in the strength
of his arm. It gets there in a hurry. After the more reps we get
together, it should work out."
Shanahan said he won't scale back the playbook for Cutler.
"For us to make the decision we've made, we feel very
comfortable he's got complete knowledge of the offense," he said.
Plummer will be relegated to backup duty for basically the first
time in his 10-year career. He's 39-15 as Denver's starter in the
regular season, 1-3 in the playoffs. Shanahan and Plummer have the
fifth-best regular-season winning percentage -- with a minimum 50
starts -- since 1970.
Cutler said he and Plummer spoke after they were informed of the
flip-flop in their roles.
"He told me it didn't change anything between me and him and
he's going to be here for me," Cutler said.
Plummer wouldn't talk with reporters after practice.
Plummer has thrown 11 touchdown passes and 12 interceptions this
season. He threw only seven interceptions last year.
"I don't think he obviously likes the move," Shanahan said.
"Any competitor would not like the move. He's going to do
everything he can to help this football team."
Plummer has three years left on his contract, but no guaranteed
money after this season.
"Would I like him here long-term?" Shanahan said. "As long as
he'd like to be here. I'd love him in that [backup] role if he
wants to be in that role. I think time will tell."
The Broncos, coming off two straight losses for the first time
in two years, host the Seattle Seahawks on Sunday night. Shanahan
doesn't think the prime-time game will rattle the rookie.
"What's the difference? A game is a game," Shanahan said.
"You've got to go out there and perform. He'll handle it well."