ESPN Network: ESPN.com | RPM | NBA.com | NHL.com | ESPNdeportes | ABCSports | FANTASY  
rpm.espn.com
rpm.espn.com
rpm.espn.com




Thursday, March 7

Robin Miller's Mailbag
Robin Miller answers user mail
ESPN.com

Check out what questions RPM.ESPN.com users had for Robin Miller -- and Robin's answers.




Will Memo Gidley get a permanent ride in CART this year? And, do you have any insight on why Ganassi went with Bruno Junquiera over Gidley for this season? Love your work.

Dan McDonald
Chicago

Robin Miller: Sadly, after three podiums and leading a ton of laps despite no testing with Target, Memo has nothing but his thumb out at the moment. Maybe something for Indy but, unless somebody gets nicked, he's a spectator again. Very disturbing for CART, at least it should be (along with Buddy Rice having nothing for the second straight year). Thanks for watching and reading.




British web sites keep reporting that Johnny Herbert will be in CART and/or the Indy 500 this year. What are you hearing on this side of the Atlantic? Also, when will CART/IRL return to Las Vegas?

Chris Cook
Las Vegas

Robin Miller: Give Johnny high marks for having great PR but he's got nothing going in CART (I asked Sigma owner Tom Wieringa because that's where Autosport had him going two weeks ago and he said he'd never met or spoke to Mr. H. He might have something going for Indy but who knows? Not sure there will be an open wheel race again in Vegas because it's so tough to draw people but it's a great race track. I'd rather see CART open the season in Vegas than in Mexico.




Why do you think Michael Andretti, at age 39, is on his way out? Last year, with a new team, less than six months to put everything together, he ended up third. A couple of mistakes on his part, and some mechanical problems, he could have done better in the points. There are teams that have been together a lot longer, with good drivers that just can't get right. I think he will do much better this year. And I agree with you, he will win the 500 this year, that track owes him.

Leo Barreca
Girard, Ohio

Robin Miller: I'm not sure how much long Mikey will drive past 40 but while he's not the throttle psycho he was 10 years ago, he's learned patience and is still very capable of running up front. He just needs to qualify better. If he quits CART, he might just run Indy for a couple of years but I don't think he's made any definitive decisions just yet.




It seems several top CART teams will be switching midseason from the Reynard to Lola chassis. Why the change and why midseason?

Terry McCabe
Chicago

Robin Miller: Because Reynard is in dire financial straits and nobody can be sure there will be an ongoing development program. The rub is that everyone is almost out of test days so they'll be pretty far behind the regular Lola teams.




I have been searching but haven't heard anything about Airton Dare catching a ride with an IRL team after that impressive showing at Miami? Have you heard anything? Would Calkins go with Greg Ray over Dare?

Andy Norman
Dallas

Robin Miller: You mean Aaron? (that's what A.J. called him last weekend). He may get to drive for Beechler at Phoenix as he recovers from his concussion but I've tried to get a hold of Foyt a couple times to see if Dare has a chance to keep the seat. Imagine A.J. with a driver from Brazil and Chile. I think Buzz is going to take Shigeaki Hattori's money for a few races, Ray still has nothing at the moment.




Please help! I'm confused! Greg Ray was to be driving for Kelley Racing. Little Al was without a ride due to lack of funding for Galles. Then, Little Al gets funding from Corteco (whoever the heck they are). However, instead of funding the ride with Galles, he bumps Ray from Kelley. What gives? Ray won't or can't comment. Any insight? Thanks and I look forward to your comments on Open Wheel Wednesday.

Brent Stiles
Cincinnati

Robin Miller: The only reasoning I can come up with is that TGeorge pays Unser a lot of money and Unser remains the IRL's biggest name (or one of) and I guess the Corteco folks were more impressed with an Unser than a Ray. Kelley says Ray promised to bring money and Greg says that's not true so who knows unless we see the contract. Thanks for watching.




Since Chris Pook took over at CART, I haven't heard a word about the planned Masters series CART was going to do with the Cobras. Is it still going to happen or has it been dropped? In my opinion, there is a ton of old CART equipment lying around that would be much more fun to see them use if they did do something like that.

Art Laski, Jr.
Riverside, Calif.

Robin Miller: That's one of the questions we're going to be asking this weekend in Mexico but I would think the Masters series might be a goner. I think Pook wants to spend more time and money on today's drivers and teams, but then it's always fun to see Mario and Parnelli competing in anything. But not old CART cars. These guys can't see that far.




Sam Hornish and Panther Racing have Homestead figured out, let's give them that, but do you think Penske's two cars finishing second and third is a preview of the remainder of the year in the IRL? Also, why do you think the FIA officials ruined the F1 opener by not red flagging the race after the tremendous first turn of the first lap wreck?

Tim Cole
Washington, Mich.

Robin Miller: I picked Castroneves to win the championship because it's 15 races, but Hornish will certainly win his share of races. He's definitely got Homestead dialed in, so we'll see. But remember Penske's strengths the past two years were on road courses. They were good on ovals, just not dominant. But I understand Penske was really pissed after getting his butt kicked last weekend. Some CART fans wonder if the Pennzoil team had an unfair advantage (light car, no rev limiter, big fuel tank), but I don't think that's true. Sam is damn good and so is Andy Brown (engineer) and they were so hooked up in the two corners (3-4) everyone else couldn't handle. As for F1, absolutely, that's why they have that rule. The fans got screwed and it sounded like the announcers were perplexed as to that call, as well.




I've heard you and many others talk about one of CART's deficiencies being the fact there are many foreign drivers "buying rides." Does this term mean these drivers are using their "personal" finances to buy a ride, that they have secured the backing of a corporate sponsor on their own and brought them to an established team or is it a combination of the two? If it means a driver has simply found a company to support his involvement in a particular series, as Al Unser Jr. did recently, then why are foreign-born drivers the only ones in CART that can seemingly accomplish this?

Ben Woodson
Irving, Texas

Robin Miller: Good question. In the late '80s and early '90s CART had a lot more ride-buyers than it does today but there are still a few. The IRL is also a ride-buyer nation, it's just cheaper. For instance, Tora Takagi and Toyota are keeping Walker Racing going with money and free engines. Michel Jourdain kept Team Rahal a two-car team by bringing a new sponsor and that's the only reason he's got a ride. I think Honda helps Shinji Nakano stay in CART. Many of the CART drivers are on big retainers and are more hired guns, while the IRL has a few decent salaries but many of the drivers rely on a percentage of the purse (which is 10 times better than CART's pathetic purse). It does seem like foreign drivers have more success than Americans at finding big money and maybe that's because this country is so over-saturated with motorsports.




Is ISC coming close to violating antitrust laws by using its virtual monopoly on major tracks to squeeze out CART for the IRL?

David Chao
Pittsburgh, Pa.

Robin Miller: I don't think that would fly, it's free enterprise and you have the right to align yourself with whomever you feel like is your best partner. Does ISC want to see CART die? Absolutely. But don't forget Bill France was a big reason George started the IRL and divided open wheel racing which, oh by the way, has destroyed TV ratings, oval track crowds and identity while NASCAR continues to pull away. ISC is now trying to screw with CART's race in Miami, but I don't think it violates any laws -- yet.




Since Sam Hornish Jr. is proving he was no fluke last year as he dominated over the CART refugees in Miami, would you consider him the brightest American star in open wheel racing? If he continues the domination, would F1 be interested in him? Or would they still insist on someone coming through the European development series (i.e. F3000)? As a former CART feeder guy (meaning he can make a right turn or two), plus his age, he sounds like a marketer's dream as the next American F1 star who can have crossover appeal.

S. W. Lee
Indianapolis

Robin Miller: I watched Sam win an Atlantic race in '99 and was impressed with him in his first IRL season with PDM Racing. The kid is very good and has excellent car control, but I doubt if F1 is in his future. It could be because he's got the skills and a road racing background, but I don't think he wants to basically go to Europe and start over in the F2 feeder system. If Rahal had stayed at Jaguar, who knows? But I was hoping Buddy Rice might be that next guy and now his career has come to a halt. Maybe Patrick Long, he's done well in Europe and is only a pup.




CART 1, IRL 0. Robin, you are an excellent writer, but get real. Yes, Hornish won, that's great, but the reports of 50 fans Thursday and 65 on Friday don't sound like a victory for me. I know ESPN paid you to write that article, but you've become who you are by telling the truth, not employer-sponsored propaganda. P.S. The fact Hornish lapped both of Penske's car's seemed very NASCAR-ish, didn't it. Think Tony gave Sam "The Call?" No doubt.

Michael Panosh
Madison, Wisc.

Robin Miller: Can I have permission to send this note to all the IRL zealots who think I'm on CART's payroll or so unfair? Hey, oval track crowds always suck on Thursdays and Fridays and Saturdays (except Milwaukee) regardless of what series it is. That's why a two-day show is the only smart thing to do. The race crowd looked to be 25,000 to 30,000, which is about what CART drew its last year in Florida. So I guess you're right, it wasn't a financial victory, just a morale victory for the IRL. Some people feel like Hornish got "The Call," but wouldn't the IRL want to save it for Indy, where they were stomped last May? Indy means a lot more than Homestead or Phoenix. We'll see. I know Penske was livid afterwards, but for exactly what reason I don't know as yet.




In open wheel racing if you are not successful you will not get a ride. But in NASCAR, I see drivers that have been on the circuit for 10 to 15 years that have a couple of wins or no wins at all! Could you explain that to me?

Jorge Gonzalez
Las Vegas

Robin Miller: Shame on you for pointing out what a fraud NASCAR has become. There are so many coast and collectors in NASCAR making millions (can you say Mike Skinner or Michael Waltrip) that nobody wants to rock the boat. They make a fortune on merchandising because the stock car crowd worships them. I cannot explain that except to offer that the Dukes of Hazard was a successful TV show.




I know even you can't compare the boring IRL (with Hornish lapping the field) and boring F1 (once Schumacher got by Montoya, which was a foregone conclusion, he ran away and there were almost no cars on the track), with the exciting NASCAR race. Who was going to win? The rookie Newman, strong and consistent Marlin, Tony Stewart running the bottom with his left side wheels below the white line. Then the yellow flag changed everything, wow, what a race! No winner has started higher than 19th, which is why provisionals are so important!. Unlike F1, where if you don't get in front of Schumacher in the first corner it is over. NASCAR rules for close, exciting racing where you have to watch the whole race, not have the race like IRL and F1 when you already know Hornish and Schumacher were locks at halfway point.

Mark Delledonne
Greenville

Robin Miller: I cannot disagree that last weekend's NASCAR show was easily the only good watch on TV and it featured quite a bit of drama and passing. But Daytona was a crushing bore (one pass on the track for the lead in three hours) and NAPCAR can always put you to sleep at Michigan or Phoenix or Homestead. The IRL usually has much closer finishes and F1, well unless Montoya is running, it's pretty sad.




Your column and insight is great and I have always found you to be very honest in your opinions; you always tell it just like it is. So I must double check my feelings with you about the IRL race at Miami on Saturday. I thought this was supposed to be the "breakthrough" year for the IRL. However, the preliminary attendance reports I have seen do not seem to suggest that (especially Thursday and Friday numbers). In watching the IRL race I saw:

a) One driver dominated and put a lap on the field.
b) Three cars finish on the lead lap separated by five seconds each (at least)
c) Approximately 50 laps of yellow flags.
d) At least four drivers spin on their own (that is to say, they did not make contact with another car; they just flat lost it)
e) A field comprised of many foreign-born road racers (many more of those than any short track guys)
f) Three or four passes for the lead and not that much action in the rest of the pack (how much passing can their be when eight to 10 cars drop out?)

So, did you notice the same race I did -- a minor league series with a few "name" drivers? I never had a problem with any of the things I pointed out when I started following Indy Car racing in the late '80s. Supposedly TG did. Well, he didn't do too much to fix half of what he had a hissy fit about in '95. What's next? And do you really think the American public is going to buy this? Miami sure didn't.

Erik Corredor
Auburn, Ala.

Robin Miller: Thanks for your passionate note. Homestead wasn't a good venue for CART and it won't be for the IRL (especially on Saturdays) and even with cheaper ticket prices. Having said that, Phoenix had 56,000 people in '95 for the last CART race and hasn't drawn half of that since the IRL took over. Nazareth gradually declined in attendance and don't expect miracles there. Of course, remember the terrific crowds at Loudon, N.H. and Dover, former IRL venues. CART's Chicago race has steadily gone downhill in attendance and so had Michigan, despite hosting three great races. The open wheel fan seems to be angry and confused because of the split and you're preaching to the choir about '95, when CART was kicking butt and filling seats everywhere. With Penske, Ganassi and Mo Nunn, the IRL is deeper than it's ever been but the overall lack of depth, funding and preparation still leaves the races looking like an IMSA show with four or five different classes. Just remember, there were 22 road racers/foreigners out of 26 drivers last Sunday, the IRL now has the same thing as CART's evil franchise system and, last time I checked, A.J. Foyt wasn't building his own engine. The IRL and CART have become brothers haven't they?




Looking at the crowd, or more correctly the lack of a crowd at Homestead, how can a promoter afford to put on an IRL race? The TV money goes to the IRL, so ticket sales must pay the promoters expenses, right? How long can a promoter afford to take a bath? Will the IRL come down to one race in May?

Rick Smith
San Diego

Robin Miller: If TGeorge pays the purse, you might be surprised how a promoter can make it. But the IRL tickets are tied into NASCAR at K.C. so that's a big bonus and the tickets are half as much as CART races were at Michigan and Homestead so, with a sponsor, it's possible to make money. Provided you don't have to pay that $1 million purse.




It was cool to meet you down in Homestead. I was wondering why the IRL does not do something that makes for great racing, like putting all the lead lap cars together, and not have them separated by a bunch of lapped cars. That would have made for a great finish at Homestead, with Gil de Ferran and Helio Castroneves behind Sam Hornish Jr., or at least a little more interesting. Not that I did not enjoy watching them race through the field, but there was no one else who looked close to staying up with Hornish besides them.

Andrew Heckman
Ft. Lauderdale, Fla.

Robin Miller: Very few of the IRL races have been runaways and the cars/engines/rules make for keeping things close, not to mention all the yellows. Watch one of their shows at Texas, you won't be bored.




I know traction control in CART is now irreversible, but it nags me as a true fan of open wheel racing to see technology again take away some of the skills needed to race these cars. Modulation of the gas on an 800-plus horsepower car exiting corners separated the men from the boys and now all they have to do is "stand on it." What's next, taking away manual shifting like F1 did? Also, since I know you love open wheel racing and know as well as any true fan that NASCAR is not the place to see real racing, don't you think we would soften up on NASCAR if they would increase their road races from just two to around eight venues. I have to admit watching those good old boys shifting and braking is a whole lotta fun compared to their usual mind numbing left turn marathons.

Jeff Spofford
Long Beach, Calif.

Robin Miller: I agree, I enjoy NAPCAR on road courses, it's much more exciting than several of their oval shows. As for traction control, many would say it's been going on since 1994 (wink, wink) and it's simply part of the evolution. I just hate the thought of all Indy cars have rev limiters and WOO rear wings and taking away "edge" required to handle a current champ car.

Send this story to a friend | Most sent stories
 

Related
Submit your questions to Robin Miller

Robin Miller answers user mail, Feb. 24

Robin Miller answers user mail, Jan. 11

Robin Miller answers user mail, Dec. 8

Robin Miller answers user mail, Dec. 2

Robin Miller answers user mail, Nov. 15

Robin Miller answers user mail: Nov. 12

Robin Miller answers user mail: Oct. 11

Robin Miller answers user mail: Sept. 26

Robin Miller answers user mail: Sept. 10

RPM user comment central

Sports Mall