![]() |
![]()
|
| Wednesday, August 29 Quarterbacks no longer center of attention By Len Pasquarelli ESPN.com |
|||||||||||||||||||
|
There are more transactions listed in the relatively scant biography of Chicago Bears quarterback Shane Matthews than there are starting assignments. As they say, you can look it up. Go ahead, count 'em, all nine lines of agate copy in The Pro Football Register detailing the 18 times Matthews was signed and released and re-signed by the Bears and Carolina Panthers, activated from one of the teams' practice squads, granted unconditional free agency, or allocated to the Rhein Fire of the NFL Europe.
Just call it the ultimate quarterback apprenticeship for a guy who has been like a human yo-yo during his NFL tenure. And, almost as an afterthought, there are also those dozen starts, or 1.7 per each of the seven seasons Matthews has bounced around the league. That number will be bumped by one Sept. 9, when the former University of Florida star gets the start against the Super Bowl champion Baltimore Ravens. But before you begin questioning Matthews' viability atop the shaky Chicago quarterback depth chart, it might not hurt to take a look at some of the other signal-callers who will get the nod on the first weekend of the regular season. Suddenly the gritty Matthews, who actually owns a respectable 75.9 passer rating and has played well when provided an opportunity, doesn't look nearly so out of place among the assemblage of retreads, former backups, journeymen, one-time minor leaguers and kids who have been anointed the starters for their respective teams. Certainly, as the role of quarterback has been diminished by the dearth of true "franchise" performers at the game's most critical position, the value has increased for some players who feature more travel stickers on their luggage than a Club Med subscriber. And at a time when standout quarterbacks are so sparse, teams are having to make do with a group of starters who a decade ago might have qualified only as clipboard jockeys. "Look, there are only a limited number of so-called 'franchise' quarterbacks around at any given time and now there might be the fewest in many years," said Hall of Fame coach Bill Walsh, a guy who knows a thing or two about developing quarterbacks. "If you don't have a Peyton Manning or a Brett Favre or a Donovan McNabb, you still need your quarterback to play well for you. And so teams are looking more now for guys who are 'good fits,' who can come in and perform well within a system." Over the last two years alone, four future Hall of Fame quarterbacks -- Steve Young, Dan Marino, John Elway and Troy Aikman -- have retired. Only in Denver, where Brian Griese is the reigning league passing champion, was the franchise able to replace the past star with another player who possesses "franchise" potential. Just five or six years ago, you needed at least two hands to count the collection of "franchise" quarterbacks in the NFL, but that number has dwindled to a handful. And because of that, the rationale of offensive coordinators has changed, and so has the overall expectation level for the quarterback position. "I don't necessarily agree that the position has been minimalized, because you still need your quarterback to play well if you're going to win, and that probably won't change in this league," said Buffalo Bills president Tom Donahoe. "But it doesn't all have to be on the quarterback anymore. You don't see as many offenses where, if a quarterback doesn't have a great day, his team loses. It's more a case sometimes of wanting your quarterback to give you a chance to win." The hackneyed adage that a quarterback gets too much credit when his team wins and too much blame in defeat is all but passé now. In the last three seasons the game has evolved to a point where, for some teams, the quarterback is no longer the primary playmaker but rather a facilitator who ensures the surrounding talent is optimally utilized and that a win is more critical than statistics. "We've been saying for years that the most important number for a quarterback is how many wins he puts up," said Bears general manager Jerry Angelo. "Now it seems that has actually become the case. Everything else pales in comparison to that number in the lefthand side of the win-loss (ledger)." There might be no more graphic validation of that shift than the case of Tennessee Titans quarterback Steve McNair. In his six NFL seasons, McNair has never thrown more than 15 touchdown passes in a year, but he enters 2001 with an impressive 41-23 record as a starter (the Titans are 27-5 over the last two regular seasons). The upshot: That McNair got a new $47 million contract this summer was testimony more to his winning mark than to his passing percentage. "He's a great leader, he plays within himself and within our offense, and he wins," said Titans coach Jeff Fisher. "If that doesn't define the position, what does?" It used to be that the quarterback was the centerpiece of every offense but, more often than not now, he is just one of the place settings. For many offenses these days, the guy behind center is just one of 11, a complementary piece of the offensive puzzle with the same degree of accountability as his 10 mates. And if you don't believe it, you need review no further than a year ago, when the Ravens won a Super Bowl with Trent Dilfer as their starter.
"What I think you saw," said Dilfer, "was a team playing to its strengths. The goal was to win a Super Bowl, not a passing title, you know? Five or six years ago, maybe I couldn't have played the game that way. But even as a quarterback, sometimes you simply have to subjugate your skills and your ego, and that's the way the league seems to be going now." While the league's spin doctors contend the game is in good hands -- with a cadre of young and talented quarterbacks like Manning, McNabb, Daunte Culpepper, Griese, Jeff Garcia and Aaron Brooks, among others -- the reality is that more starters on opening day will have come from the scrap heap than the top of the mountain. That speaks to a couple realities: First, that the paucity of top-flight quarterback prospects who enter the league in any given year from the college ranks has forced many personnel directors to seek alternative scouting grounds, like the NFL Europe, the CFL and the Arena Football League. Second, it says that quarterbacks with the right temperament and mindset for the game of the new millennium aren't solely located in the first round. Of the projected opening day starters, just nine are former first-round selections, while 10 were either drafted in the seventh round or lower or entered the league as free agents. Just 14 teams will start quarterbacks they originally drafted. Ten of the starters have been with at least three different teams. Counting his stints in the USFL and in the CFL, Doug Flutie of San Diego is playing for his ninth different professional team. Chris Chandler of Atlanta is with his sixth franchise in the NFL. Jeff George of Washington, Oakland's Rich Gannon and Miami's Jay Fiedler are with their fifth teams, Trent Green of Kansas City is with his fourth. Kerry Collins of the New York Giants is with his third team and didn't find true success until after he hit the bottom of the barrel both personally and professionally. St. Louis' Kurt Warner, the league's most valuable player only two seasons ago, was an undrafted free agent who played in Europe and in the Arena League before he got a shot at stardom, and that only came when Green sustained a season-ending knee injury. Just five years ago, Fiedler was mentoring the quarterback position in the college ranks instead of playing it in the NFL, and some people told him his future might be better as a coach. The articulate and ever-candid Fiedler doesn't buy in wholesale to the notion that the quarterback position has been minimalized or its importance dramatically diminished. He does, however, agree that the era of quarterbacks single-handedly winning games likely is over, at least for the foreseeable future. "As the quarterback," he said, "you're still accountable. But what you see now is a game in which the quarterback is more like one part of the sum." Len Pasquarelli is a senior NFL writer for ESPN.com. |
|
||||||||||||||||||