NFL
Scores
Schedules
Standings
Statistics
Transactions
Injuries
Players
Message Board
NFL en español
FEATURES
NFL Draft
Super Bowl XXXVII
Photo gallery
Power Rankings
NFL Insider
CLUBHOUSE


ESPN MALL
TeamStore
ESPN Auctions
SPORT SECTIONS
Monday, July 10
 
Upon Further Review: Irvin's Canton-bound

By Joe Lago
ESPN.com

Michael Irvin
Michael Irvin is Dallas' all-time leader with 750 catches and 11,904 receiving yards.
Our last image of Michael Irvin isn't too flattering.

On the concrete masquerading as artificial turf at Philadelphia's Veterans Stadium, Irvin laid motionless after taking a blow to the head by Eagles safety Tim Hauck last October 10. That 8-yard gain with 5:16 left in the first quarter of Dallas' 13-10 loss to Philadelphia would be his 750th and final reception of his career.

Say what you want about the man affectionately known in Big D as "Playmaker." Call him arrogant -- some will even accuse him of being a cheat with the way referees allowed him to push off defensive backs -- but call Michael Irvin a Hall of Famer.

No way? Reserve judgment until you review the numbers of receivers already in Canton.

Irvin has more catches than Raymond Berry (631). He's gained more yards receiving than Lance Alworth (10,266). The best measuring stick to gauge his worthiness is Charlie Joiner. A possession receiver like Irvin, Joiner caught as many passes and touchdowns (65) as Irvin but did so in six more seasons during an 18-year career. Yes, Joiner can be found in Canton.

Comparing Irvin to Hall of Fame wide receivers
Name Rec Yds TDs
Michael Irvin 750 11,904 65
Charlie Joiner 750 12,146 65
Don Maynard 633 11,834 88
Raymond Berry 631 9,275 68
Fred Biletnikoff 589 8,964 76
Lance Alworth 542 10,266 85
Tommy McDonald 495 8,410 84
Don Hutson 488 7,991 99
Paul Warfield 427 8,565 85
Tom Fears 400 5,397 38

For those who believe Irvin's off-the-field problems have tainted his Hall of Fame résumé, just remember these two words: Lawrence Taylor.

Where does Irvin rate among the best receivers of his era? With Jerry Rice, Cris Carter and Herman Moore in his conference, Irvin managed to play in five Pro Bowls. He entered the 1999 season fourth among active pass catchers behind Rice, Andre Reed and Carter.

Irvin earned his place in the Hall by going where few receivers dared to venture -- over the middle of the field. Using his 6-foot-2, 207-pound frame to shield corners from the ball, he did so with ease to pick up a first down and set up another series of Emmitt Smith runs up the middle.

Speaking of Smith, he's a shoe-in for the Hall. So is Troy Aikman, who's one of only three quarterbacks to win three Super Bowls. The third component of Dallas' Big Three should get his day in the Ohio sun, too.

That image will be more appropriate to remember one of the game's best receivers of the '90s than that scary scene last October.

Joe Lago is the NFL editor for ESPN.com.





 More from ESPN...
Cowboys lose emotional leader as Irvin retires

 ESPN Tools
Email story
 
Most sent
 
Print story
 
Daily email