Change for change's sake
By Dan Shanoff
Special to Page 2

INDIANAPOLIS -- A secret memo to senior members of the NCAA Executive Committee was passed along to Page 2 by a high-level source inside the association. The document details a radical change to the Bowl Championship Series system.

Fearing even more snide remarks from the public about the computer-ranking portion of the BCS caluculations, the NCAA is giving serious consideration to replacing the eight computer rankings with a slate of new judges. The contenders were evaluated by an unnamed member of the NCAA staff. Here are the key excerpts of the secret memo:

Candidates for the BCS panel
Candidate Pros Cons
Mel Kiper

Has no problems with decisiveness The hair
Notre Dame coaching candidates Everyone's included! School doesn't remember what BCS is
Joey Harrington

Seems to think he has answers Only a "show" in Heisman race
Florida fans Nothing better to do A wee bit anti-Vol
LSU coaching staff SEC title game experience Coming from SEC West, can they recognize good teams?
Gary Barnett

Knows how to make a good case That fake punt vs. Texas
The Bowden family Down-home folksiness Bobby's cowboy hat = poor judgment
BYU boosters Understand "undefeated" Don't understand "TV ratings matter"
If there is a willingness to go a different direction than that whole "they really should be familiar with football" hang-up, then perhaps we could consider:
The Stanford band Too clever ... ... for their own good
The "Oceans 11" gang

Bernie Mac, Matt Damon Donald Sutherland
Our member-schools' sports information directors Sympathetic to the NCAA's need for "clarity" Don't they already vote in the coaches' poll?
Shaq and Kobe

Know championships L.A. bias?
Real World New York II housemates Squabble in best tradition of rankings-meisters Perhaps too much attention-draining other drama
*N Sync

Inroads into the elusive "tweens" market "It's Gonna Be(C.S.)" anthem just misses the mark
The combined casts of "Law and Order" shows Good at solving mysteries There's enough sanctimony in college football as is
Magic 8-Ball

Can see the future That thorny "Ask again later" issue

Dan Shanoff is a regular contributor to Page 2.




TALKIN' BCS

ALSO SEE:


Dan Shanoff Archive





ESPN TOOLS
 
Email story
 
Most sent
 
Print story
 




espn Page 2 index