ESPN Network: ESPN.com | RPM | NBA.com | NHL.com | ESPNdeportes | ABCSports | FANTASY  
rpm.espn.com
rpm.espn.com
rpm.espn.com




Wednesday, December 4
Updated: January 12, 5:52 PM ET
Robin Miller's Mailbag
Robin Miller answers user mail
ESPN.com

Robin Miller Check out what questions RPM.ESPN.com users had for Robin Miller -- and Robin's answers:




A recent article in AutoWeek stated that Arie Luyendyk has signed with Mo Nunn to run at Indy in 2003. What happened with the close relationship between Arie and Fred Treadway of Treadway/Hubbard Racing?

Pat Rizkcity
Woodlands, Texas

Robin Miller: Treadway Racing is no longer in business, or so I'm told, and Luyendyk knows he's got a helluva lot better shot at success with Nunn's effort.




What do you think will be the outcome of the contract dispute between Tomas Scheckter and Red Bull Racing? Will it be going to trial? Surely a contract still means something, doesn't it?

Robert Butler
Germantown, Tenn.

Robin Miller: Can't predict since I haven't seen the contract. All I know is I asked Tomas last July what his plans were for 2003 and he said he was a free agent. But in this day and age I think any contract can be broken and Scheckter may have a pretty solid complaint about a safety issue in what turned out to be his final race in 2002.




What's in the future for Alex Tagliani?

T. McCrorey
Kalamazoo, Mich.

Robin Miller: Tag is hoping to be with Newman-Haas, but may end up with Paul Gentilozzi's new team. Player's is paying Tag's salary for 2003.




What are Buddy Lazier's plans for the 2003 IRL season? Will all of the new 2003 IRL cars have front noses like the new Falcon chassis? Thanks for the honest and insightful reporting.

Trey McPherson
Orlando, Fla.

Robin Miller: Despite losing Coors as a sponsor, Ron Hemelgarn claims he'll have a car for Lazier. Have not seen the new Dallara or G-Forces but that Falcon is a zoomy looking piece. Trouble is, I don't know who they can get to run one of them unless they give it away. Lola had that same problem a few years ago. Thanks for watching and reading.




How can you think Cristiano da Matta deserves the Driver of the Year over Tony Stewart when Stewart runs in a much tougher series, he competes against 42 other drivers each week and da matta only competed against 17 other drivers each week and he only ran 19 races with only one being longer than 200 miles in length. Stewart ran 36 weeks and almost all of those races were 400 or 500 miles in length. Face it, NASCAR is a tougher series than CART.

Rick Schwartz
Taylor, Mich.

Robin Miller: The premise of my column was that all of those guys (Kinser, Hornish, da Matta and Kurt Busch) had better stats than Stew and the Driver of the Year should be dominant, which Stew was not. He's a phenomenal racer and one of the best in the world who could probably drive rally cars if he tried. But I think even he would agree he's had much better seasons in NASCAR. No argument that NASCAR is a much tougher grind but CART still presents the toughest challenge for a driver's ability. Stew was the champion of this country's most popular form of racing but I don't think he was Driver of the Year.




Your motorsports coverage is the highlight of the RPM page on ESPN.com -- thanks for all the opinions and inside information. Here's my question: I just read that CART had 2.7 million fans attend their 19 races in 2002, a record number for the series. My calculator says that's an average of 140,000 fans per race. If that's accurate, I wonder why everyone is shoveling dirt onto CART's grave -- that's a huge number and certainly more than the IRL races get. Or, is that number really the "weekend totals" where they count every sap who passes through the turnstiles for four days (meaning they count some people three or four times)? I guess I'm looking for a new angle on the whole IRL vs. CART thing. I keep reading that CART is in trouble, and I agree that IRL racing was much more compelling this year, but that attendance number almost made me choke! How 'bout some insight, Robin?!

Daniel Goodman
West Palm Beach, Fla.

Robin Miller: First off, thanks for the kind words (your check is in the mail). As for CART, the one saving grace it's had through these last two years of turmoil is its crowds in Canada, Mexico, Australia and Long Beach. Obviously, most of those are street races and, to be honest, attendance at Laguna Seca and Mid-Ohio was woeful this year. Elkhart Lake was decent and Cleveland was full but only had 25,000 seats. Fontana was lame (maybe 55,000) -- unless you compare it to the IRL's race there -- and Chicago was embarrassing (less than 10,000). CART won't have the depth of talent its had the past decade in 2003, nor the 25-27 cars it needs, but it should continue to draw at its street shows and maybe those three F1 tracks (Brands Hatch, Spa, Estoril). The IRL draws well at Texas (both races) and it's hard to say the exact numbers at Kentucky, Nashville, Kansas City because all the NASCAR season tickets are counted. The IRL's first race at Michigan drew about what CART did in 2001, but Phoenix has never recovered its crowd since the split. Naturally, one strong series is the answer to restoring open wheel attendance. But don't hold your breath.




C'mon Miller, I know you are so blatantly biased for CART at times I think you work for CART and not ESPN, but even you have to admit the most exciting racing next year is going to be Sam Hornish Jr. trying to make it three in a row going up against the likes of Tomas Sheckter, Gil de Ferren (two-time CART champ), Tony Kanaan, Helio Castroneves (two-time Indy winner), possibly Kenny Brack (IRL champ and Indy winner) and Dario Franchitti (but I think he is better on road courses). Tell me that isn't a fantastic driver lineup! Am I wrong? If Jimmy and Kenny do not return to CART they will have no former champions from any series and the driver with the highest wins after Tracy will be Carpentier, who got his first win last year. You also complain and call the IRL restrictor plate racing which I don't understand as there was a big difference last year between the Infiniti and the Chevy. What are you going to say about CART all running Lolas with identical crappy Ford engines? Isn't that the same thing if everyone has identical 750 horsepower engines? The IRL will have three different engines and three different chassis and by the way, CART is only running two ovals next year and there is no difference between street and road circuits. If you are fast on one you will be fast on the other like da Matta this year.

Mark Delledonne
Greenville, S.C.

Robin Miller: Whoa, so much in such a short paragraph. First off, I've spent a good portion of the last two years bashing CART, on TV and ESPN.com, for its greedy, stupid, self-serving, arrogant behavior. Other than the sham known as last year's Indy 500, the IRL escaped 2002 without much criticism from me or anybody else who reports on open wheel. There is no doubt the IRL will feature plenty of talent and good rivalries in 2003, while CART will be reloading (hopefully with some young Toyota Atlantic drivers). Just about everyone who has driven CART and IRL agrees the IRL cars are much easier to drive because they have less horsepower and a lot more downforce than a CART Champ car. Yes, CART's new cars will pretty much be a spec series but they will have 750 horsepower. Indy cars shouldn't have less horsepower than a World of Outlaw sprinter. Having said that, the IRL staged much more exciting races/finishes than CART, NASCAR or F1 last season and their races make a much better TV show than any of those other three (although nobody watches IRL or CART, check the ratings). I think you'll find there is a pretty distinct difference from road courses and street circuits as far as precision goes but da Matta was also strong at Fontana before he blew up. Obviously, CART needs a half dozen ovals to keep that diversified balance. I think what you may be saying is that with Toyota, Honda, Penske, Ganassi, Rahal, Nunn, all those evil road racers, a handful of Brazilians and a race in Japan, the IRL is starting to look a lot like CART three years ago. So I guess that was Tony's vision, yes?




A number of weeks ago you reported that there would be IRL races at Watkins Glen and Sears Point in 2003. To this point there have been no announcements. Any news on this front?

Tom Bastian
Fairport, N.Y.

Robin Miller: To quote my pal A.J. Foyt, "I was sabotaged" with some bad information. Some of the new IRL owners were told that road racing was in the future so maybe it's 2004 instead of 2003 but it's still not too late to add a race or two. Heck, CART's schedule changes every week. But the new IRL cars are equipped to road race so it's only a matter of time.




Now that it's been announced that CART's TV package cost them a $12 million-plus loss in the third quarter of 2002, what can you tell me about the TV package for 2003? Is it a continuation of '02 as some say? Is it being negotiated now? Are the prospects of greater race-day accessibility going to improve? (I can't get Speed Channel.) Will they continue the hours of coverage or increase/decrease them?

Ryan Hoover
Kahului, Hawaii

Robin Miller: CART wants to run on CBS at least six to eight times in 2003 and FOX a couple but, obviously, they will be time buys that cost a lot of money. Speed is coming back and hoping to get to 50 million homes by 2003. Speed plans to continue its practice/qualifying/Friday night coverage and, obviously, the objective is to reach more people, which FOX promises to do. More shows? Hard to say but I hear there's a possible open-wheel show in the works.




You get the scoop before anyone and report it as you see it, what is your opinion on how things are coming together for next year's CART season? I think it is looking great so far and I see about 26 cars.

Tim Fregeau
Plainfield, Ill.

Robin Miller: Are you related to Chris Pook? Just kidding. I think 20 cars would be an over-achievement at this time. A lot depends on Morris Nunn (one, two or no cars?), Stefan Johansson (one or two?), Pat Patrick (one or two?), Bobby Rahal (one or two?), Dale Coyne (one or two?) and whether some F1 or F3000 teams actually pony up and come over here. But there will be 18 because that's what many of the contracts demand. Thanks.




Great article on the Driver of the Year. Cristiano won deservedly. I would have liked to have seen your comments on John Force, he is the greatest racing personality these days, as well as a damn good driver.

Mike Ribas
Ypsilanti, Mich.

Robin Miller: Larry Dixon could have easily been Driver of the Year as well, based on his season, and I should have included him in that commentary. Force is deserving, as well, but the point of that story was defining what Driver of the Year really is and what the parameters should be. Thanks.




I've begun to feel sorry for Sarah Fisher. All she seems to be doing is silly publicity stunts for the IRL. Wasn't she the poster girl for the IRL ? "See, we take homegrown talent and give them a place to race." Did that include being grand marshal for a parade?

John Williamson
Apple Valley, Calif.

Robin Miller: Her F1 appearance was certainly that and the IRL does seem to be a dichotomy in that it's always promoting Sarah but can't find the money to make sure she's in a car. They gave her the most popular driver award last year before the IRL opener at Homestead -- which she watched. Sarah needed some seasoning in Atlantics but the IRL needed an immediate PR tool so she got thrown into the deep end. She's got talent and nerves but she still needs a lot of laps and nurturing.




I know Rockingham was ditched and Chris Pook has promised "exciting European venues in 2003", but should I really start waiting for Champ cars at Spa next year? If that would take place, it would be huge. I can't wait to see the Champ cars fly through Eau Rouge at 200 mph or Paul Tracy attacking the curbs at the Bus Stop chicanes. And one more thing. I think we have said enough negative things about CART. The future may not look very bright right now, but let's still give Pook some time and let's not ditch the fantastic series that has provided the best racing on Earth for the last 15 years. But about the new driver announcements, I'm not happy at all. Joel Camathias who? F3000 racers may be a little unknown there in America but this guy is completely unknown in Europe as well! It's better to hire a couple of not-so-spectacular former F1 guys like Mika Salo, Eddie Irvine or Allan McNish, rather than an unknown backmarker from F3000.

Jari Setälä
Helsinki, Finland

Robin Miller: All the way from Finland, that's cool. I broke the story on ESPN a few weeks ago that CART was headed to Brands Hatch, Spa and Estoril and I think all three are still a go for late April and early May. Obviously, Bernie and Chris are working together because that's the only way it could happen. I wrote four years ago that CART needed to hire Pook and, had they, Honda and Toyota would still be around. He's got a lot of problems to solve but he does understand how the game is played and the product. He just needs to make sure he gets some young American road racers in the lineup because, other than Tracy, CART has no recognizable names and needs to cultivate some new ones. I'd rather see Rocky Moran or Memo Gidley or Alex Barron instead of McNish or Magnussen. Thanks for your note and tell Mika Hakkinen hello.




What can the average, but loyal CART fan do to help it survive? I go to at least races per year, usually attend 'Runway Madness' and watch all the races. I voted with my wallet by canceling the Honda Pilot I ordered in favor of an Explorer and will trade my Tundra for the next F150. Any suggestions as to what else a desperate CART fan can do?

Stan Gibford
Bend, Ore.

Robin Miller: I'd say you've gone above and beyond. We all know CART won't have the depth and talent it's maintained for more than a decade but it does have the opportunity to reload with Alex Gurney, Memo Gidley, Joey Hand, Alex Barron, Rocky Moran Jr., Ryan Hunter-Reay, Jon Fogarty and, in a couple years, Danica Patrick and A.J. Allmendinger. The question remains: will the owners give these kids a chance?




Will we see Jacques Villeneuve in the Indy 500 or Helio Castroneves in Formula One? Also, since the CART Chicago race is in May, how do you think it will affect the drivers running the Indy 500 and the CART race?

Tony Donohue
Portage, Ind.

Robin Miller: The only way somebody like Bruno Junqueira can compete at Indy next year will be as a second-weekend qualifier because I think he'll be racing CART in Europe in late April and the first two weekends in May. I think he's about the only CART guy even considering that because everyone else (like Rahal or Mo Nunn) will have separate IRL efforts. As for Jacques and Helio, I think you've got a better shot at seeing Helio get an F1 chance, although not if he stays in the IRL much longer.




Can you elaborate on the latest rumors of current CART teams involvement in the IRL next year (ex: N-Haas/Brack/Rahal) and the rumors of current IRL teams going to CART for '03? Also, if CART will be in Europe on pole weekend at Indy, will this keep CART teams totally out of Indy -- or will they attempt to qualify on the second weekend? How many cars are slated to be at Indy and the entire IRL season? With the talk of CART changing to gasoline V-10s in '05, is there any talk of the IRL also switching from methanol to gas? Also, can you explain the logic behind this change? Isn't methanol considered to be safer than gas and burn more efficiently? Is the loss in burning efficiency the reason to switch to V-10s?

Mike Bradley
Indianapolis

Robin Miller: Rahal will run an IRL program with Brack and engineer Don Halliday (they won four CART races together in 2001). Read my answer above about Indy/May. Haven't heard anything from the IRL about gasoline but I'm told CART would make the switch because companies like Shell might jump back into sponsorship. Gas is evidently much more marketable than oil at this moment. And, obviously, some sort of alignment with Bernie Ecclestone would be another reason.

Send this story to a friend | Most sent stories
 

Related
Robin Miller answers user mail, Oct. 17

Robin Miller answers user mail, Sept. 23

Robin Miller answers user mail, Aug. 28

Robin Miller answers user mail, July 30

Robin Miller answers user mail, June 4

Robin Miller answers user mail, May 23

Robin Miller answers user mail, April 17

Robin Miller answers user mail, April 2

Robin Miller answers user mail, March 7

Robin Miller answers user mail, Feb. 24

Robin Miller answers user mail, Jan. 11

Robin Miller answers user mail, Dec. 8

Robin Miller answers user mail, Dec. 2

Robin Miller answers user mail, Nov. 15

Robin Miller answers user mail: Nov. 12

Robin Miller answers user mail: Oct. 11

Robin Miller answers user mail: Sept. 26

Robin Miller answers user mail: Sept. 10

RPM user comment central

Sports Mall