Darren Pang


NHL
Scores
Schedule
Standings
Statistics
Transactions
Injuries
Players
Message Board
NHL.com
Minor Leagues
FEATURES
Power Rankings
Playoff Matchups
Daily Glance
NHL Insider
CLUBHOUSE


ESPN MALL
TeamStore
ESPN Auctions
SPORT SECTIONS
Monday, March 24
Updated: May 22, 8:38 AM ET
 
Voting for Vezina? Look at the right numbers

By Darren Pang
Special to ESPN.com

The Vezina Trophy is awarded "to the goalkeeper adjudged to be the best at his position."

This will be one very difficult process for the NHL's general managers because we have seen brilliant performances from several worthy candidates, including ones that lifted non-playoff teams into the postseason.

I have often found that most observers, whether it is media, GMs or the players themselves, will lean far too often toward the goalie who has a very good reputation based on past performance and not necessarily the goalie who has actually played the best during the season.

That said, it is amazing that Martin Brodeur has never won the Vezina Trophy, as he has demonstrated just what consistency is all about. He hasn't received his full share of credit because the Devils are always a strong defensive team. Marty doesn't have to stand on his head every night and dominate games like so many in the league have to do. The Devils are always in the top three in the East, so there is never any desperation when it comes to just making the playoffs, which is the situation that earns many goalies the credit.

We certainly saw that last season with Jose Theodore. He caught everyone's attention down the stretch as he helped the Canadiens into the playoffs, then surprised many when he walked off with both the Vezina and the Hart Trophy at the awards ceremony. All season, most of us felt that Patrick Roy or Sean Burke would win at least the Vezina, and maybe even the Hart. When you have teams like Colorado and New Jersey, you expect them to win and be at the top of their conferences.

Imagine if in the last game of the season, Colorado HAD to win to get in the playoffs. Would we be throwing the same accolades toward Roy and claim how great he was to get them in? Or would people instead bemoan their position and call it disappointing? In those instances, we marvel about the acrobatic Theodore and forget about Roy or Burke.

Every team plays a different style so a goaltender on one team can see the same amount of shots as another, yet the quality of one will certainly differ than the other. A snap shot from the top of the circles counts just the same as a one-timer from the slot. These are two very different scoring chances, as we all know. A good goalie on a good team -- like Brodeur -- has to make three or four momentum-saving stops to win games 2-1. Whereas, a good goalie on a bad team can see 35 shots and give up four goals, but still get credit for bailing out his team, even if one of those goals was a terrible one. When you face fewer shots, and your team is out shooting the opponent, the magnifying glass is at its strongest and is focused on scrutinizing the goal(s) against. The best example is clearly Brodeur in New Jersey.

Another valid argument, in terms of difficulty in shots against, is how many times a team is shorthanded. This is an area that I hope the GMs look at before casting their votes. Let's take a closer look at four top candidates for the Vezina Trophy and how often their teams were shorthanded:

  • Martin Brodeur, New Jersey Devils: The Devils are the second-best disciplined team, spending only 11.4 minutes per game in the box. They have faced only 242 power plays and have been on the power play 275 times (+ 33). The key stat for Brodeur is his 23-14 record in tough one-goal games, with the league's top-ranked penalty-killing unit. He leads in wins with 38, ranks fifth in GAA (2.10) and is tied for the league lead with eight shutouts. He is not in the top five in save percentage.

  • Ed Belfour, Toronto Maple Leafs: Toronto is ranked 27th in penalty minutes per game at 17.0. They have faced 397 power plays and have had a man advantage 334 times (-63). While their penalty killing is very good (third-best in the NHL), the quality of shots that he faces is much higher than that of Brodeur, in most cases. He has won 33 games, stopped 92 percent of the shots he faces, and has posted seven shutouts. The Leafs are 18-13 in one-goal games.
  • Marty Turco, Dallas Stars: There are two arguments with regards to his injury, which shelved him for 18 games. During that time he could have gone into a tailspin that would have hurt his numbers or he would have continued his great play and separated himself from the pack. His value showed in his return to the lineup; he gives this team confidence and swagger. The Stars have had 303 power plays for and have been on the kill 320 times (-17). Their penalty kill ranks fifth. At 5-on-5, the Stars are one of the best, scoring 47 more goals than they have given up. He has won 26 games while stopping an NHL-best 93 percent of the shots he has faced. He leads the league with a remarkably low 1.76 GAA.

  • Jean-Sebastien Giguere, Anaheim Mighty Ducks: They have the second-best penalty-killing unit (87.5 percent) and spend just 11.7 minutes per game in the box, which ranks third in the league. They have had 324 power plays compared to 313 penalty kill situations (+11). He will receive plenty of recognition, as he's helped get the Ducks get back into the playoffs after an extended layoff. He has been a difference maker for the Ducks and continues to improve. He is currently tied for fourth in wins with 32, while also throwing in seven shutouts. The Ducks are 23-13 in one-goal games. The next tier of candidates are:
  • Patrick Lalime, Ottawa Senators: The Senators have long been one of the most disciplined teams in the NHL, but this season they are ranked ninth in penalty minutes per game with 13.6. They've been on the power play 359 times and have been shorthanded 311 (+48). Their PK is ranked 11th at 84.2 percent. They are 15-11 in one-goal games. Lalime is tied for first in shutouts with eight and is tied for second in wins with 36.

  • Dwayne Roloson, Minnesota Wild: If they didn't rotate goalies he would be right there with the other guys; his season has been brilliant. He is second in GAA at 1.89 and he's tied with Turco in save percentage at 93 percent.

  • Roman Cechmanek, Philadelphia Flyers: He is the beneficiary of a tight defensive team and, as his numbers show, has enjoyed a great season. His GAA is third, at 1.95, and his save percentage is fourth, at 92 percent.

  • Dan Cloutier, Vancouver Canucks: Because of his knee injury, the attention surrounding him has dissipated, but he has enjoyed a spectacular season and still is in the top five in wins with 32. He has shown a very resilient side to his character and has improved his movement and patience in the net.

    In the end, I think Ed Belfour should win the Vezina for the third time in his career – and the first time since 1993 when he was a member of the Blackhawks. I have spoken to many of my friends for are former goalies and are broadcasting around the NHL and the consensus is that Brodeur, Belfour and either Turco or Giguere will round out the three finalists, with Roloson, Cloutier and Lalime receiving recognition as well. Brodeur may very well win his first Vezina and there wouldn't be much argument. He has been the difference in so many low scoring games, especially earlier in the season when the Devils couldn't score more than two goals per game and they were still winning or tying.

    Darren Pang, a former goaltender with the Chicago Blackhawks, is a hockey analyst for ESPN. His goalie rankings appear every other week in Net Effect.





  •  More from ESPN...
    Darren Pang Archive

     ESPN Tools
    Email story
     
    Most sent
     
    Print story
     
    Daily email