Keyword
OLYMPIC SPORTS
Schedule
Message Board
SPORT SECTIONS
Monday, April 22
 
Officials seek scoring alternative amid scandal

Associated Press

NEW YORK -- Hoping to head off future scandals like the one that rocked the Salt Lake City Olympics, figure skating officials are looking into computerized evaluations of judges that could detect national biases.

The International Skating Union's technical committee had been examining such a system for the past two years. When the scandal broke in February, even more urgency was attached to revamping the way the sport is judged.

Since then, ISU president Ottavio Cinquanta has decided to make his own proposal about overhauling the way judges operate. He must present his idea at least 15 days before the ISU Congress meets in Kyoto, Japan, in June.

Until then, the technical committee's work is on hold.

"It may, in fact, happen someday, but right now it's on hold until work can be done" on Cinquanta's proposal, said Ron Pfenning, a U.S. member of the technical committee who also was the referee of the controversial pairs event at the Winter Games.

Cinquanta ordered duplicate gold medals awarded to a Canadian couple, Jaime Sale and David Pelletier, after judging improprieties were discovered. A Russian couple, Elena Berezhnaya and Anton Sikharulidze, initially won the gold.

The technical committee's computer system would rely on a complex mathematical formula that took into account every mark a judge has awarded at a competition.

Pfenning said this method "would be a tool, and it's an evaluation that's totally objective."

"The same principles are being applied to every judge at every competition throughout that whole season. It provides a foundation of consistency throughout the world," he said.

It also could provide evidence that a judge favored teams from a specific country or region. If a judge consistently voted higher for competitors from the same nation than other judges, the computer analysis would show it. That judge then could be subject to disciplinary action by the ISU.

The same would be true for other judging discrepancies, even if they don't involve national bias.

"It's only when someone is in really quite a solo position ... that they would receive a less than positive evaluation on that part," Pfenning said.

Pfenning will be in Lausanne, Switzerland, next week for an ISU hearing with Marie-Reine Le Gougne, the French judge for the Olympic pairs competition whose vote was nullified. Le Gougne at first said she was pressured by Didier Gailhaguet, head of the French Olympic team and France's skating federation, to "vote a certain way." She later denied such pressure, but was suspended by the ISU pending the hearing.




 More from ESPN...
French judge in scandal fires back at ISU
Attorneys for the French ...

 ESPN Tools
Email story
 
Most sent
 
Print story