NFL Preview 2001
Keyword
NFL
Scores
Schedules
Standings
Statistics
Transactions
Injuries
Players
Message Board
NFL en español
CLUBHOUSE


SHOP@ESPN.COM
NikeTown
TeamStore
SPORT SECTIONS
Thursday, August 30
 
Will Couch, Smith move forward or backward?

By John Clayton
ESPN.com

New Browns offensive coordinator Bruce Arians, a former Colts quarterback coach, compared notes the other night by phone with Peyton Manning.

Arians explained how well things were going with franchise quarterback Tim Couch, whom Arians believes is turning the corner in his early NFL career. Being a workaholic who deals in specifics, Manning asked where the Browns were in the installation of the offense.

Tim Couch
Quarterback Tim Couch sometimes feels all alone in the Browns' offense.
"We're back at your rookie year," Arians said.

"Oh, God, that bad?" Manning told Arians.

Ah, to be a young quarterback again. NOT. It's not their fault because they are drafted into the position, but highly-rated rookie quarterbacks usually turn out to be either coach-makers or coach-killers. This is Year Three for the Class of 1999, the biggest quarterback year since the Dan Marino-John Elway draft of 1983. Donovan McNabb of the Eagles and Daunte Culpepper of the Vikings already established themselves as saviors. Cade McNown, the 12th pick of that draft, washed out after two seasons with the Bears and is now the third-string quarterback for the Dolphins.

Aaron Brooks arose from the fourth round to become the next potential 1999 star after he was traded to the New Orleans Saints.

That leaves Couch, the top pick in 1999, and Akili Smith, the third pick, as virtual third-year rookies. Each has been through a head coach firing. Each has had to change offensive coordinators and learn new systems. While Couch still starts for the Browns, Smith has regressed into the No. 3 role on a losing Cincinnati Bengals team.

What will it take to get them on a McNabb or a Culpepper level? Will they join McNown in the journeyman moving quarterback club next year? The answers are rather surprising.

Without hesitation, Arians says Couch is at that level. Unfortunately, the team around him isn't. As for Smith, he's also paying a price for having too much young talent around him. His confidence is fragile. His performance at times regresses. It's not out of the question for the Bengals to expose him to the expansion draft after the season and have the Houston Texans pass on him.

Couch and Smith are two quarterbacks connected by Ohio roads that are going in different directions.

"Tim's struggles have been more because he's had so many young guys around," Arians said. "But as a player, gosh, he's outstanding. He can make all the throws. He's accurate. He has great touch. To me, one of the critical areas is how he throws the deep ball. He doesn't miss many, and the other day he missed one on a guy who was wide open. He's not used to having guys that wide open, but he's extremely accurate deep."

Football is a team game, but the NFL pays quarterbacks to be above the team. Couch, for example, received a seven-year contract which, with escalators, can be worth $59.4 million and included a $12.25 million signing bonus. Smith's contract is worth $56 million and had a $10.8 million signing bonus.

"We have to surround Tim with the talent he needs, and that's a big chore," Arians said. "We've got to give him a couple of go-to guys. Maybe that's going to take another year of teaching the guys here to catch up to him."

And that sorting out process keeps Couch as a virtual third-year rookie even though he's looking more the part of a franchise quarterback. Training camp hasn't sorted out many answers. Injuries to Kevin Johnson, Dennis Northcutt and JaJuan Dawson have left the receiving position in turmoil.

"Most of the time, Tim's been without two of his top four receivers and we won't have Dawson until the season-opener," Arians said.

The offensive line has also been a mess, causing a constant shuffle of new faces. Rookie James Jackson and Jamel White are emerging as the top running backs, but they, too, are young and unproven. Couch may be establishing himself, but the offense around him is still in expansion team mode.

"Whether he's a good quarterback or not, it's just not fair to Tim," Arians said. "There's no Edgerrin James. I think we got some nice tight ends in Rickey Dudley and O.J. Santiago to create some mismatches. With the young backs, I think we will be able to run the football. But this situation is unlike Peyton Manning's. Tim didn't have the opportunity to walk in and have Marshall Faulk, Marvin Harrison, Ken Dilger, Tarik Glenn and others."

Arians sees similarities between Couch and Manning. When Arians talked to Manning, they recalled the rookie days when Manning was making mistakes even though his experienced receivers were mostly in the right spots. It's the reverse for Couch. He's started 21 games and thrown 614 passes. During the offseason, Couch improved the mechanics of his throwing. He is more accurate and his throws are stronger.

Still, the mistakes by others get Arians to the point of screaming.

"With Peyton, I was used to seeing guys in the same system for three or three-and-half years," Arians said. "I'm so used to seeing a play executed a certain way for years. It gets frustrating because guys are at eight yards in the route instead of 12 or they are at 10 when they are supposed to be at six."

The one sign of encouragement is, despite the problems of offensive talent transition, Couch and the Browns are keeping their offense on the field against good defenses such as Tampa Bay, Green Bay and Washington more than 30 minutes. In the past two seasons because of three-and-outs, they were only on the field for roughly 52 plays, keeping the defense out there for more than 70.

Akili Smith
The Bengals are still waiting for Akili Smith to grasp their offensive scheme.
Smith's problem is no longer the talent around him. It's his inexperience at the position. Remember he came to a team that had Corey Dillon in the backfield and Darnay Scott and Carl Pickens at wide receiver and Tony McGee at tight end. Sure, the offensive line was porous, but Smith wasn't ready for prime time when he got to Cincinnati.

Because of what happened to him, he might have to go elsewhere to find his spot.

"Some guys develop at different paces," new Bengals offensive coordinator Bob Bratkowski said. "You are looking at a guy who really only was a one-year starter at Oregon. There is a background of a number of games other guys like Donovon McNabb had that Akili didn't. Various things happen in those games and you learn to deal with them. Akili has had a lot of things missing he hadn't had to deal with that slows down the process."

The problem is pinpointing the two or three things to work on to fill in for that lack of experience. Smith has the arm and the running ability. That is unquestioned. But he hasn't been involved with enough successful things on a field to improve.

"Akili was getting closer and showing signs of being able to move the team," Bratkowski said. "He throws well and was using his running ability. Look at McNabb's passing rating. It's not sterling but he's able to move the team. Akili is a big strong man. He can handle the hits."

But there are so many other things that break down in plays that have consumed Smith. He's still learning the management of protections. He's still mastering the reads of defense. He's still adjusting to the movement of the receivers.

His biggest sin, though, is inaccuracy. He's completed only 47.1 percent of his passes in his first two years. He's unsure. Being unsure leads to off-target tosses. To make matters worse, he's been bothered by tendinitis in his throwing shoulder that has kept him out of practice for almost three weeks, allowing Jon Kitna and Scott Mitchell to move ahead of him on the depth chart.

"Young quarterbacks tend to lose confidence if they have problems," Bratkowski said. "Last year, the team started two rookie receivers. That is not conducive to getting confidence. Look at Culpepper. He had Robert Smith in the backfield and guys to throw to like Randy Moss and Cris Carter."

Of the two, Couch, drafted two slots ahead of Smith, is closer to hitting the big time.

John Clayton is a senior NFL writer for ESPN.com.







 More from ESPN...
Mort: Ranking the NFL's QBs
ESPN's Chris Mortensen ranks ...

Pasquarelli: It's now or never for Bucs
The clock is ticking on the ...

Question of the Day: Coaches on the spot
ESPN's experts talk about the ...

 ESPN Tools
Email story
 
Most sent
 
Print story