espn.com scoreboard schedule message board history video gallery NHL on espn.com

Saturday, April 27
Updated: April 27, 8:28 AM ET
 
McLaren vs. Zednik: A formula for disaster

By Nancy Marrapese-Burrell
Special to ESPN.com

One day, Bruins' defenseman Kyle McLaren was a hard-hitting, passionate and feared NHL player. In a span of a split second in Montreal on Thursday night in Game 4 of their first-round playoff series, he became Public Enemy No. 1 throughout much of the Quebec province.

The crushing hit on Canadiens' forward Richard Zednik, delivered with 1:17 remaining in regulation when McLaren drove his left forearm into Zednik's head, was disturbing and jarring and no doubt will have serious consequences.

It promises to be the lightning rod for the rest of the series which resumes this afternoon at the FleetCenter. Will coach Michel Therrien follow through on his threats to retaliate against Boston's best players -- namely Bill Guerin and Joe Thornton? Will the Habs go after goalie Byron Dafoe, who has vastly outplayed the highly touted Jose Theodore?

Commissioner Gary Bettman said vigilante justice won't be tolerated and he has told that to both the Canadiens and Bruins but tensions are running very high.

To wit:

  • It didn't take long for the series to deteriorate into mass hysteria. Therrien's rant about Robbie Ftorek engineering all of this (Is he talking about the same Robbie Ftorek I've seen every day all year?) is simply preposterous. As badly as Therrien lost his logic, he appeared to also have lost his mind in the process.

  • The feel-good story of the year?? When the series started, the good vibes were flowing like Niagara Falls. Instead of being the hate-fest this series has deteriorated into now, there were smiles all around. Both teams were celebrating the remarkable and inspiring comeback of Saku Koivu. Not only is Koivu back being captain and in the lineup, he is nowhere near a token forward. He has been a real force for the Canadiens and has been effective after moving to center.

  • Theodore had an astonishing run at the end of the regular season. It can be argued convincingly that he is the reason the Canadiens even made it to the playoffs. But since arriving into the postseason, he hasn't been on top of his game and doesn't look like the MVP candidate he did earlier. He vows to keep working, which is admirable, but he hasn't come close to stealing a game for this team which may have to happen in order for them to have a chance to win.

  • As much as there is concern for Zednik and the hit he took -- all completely warranted -- what seems to be missing here is the acknowledgment that hockey is a full contact sport. Was McLaren's hit on Zednik punishing? Absolutely. Was it bone crunching? Obviously. Was it dirty? The Habs say yes. The Bruins say no. The truth is, Zednik had his head down, McLaren had his arm up. Zednik was in the offensive zone, with the puck, and on his way to the net. McLaren was determined to stop him. In other words, it was a formula for disaster.

    "If you look at the hit, he used his arm," said goalie Byron Dafoe. "It wasn't an elbow, he didn't look for it, he didn't try to slash him in the head, he just made a good hit."

    Good? No. High? Yes. The league has been cracking down on hits to the head and for obvious reasons. In fairness on the other side, McLaren is a player who has been through a lot. He has weathered many hurdles in his career because of serious injuries. Many of those have come as a result of the punishing style he plays, something he would freely admit. Despite his impressive resume, he had no previous suspensions on his record although it's likely the high profile nature of this hit will taint him for years to come.

    "I think the whole thing has been blown out of proportion," said Bruins' veteran defenseman Sean O'Donnell. "I've only been here a year but it gets around the league that Kyle is not known as a dirty player. I think Mac's record speaks for itself. When I played on the West Coast, I never heard one person say he was a dirty hitter."

    Some have compared McLaren's tactics to Toronto's Tie Domi. Nothing could be further from the truth.

    "That's ludicrous," said Dafoe. "Tie Domi went out of his way to hurt [Scott Niedermayer]. Kyle was just doing his job as a defenseman, to take a hit on a forward attacking him with the puck. It was completely different. Kyle has never had a history of this as far as suspensions, Kyle throughout the entire game had no reason to go after anybody, let alone Zednik. So show me the motive. It was just an unfortunate incident."

    Nancy Marrapese-Burrell of the Boston Globe is a regular contributor to ESPN.com.

  • Series Page


     ALSO SEE

    Nancy Marrapese-Burrell Archive

     ESPN Tools
    Email story
     
    Most sent
     
    Print story
     


    espn.com abcsports.com home