| ESPN Network: ESPN.com | RPM | NBA.com | NHL.com | ESPNdeportes | ABCSports | FANTASY | |
![]() |
|
|
| |
|
Wednesday, August 28 Updated: September 23, 7:15 PM ET Robin Miller answers user mail ESPN.com Check out what questions RPM.ESPN.com users had for Robin Miller -- and Robin's answers:
Do you have any idea how serious the talk is about next year's Cleveland CART race being under the lights? If they do it, I guarantee nobody will be doubting the attendance figures. Bob Hengen Columbus, Ohio Robin Miller: Pook sounds like it's going to be a night show and it will be a big deal.
CART said at the start of the season it would use more local cautions this year, but only one of the caution's at the Canada race was even close to needing a full-course caution. People pay good money to see racing -- let's see more green flag racing and pit stops. This is what racing is all about. James Mayfield Houston Robin Miller: I agree the worst thing about those full-course yellows is all the time is takes to tow somebody in or to a safe haven or wherever. But they don't have enough cranes yet (like F1) and some drivers unfortunately don't think about finding a safe place to park when they blow up. Other times, it's impossible, but at least they're racing longer and harder this year with the new fuel specs. Look at Cleveland and Mid-Ohio for examples.
With recent speculation that the IRL may eventually yet again veer off of its original plan and run a few road courses in the future (most likely Watkins Glen, N.Y.), I was wondering if anyone ever tested an IRL car on a road course? I would be curious to see how the acceleration in the IRL 3.5-liter normally-aspirated engine would compare to the turbos of CART. I would also be interested in the road course handling characteristics of an IRL machine since they seem more elementary than a Lola or Reynard. George Phillips Nashville, Tenn. Robin Miller: Watkins Glen will be on the sked and maybe IMS as a footnote to the USGP. The new IRL cars will afford fueling out of both sides, so it's a given. As for testing, I think they might have tested here recently but I'm not sure. Those cars would look like Atlantics compared to a Champ Car on a road course. Gee, Tony George has engine leases, franchises, lots of foreign road racers, a race in Japan and now some road courses. Isn't that special?
Thanks for all the insider news. Any chance Rusty Wallace would ever run the Indy 500? Would Roger Penske entertain the idea? How about Helio Castroneves or Gil de Ferran at the Daytona 500? John Cassidy Wilmington, Del. Robin Miller: Rusty Wallace is way too old, smart and rich to do anything that crazy. Maybe 15 years ago, but not now. Penske tried Sneva and Bettenhausen in NASCAR, but that was a long time ago. I doubt it.
Can you comment on the IRL attendance on Friday and Saturday, especially Friday, at Gateway this past weekend? How does this compare to CART's attendance at Montreal this past weekend? Which series drew more, and what series has drawn more fans for the season? It seems the "CART is dead" reporting is more media bias than fact. Yes, CART has had its problems, but the series has many positives, too. Michael Panosh Manitowoc, Wisc. Robin Miller: CART drew 47,000 on Friday, 60,000 on Saturday and they announced 64,000 on Sunday, but the local media said there was more like 75,000. Doubt if there was anybody at Gateway on Friday or Saturday and I noticed The Indianapolis Star reported 36,000 for the race. Hmmm, seems to me that grandstand at Gateway only holds 31,000 and it didn't look half full. Yes, CART is in trouble as far as car count for 2003, but it still has quite a large fan following across the globe. And they don't have to buy NASCAR tickets, either.
Chris Pook said in a chat session on ESPN.com that CART was looking at gas-powered V-10 engines for 2005. What is the reasoning behind that? Alex Ardussi Bantam, Conn. Robin Miller: He's been to Europe a couple times and obviously feels there might be interested manufacturers with those specs. Finding somebody to fuel the cars might be difficult, however.
I know Michael Andretti's decision is not official yet, but what do you make of this comment by Chris Pook?
"Well, I'm not sure how much talent is going over to the IRL. I think the guys that consistently qualify on the front part of our grid our with us. The more senior ones who qualify in the back part of the grid -- I think the IRL provides a good retirement opportunity for them."
Robin Miller: Michael is long gone to the IRL, trust me, and that was just a little shot given to him by Pook.
Was Chris Pook serious about wanting CART to become a feeder series for Formula One? In the Montreal Gazette he was reported to have said, "I'd love CART to be a feeder series for F1. My predecessors thought that CART was an alternative to F1. I don't believe that. I'm 180 degrees from that. F1 is at a level and class of its own. We fit in somewhere below them. It would be great if we could develop drivers to go there." Is he trying to develop a tie-in with F1 so they may eventually takeover CART? Is that why V-10 gas-powered engines are a possibility for 2005? Your insights would be most appreciated. Stephen P. Brown Brighton, Colo. Robin Miller: I think Pook is trying to point out that it's an honor to have F1 snatch up CART's champions every few years and, to some point, I agree. It says something for CART's on-track reputation. But it's tough to build any fan following when you lose Jacques Villeneueve, Alex Zanardi, Juan Pablo Montoya and maybe Cristiano da Matta. Pook has spent some time in Europe talking with engine manufacturers so that's where his V-10 idea got legs.
Well, as you may already know, Tomas Scheckter was quoted as saying he was refused entry into the pits at Kentucky when he reported a tire problem. They then quoted Bobby Rahal as saying that he would love to see Scheckter in CART. What do you know about this? Scheckter is a talented driver, he has probably the most laps led in the IRL if not in the top-five, he led the most laps at Indy, but he has not finished his races. What can we find out about this situation? Adolfo Rodriguez Killeen, Texas Robin Miller: I was told that another team saw Scheckter's tire going down, but failed to report it to his team. That would be very sad if true but nothing would surprise me. Scheckter told me last month he wanted to get back to F1 and he knows he's got to go road racing again so CART would be a logical choice. There seems to be interest in him, but Eddie Cheever sounds like he holds the key since he's got his contract for 2003.
Love your coverage of open wheel racing. What's the latest on Penske's drivers? I heard a rumor that Castroneves may be testing with Toyota in F1. And after Michigan, de Ferran looked downright mad about being in IRL. Any chance he may end up back in CART? Tony Dinelli Tulsa, Okla. Robin Miller: I wouldn't be surprised to see Gil quit at the end of this season, especially if he wins the title. My Autosport boys say a test for Castroneves is in the works. How about Sam Hornish to Penske? Don't bet against it.
It seems as though we are seeing more and more blown engines in CART recently. How much effort is Honda and Toyota really putting into their last remaining days with CART before they jump to the IRL? Bruce Woloshyn San Diego, Calif. Robin Miller: I can't imagine either one slacking off to the point of not trying to win every race because they hate each other so much.
I'd like to be a fan of both CART and IRL. How come the races are broadcast on top of each other, so both series lose out? To watch them both, you have to switch back and forth, and end up missing most of both races. Both series could have a lot of us as fans, if the schedule allowed it. Cheryl O'Donnell Las Vegas Robin Miller: Good point. Of course you need the cooperation of both to try and avoid conflicts when possible but that requires both sides wanting it to happen. When they've gone head-to-head on regular TV this year, both seem to always end up at 1.1 or 1.2, so obviously the audience is divided and neither series can benefit as NASCAR rides away into the sunset. The IRL does have three night races to try and get away from NASCAR and any head-to-head with CART, but those have been their worst-rated races for some reason. Makes no sense because Texas is always their best show under the lights.
Considering the changes and in many ways improvements that Chris Pook has made with CART this year, what do you feel must be done for the IRL and CART to coexist? Also, what do you feel must be done for them to grow and feed off each other? Sam Mancuso Hollywood, Fla. Robin Miller: As I stated in an answer above, they are coexisting, but it's still a civil war and that, as history tells us, is the worst kind of conflict. Tony George wants CART dead and buried and CART's owners may have finally figured that out in the past year. They cannot grow or feed off each other. A united series is the only hope of returning open wheel to the prominence it had in 1995. But that appears to be a long way off.
Patrick Carpentier replacing Christian Fittipaldi at Newman-Haas would not be a bad career move, but why do you think he and not Alex Tagliani is being cast off to make room for Paul Tracy? (Your assessment of the JV/BAR/Player's situation makes sense, too.) Also, what about Kenny Brack's dismal season at Ganassi? Since he failed to get Ricky Rudd, maybe Chip can put him in his third Cup car and form a tag team with Jimmy Spencer! Or is Brack headed back to the IRL with A.J. Foyt? John Weaver Camp Hill, Pa. Robin Miller: Gerry Forsythe wants to keep Carpentier at Player's, so it should be interesting since Tagliani already has a contract and Tracy is coming on board. Villeneuve's agent supposedly demanded $60 million to go to CART and come back for his final two years with BAR, so that's not going to happen. Could Player's farm out Tagliani? Or will Carpentier end up with Ganassi or somebody in the IRL? Like Andretti?
What is the latest rumor about Max Papis? I know he has a ride at the Petit Le Mans in October, but what else is there? Does he have a ride for next year? Dan Hajek Waukesha, Wisc Robin Miller: I heard today he was testing a Winston Cup car. But he's got nothing in CART at the moment. Maybe if Arciero fields a CART team in 2003.
One way to increase passing in CART is to draw for positions. It has never made any sense for any sport to put the best in front to start. Cleveland was a better race last year when qualifying got screwed up. Give the traditional backmarkers a shot to prove they can compete or at least get exposure for their sponsors. A draw would be more interesting than most qualifying sessions! What do you think? Mike Gruber Lakeland, Fla. Robin Miller: I think it's a super idea for television and the fans, but it ain't gonna fly with the teams. I'd love to see inverted starts and purses paid according to positions improved.
I hate the idea of this happening, but I have to ask. If CART was to fold and all of CART's teams move to the IRL. Do you think Tony George would slowly return to the CART venues on the street and road courses? Rene Molina Edinburg, Texas Robin Miller: Well, he's already gone back on everything else he said he wouldn't do (engine leases, franchises, foreign venues) and I know he's going to be at Watkins Glen in 2003 and, with Toyota on board, Long Beach would be a given. Not sure how anybody could turn their backs on Canada and Mexico, but if CART dies, American road racing will be gravely wounded. And open wheel. The people who attend Elkhart Lake, Mid-Ohio and Long Beach are more sophisticated and knowledgeable than people may realize. Ditto for the Canadians.
Why doesn't CART pool its resources and offer Jeff Gordon a Michael Schumacher-like contract? Gordon has already established himself as one of NASCAR's all-time greats, and his team is really not competitive at the moment. With a few CART wins and an Indy 500 or two under his belt, he could achieve A.J. Foyt/Mario Andretti status. I think he's still young enough to adapt to CART, though certainly not F1. Anything he does in NASCAR from now on will be redundant. If CART can afford Jacques Villeneuve, it can't afford not to go after Gordon -- and nobody else in the world could have as big an impact on the series. Bill Kuhlmann Independence, Mo. Robin Miller: Barry Green tried to get Gordon a few years ago and, basically, he probably thought about it but not for long. He doesn't seem to care about Indy cars, which is kinda sad because he belongs in at least one Indy 500. CART can't afford anybody (Imperial Tobacco was going to pay Jacques' salary if he came to CART). I'd go after Tony Stewart, he can road race and he's such a talent and big name.
What form of racing do you feel has been the most competitive this year? I lived in Indy all my life until a few years ago and I can't get enough racing no matter what brand. My favorite is F1, but that has been over since the beginning of the year. NASCAR is a glorified follow the leader at most tracks. CART has only 18 cars and eight good drivers, and some of the street courses are a joke. I feel the IRL has put on the best shows of the year. Close finishes, high speed and a few night races. I can't figure out why they do not draw a better crowd. Are the races to short? Not enough driver recognition? No road courses? What do you think is the problem? Gary Gaddis Boston Robin Miller: Good question, tough to give a short answer. The depth of the field in CART and NASCAR is by far the strongest of the four. So, in that respect, they are the most competitive, although they don't put on the close finishes the IRL always seem to pull out. The IRL cars have so much downforce and equal power they are forced to be close and, therefore, can run together. There are also enough cars and field fillers in the IRL they constantly have traffic, while CART's cars all seem to run the same speed at many tracks. That's why CART's races have been so ho-hum most of this year and last. Yes, it requires a lot more talent to handle a road course than a big oval where everyone is wide open all the time, but the road races and street courses don't make good television. The fans enjoy those type races and, obviously, CART draws much larger crowds in the course of the season (except Indy). CART needs more cars because 18 isn't nearly enough. That is one of NASCAR's strengths, 43 cars and lots of traffic. The IRL has had like 125 drivers since 1996 so it's a little tough to get much of a fan following with all the changing faces. But the open wheel split damaged CART and the race fans haven't embraced the IRL except at a couple of tracks where they've got to purchase NASCAR tickets. Although, Kansas City and Kentucky appear to have taken a liking to IRL -- much like Texas. One series with the 20-22 best venues might revive open wheel in a few years but that looks to be a longshot at best.
I saw Roberto Moreno at Mid-Ohio and I was wondering, what has he been doing lately? Jim Hannon Ironton, Ohio Robin Miller: Wearing out his shoes looking for a ride. He may do some testing for CART's new aero package and he's got his hat in the ring at one CART team for 2003. He still wants to drive, I know that much.
How did you like the "taxi cabs" at MIS? If IRL and CART could race like NASCAR they would put 43 cars on the track instead of only 20 some. Yes NASCAR will sell out MIS and all other tracks because it is an exciting race unlike the open wheel cars that run on the same tracks. Try putting IRL and CART on Bristol and see how they run -- NOT! So why not try it you might like it. Stop downgrading our sport and we won't downgrade yours. Carl Lewis Jackson, Mi. Robin Miller: To refresh your memory, the last five open wheel races at MIS (four CART 500-milers and one IRL) featured more passing in 25 laps than NASCAR has had in the past decade at that track. CART had 63 lead changes one year and the last 30 laps of the IRL show this year were excellent. Watching cars dart, dodge and duel with each other at 215-225 mph for three hours is so much more exciting than watching those TinTops drone around at 40 mph less for four hours. Is NASCAR exciting at Bristol, Richmond, Atlanta? Absolutely. But at Phoenix, Michigan, Texas and Fontana it's no contest -- open wheel rules.
If you had to decide between da Matta and Castroneves for your F1 team, who would you pick? Jesse Aragon California Robin Miller: Tough call. I'd probably test them for two days and take the fastest.
Will CART really have 25-27 cars next year, or does a "letter of intent" not mean anything? Who's staying and who's coming? Will adding money to the CART team incentive program make a big difference? Alf Gordon New York Robin Miller: I've asked Pook that question several times recently (watch RPM2Night this week for his interview) and he says he can't reveal the new teams yet. I think CART would be thrilled, if not lucky, to have 18 cars answer the bell next year. I don't know where they're going to come from. That incentive package won't be enough to keep anybody in the series or draw them into it.
I keep hearing about Bryan Herta going to F1, but is there any chance that he's going to run the Indianapolis 500? Alex Chernogaev Brooklyn, N.Y. Robin Miller: Herta is trying to get some money for the Minardi ride at the USGP, but it doesn't look promising. Don't know about Indy, he's running ALMS this year. I'm sure he's always going to be interested with the right opportunity.
I used to work as one of the official photographers for CART from 1996-99. At the time I did not realize how good things were until now and how I see how bad things are -- Zanardi and Montoya doing the business, while Tony George and his bunch of Marco Grecos were making a mockery in the IRL. Well, today I find myself in Paris and I work for a small TV station, Motors TV. We rebroadcast the CART races the following week, and then re-show them five or six times until the next race. I also watch the IRL and CART races "live" on our rival station AB Motuers. I must be honest, while I do not really care about the rules, the politics and the rest, but when I watch an IRL event like the one Tomas Scheckter won at Michigan compared to the Cleveland or Mid Ohio CART events, the IRL puts on a better show. Now all they need to do is keep attracting the top teams from CART, add a few of the key road and street venues and what you will have is one super strong American single seater championship that the general masses will take interest in.
P.S. Say hello to Gordon Kirby and Paul Webb for me, thanks.
Robin Miller: CART's aero package killed the short oval races and road and street courses have always been tough to pass on but CART no longer has enough backmarkers to make it more interesting and force traffic. You need jam cars like the IRL and NASCAR have. CART also needs to get rid of a couple of the road courses it's outgrown like Laguna Seca because the cars are simply too fast. Yes, the only way open wheel can ever get back to the level it was in 1995 is to be in one series with all of CART's current diversity. But don't hold your breath. I tell those two you said hello.
What is the truth concerning the rumor of an American F1 team in the works? I have heard Penske would be interested. It would be nice to see at least some American participation in F1. P. Worth Thompson Zachary, La Robin Miller: Red Bull has instituted a program for young Americans and Danny Sullivan is the talent scout. Penske tried F1 once and that's when it was relatively cheap. F1 has to want an American and, like Michael Andretti has said, I don't think F1 really cares one way or the other.
What has NASCAR seen in the younger Fittipaldi? He was consistently beaten by Robby Gordon in Team Walker and by Michael Andretti in Newman-Haas, not to mention the gap between the performance of da Matta and his in the last couple of seasons. Am I that unfair or it is a case of too many chances in comparison to his results? Rafael Rangel Giovanini Belo Horizonte/Minas Gerais, Brazil Robin Miller: I think Bill France Jr. sees the potential to tap into the vast foreign market that Fittipaldi represents. I think that's the only way Christian will be welcomed and, after NASCAR bleeds him, he'll be in ARCA.
Please put the rumors swirling around Sam Hornish Jr. to rest. Is he or isn't he going to be in the IRL full-time after 2003? Thanks for shooting it straight. Jared Meese Ballwin, Mo. Robin Miller: I would think Roger Penske would try and snap him up ASAP. Probably depends on what he can earn (he made $125,000 this year) so he's looking for some financial security.
You are the man! I was wondering what has happened to Team Target this year in CART? Kenny Brack, in my opinion, is still one of the best, but has had a down year getting adjusted to the team. Bruno has run very well, but Chip still treats him like crap. Adding Scott Dixon was OK, but I think it has stretched the best team in the business too thin. Is Chip spending too much time in 'Tintop' land? Brian Oppmann Bloomington, Ind. Robin Miller: Don't think there's any chemistry between KB and the Target boys. Ganassi doesn't appreciate Bruno and doesn't deserve him (he's going to Newman-Haas). Dixon will be back with Ganassi in 2003.
Where does Team Rahal stand on it's future? IRL or CART? Who and how many drivers? What about his sponsorship? What happened to Miller as a sponsor? William Forest Lima, Ohio Robin Miller: Good question. Shell's contract is up and Gigante was only a one-year deal. Rahal says he's working on both of them and Miller will be back with him but only at Indy again. I'd say he's 50-50 to have two cars in CART next year. |
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
|
|