| ESPN Network: ESPN.com | RPM | NBA.com | NHL.com | ESPNdeportes | ABCSports | FANTASY | |
![]() |
|
|
| |
|
Thursday, November 15 Robin Miller answers user mail ESPN.com Check out what questions RPM.ESPN.com users had for Robin Miller -- and Robin's answers.
What is Roger Penske doing? Selling out all his race tracks then being upset that CART can not race on them. Then quitting CART and then going to the IRL. What do you think he wants? Angie Postma Slayton, Minn. Robin Miller: ANGIE: RP has a very selective memory doesn't he? Obviously, since he's still a major shareholder in ISC he knew exactly where the France family was going with Michigan, Fontana, Nazareth and Homestead. Nobody wanted to run Nazareth anymore, the CART cars were way too fast and the show sucked -- just like the crowd. Michigan had 78,000 people in 1995 and ISC did little or nothing to promote the last three 500-milers. Wait 'til you see the IRL ticket prices compared to CART's. Like Danny Sullivan once said, when the music stops, Roger always has a chair and he's doing what is best for Team Penske, just like always. I understand Marlboro wanting to be at Indy but you would have hoped Helio ran the IRL and Gil returned to defend his CART title.
Firstly, I always enjoy listening to you on RPM2Night. My question is, has there every been any thought to CART racing at Daytona on either the full TriOval circuit or the combination circuit such as the Daytona 200 for motorcycles. I would have thought the latter would have been quite exciting. Also has the IRL ever shown interest in racing at either Talladega or Daytona? Nelson Knight Auckland, New Zealand Robin Miller: NELSON: Indy cars tried Daytona once and it was a disaster (one or two deaths). The CART cars are way too fast for that track or Talladega, although I understand the IRL might have considered Daytona during the past year or two. Those are stock car tracks -- not open wheel. Thanks for watching.
I'm glad you're back with email, I loved getting your quick responses when you were at the paper. Can something get worked out so that the Indy 500 is also a CART sanctioned event under IRL rule and counted legally as the same series for CART's cigsponsors? If that could happen, I think it would help the teams stay in CART. Bruce Holst New York Robin Miller: BRUCE: No way CART will ever be allowed to sanction the Indy 500. It could be added as a points paying race like it was for many years but that still doesn't get around the tobacco legislation -- only one series can be chosen. Thanks for your support.
I love your tell it like it is attitude! Question: How do you really think Gil and Helio feel about running in the IRL? It seems like a B-league series to me and a step backwards for these great drivers. Sean Clar San Carlos, Calif. Robin Miller: SEAN: They will both play the good soldier but, naturally, neither wants to go down to Triple-A and quit road racing. But, right now, they have no choice unless maybe Ganassi buys out one of them to run in CART (not likely). Thanks for reading.
A very simple question: Do you or do you NOT like A.J.? Mark Lind Algonquin, Ill. Robin Miller: MARK: I do like Foyt and we have a mutual fondness for giving each other a hard time. (LIke when he's making fun of CART for being a bunch of F1 wanna-bes and his driver is Eliseo Salazar or Marco Greco). He's one of the guys (along with Parnelli and Herk) who got me hooked on racing in the early '60s and, when he's not drinking that IRL Kool-Aid, he can be engaging and interesting as hell. Matter of fact, we spent a half hour shooting the breeze this morning. And, even if I didn't like him, I damn sure respect what he could do in a race car from 1958-78.
I just saw something on TV that sums up CART like nothing else can. It was a promo for the film "Driven", encouraging folks to order it on PPV. The spot also said that if you order it you can enter to win a driving experience at CART Driving 101. All you had to do was enter was register at -- get this -- NASCAR.com! The fact that CART isn't using this promotion to drive people to its Web site again indicates that it has no clue. I've remained loyal as long as I can; from now on, my first viewing priority, and my ticket $$ goes to the IRL. Comment? Mark Founds Hockessin, Del. Robin Miller: MARK: I saw the same ad the other night and I'm trying to find out how it got on NASCAR's Web site. CART is clueless about a lot more than TV ads, unfortunately.
First. Since the Star fired you, we don't have anyone who will ask the hard questions of the IRL like you did....we open wheel fans miss you. Now. While Joe Heitzler is the most visible target at CART, doesn't the structure of CART and the owner's voting rights pretty well ensure that the inmates will remain in charge of the asylum? It seems to me that even if they had the brightest, most charismatic executive on the face of the planet, some one like Jack Welch (of GE) as the CART CEO, we would still have anarchy. Craig Gigax Indianapolis Robin Miller: CRAIG: You are very perceptive. The owners make the call 90 percent of the time and the CEO is merely a messenger in many instances. But if Chris Pook comes in and Gerry Forsythe rids the board of directors of car owners, things could change drastically -- if not for the better. Pook should have been picked a year ago because he could actually save this thing. Thanks for the kind words, I miss writing in The Star.
Since CART is facing an engine shortage after the adaptation of IRL-like engine specs, why can't CART teams buy Chevy (formerly Olds) and Infiniti engine components and build their own engines? As I recall, the whole point of the IRL engine specs was to provide cheap engines. Tim Severin Las Vegas Robin Miller: TIM: They can, and probably will eventually, providing the CART specs are close enough to the IRL's. But Nissan may be going bye-bye in the near future and if John Judd or another manufacturer doesn't step in, not sure that Toyota and GM will supply everyone in both series, although they may have to. Toyota will drive up the price of going fast in the IRL -- immediately.
I really have a bone to pick with you I do not doubt your intelligence in the world of open wheel racing, but here are some questions that are really bugging me. I am really curious on how you would put CART and the IRL back together? CART is in a real pickle because they are saying two opposite things concerning the 2003 season. Is CART going in a direction to maybe turn into the F2 World Championship? What about the IRL and their new "feeder series". Could this be the Indy Lights with a new packaging. I want to lay this thought on you and the viewing public, could the IRL and CART really be sanctioned in secret by one body, and the IRL was meant to become the next generation of Champ Car Racing in America? Aaron Campbell LaFollette, Tenn. Robin Miller: AARON: If all the planets got aligned and CART was taken off the public market, it's feasible that there could be some kind of unified series with the IRL controlling the ovals and CART taking care of the road and street circuits. Pick the best 22 races from both and have at it -- with an oval track champ, a road racing champ and an overall champ. It's the only hope open wheel has.
Why does it seem everyone is dogging the normally asp engines for CART for not being "high tech" enough? Correct me if I'm wrong, but aren't F1 engines normally asp? Isn't there room in the IRL engine to make them more advanced for CART? Maybe not in the near future, but as the engine development grows? Douglas Cole West Chester, Ohio Robin Miller: DOUG: I think people are dogging CART for dragging its feet in the engine rule department and for announcing a new formula without having any manufacturers at the press conference to confirm their participation. I believe CART wants to run 11,500 RPMs in 2003 and move to a 12,000 RPM rev limiter in 2004 to give the cars enough power for the road courses. There are a couple of other technical points that could also enhance the CART normally-aspirated engine.
I recently was talking with a management person for one of the most successful CART teams, and this person believes that 2002 will be the last season for CART. I found this interesting because the person who said this is an outsider to the racing world, and they only work for the CART team because of the persons business, not racing, experience. What do you think? Jim Fleming Indianapolis Robin Miller: JIM: Depending on what happens in the next few months, it's possible that teams like KOOL Green and Target/Ganassi could be headed for the IRL in 2003 simply because they require American venues and get nothing out of the international schedule. That's the reality -- the sponsors have been loyal to CART since 1996 but that appears to be changing and 2003 is very much a wild card.
There is an old adage that goes like this, "perception becomes reality." There is a whole generation of race fans (I'm 31) that have "jumped on the NASCAR" bandwagon in the last few years. Most of these fans don't know or remember how CART and the Indy 500 used to be. To them, NASCAR is the pinnacle of auto racing. Why doesn't a CART owner put a ChampCar and a stock car on the same track for a little demo. I remember Popular Mechanics did this with Zanardi's car versus Robby Buhl's car in '97. Ganassi would be the obvious choice because he owns both. Invite the media and lets see who gets blasted. What do you think? John Goolsby Birmingham, Ala. Robin Miller: JOHN: I don't think it would change the mind of 10 people. NASCAR is a religion and CART and IRL are preaching to empty churches (at least on most ovals).
If (or when) Marlboro and Team Penske make the switch to the IRL, what are the odds Marlboro will become the title sponsor of the IRL? Since the IRL has no title sponsor right now. Tom Conover Bear, Del. Robin Miller: TOM: Good question and I asked that recently of an IMS VP and he said that hadn't been discussed. Then again, he simply may not have been invited to the conversation. It makes sense and Marlboro could have some extra money lying around since the IRL is cheaper than CART.
Will Mark Dismore still race the IRL in 2002? Is he a possible favorite for the second Cheever ride? Tommy Plahitko Terre Haute, Ind. Robin Miller: TOMMY: You would hope Diz at least gets a decent ride at Indy but I don't know about Cheever's second seat, or if there is going to be one. If Diz had money, sure.
I've heard talk about Bernie Ecclestone being interested in a second US venue for a grand prix. What do you think the chances are of something like a USGP West at a place like Laguna Seca or even a new circuit. Also what's the deal with the future Russian, Mideastern, and Chinese GPs? Brian Murcko Baltimore Robin Miller: BRIAN: Laguna might pack 'em in but I always heard Chris Pook wanted to do something in downtown San Francisco or maybe New York City. Don't know about those other three possibilities. China is supposedly interested in F1 and CART.
Robin, When you were at Nazareth this year you were telling some pretty good stories. You were talking with your crew. How about a book of these short stories& Quotes? Charlie Wallace Montgomery, N.Y. Robin Miller: CHARLIE: I've thought about it but I'd probably have to get protective custody if I told all the "true" stories. It's a thought, thanks.
Outlaws or the All Stars on television some more? Should WoO and All Stars combine into one series to make it a larger series? How about some input from a former sprint driver. Brad Wilson Toledo, Oh Robin Miller: BRAD: I don't know how the Outlaws do on TV (a tuff sell on Sat nights) but I would think the exposure has been good for sprint car racing in general. But one series is enough.
I know that the IRL is desperate for a huge star and has been promoting certain drivers in the past few years. Yet, the "stars" such as Unser and Fisher have been almost busts. I was wondering if this line of promoting racers has hurt the credibility of the series. Also, I was wondering if you thought that any current drivers should be removed from CART/IRL rides. By the way, you should have been the president of CART instead of that dope Heitzler. Andrew Wolff Readlyn, Iowa Robin Miller: ANDREW: Sam Hornish definitely emerged as the IRL's newest star this past season after Sarah lost all her confidence and Junior is a shadow of his old self. But Fisher still gets the biggest ovations and sells the most T-shirts and she's only 21. She's got a future, with the right situation and engineer. There are a few guys in both series who need to either retire or head for Petite LeMans -- or get some more miles. Thanks for the vote of confidence but as much as I beat on those owners I don't think I'd get many votes.
Doesn't the survival of CART actually benefit the IRL? If CART was to eventually fold and it's surviving well funded teams jump to the IRL wouldn't that drive some of the IRL's smaller under funded teams out of existence? Dave Surgent Johnson City, N.Y. Robin Miller: DAVE: Yes, that's what I've tried to tell a few IRL zealots. They don't want to see CART fold or most of their teams will get steam rolled and be out of action. I said if they thought the last two Indy 500s were bad, wait until everybody shows up.
CART racing at Fontana is looking a lot like NASCAR restrictor plate racing. Is anyone at CART looking at a rules package that will allow them to race at the big tracks without having 15 or 20 cars wiped out in one wreck? Allen Groff Columbus, OH Robin Miller: ALLEN: I hope so. As much passing as there was and as much as the fans seemed to like it, it's not racing when guys are riding the brakes and trying NOT to lead. Zanardi said it after the '98 Michigan 500 and I argued with him but, in hindsight, I think he's right. Even da Matta said winning that race didn't give him the same feeling that Australia did because so much luck is involved and where you are with two laps left.
F1 is having problems with its engine manufacturers that are unhappy with F1 management arrangements, and are talking of starting their own alternative F1 series down the road. With CART's engine supplier problems, yet healthy global presence and vastly greater North American presence than F1 offers (and better racing to boot)... wouldn't that suggest opportunities for both CART & engine manufacturers? How come neither is finding benefit in the other, considering CART's needs and engine manufacturer's wants? And wouldn't a variety of F1 engine manufacturers get greater bang for the buck spreading their engines across CART as well, if an engine spec could be worked out? Why no news of discussions between the two groups? They could snap up CART's stock and have CART ready to go, no? Yet no one talks of the possibilities. Why not? Ken Waters Phoenix Robin Miller: KEN: Several people wondered out loud why CART didn't simply adapt the F1 engine specs and see how many might be interested. I never heard a definitive answer but it probably makes too much sense.
With regard to the whole Penske/IRL dealie, I would think that both Helio and Gil's contracts would be very specific as to the series, car, and number of races each driver would be required to run, and that a change in the series, car, and number of races run would open both driver's contracts up to renegotiation. Any insight to how the driver's contracts would work if they would jump from one series to another? Harry Dempsey Cleveland Robin Miller: HARRY: I've tried to pry that info out of Gil but, alas, no luck as yet. Trust me, when he signed on with Penske he didn't dream he might be heading for the IRL in his third year. Ditto for Castroneves. They don't want to leave CART, but.......
Robin, with Penske going to the IRL, Mo Nunn downsizing, Rahal looking for a sponsor for his second car and Jerry Forsythe's announcement folding the 77 team it looks to me like CART might be struggling to reach 18 car grids next year. Your thoughts on the size of the CART grids next year. Robert M. McAdam Roanoke, Va. Robin Miller: ROBERT: That's what I count, 18 to 20 cars, max unless CART spends some of that $140 million it's got in the bank and props up a couple teams to keep them running two cars. The other concern is what kind of car count is guaranteed to the promoter. You can have a good race with 18 cars, providing the quality remains.
Any silly season news you are hearing, such as driver/team changes in CART or IRL? Or other tracks/circuits being considered for adding or dropping of races? Alf Melman Los Angeles Robin Miller: ALF: Nothing at the moment, just waiting to see who Ganassi's second shoe will be and if Rahal runs two cars and who Foyt will hire. Las Vegas and Miami are still being considered for CART, or so I'm told. The IRL sked is set.
Coach Miller, (former league players say you were the best coach in Indy!) why did Tommy Kendall get out of racing after being so dominant in SCCA? Keep up the honest commentary. Jeff Mason Speedway, Ind. Robin Miller: JEFF: I was told Tommy priced himself out of Trans Am and television (I thought he was excellent on TV) and hopefully he'll be back some day. Thanks.
1) Being an open wheel race fan, unfortunately we spend more time talking politics than racing. What is the inside story with the push to have Chris Pook take over CART. I remember before CART selected Heitzler, Pook wanted more control than the owners were willing to give up. 2)It appears that John Vannini is pushing for Chris Pook. What is John's background as it relates to racing and CART? Doug Sharp Indianapolis Robin Miller: DOUG: Pook scared the owners because he's smarter than they are and knows how to make things happen. He's back in the picture because Vannini and Forsythe both want to blow up the board of directors and throw the owners off, which would open up the opportunity to hire Pook -- the man who should have gotten the job last year. Don't know much abut Vannini, he's 39 and driving Barber Dodge.
Why hasn't anyone floated this idea; Galles has said that he'll let Al Jr. go because he doesn't have sponsorship for his car. Penske made some cryptic remarks about how far the team had come since 1999 and it's too bad that Al wasn't there. Would it be possible for Penske to run Al Jr. and Castroneves in the IRL and let Gil defend his CART title? And, Miller has never said what their deal with Rahal is, and aren't they another Philip Morris company? I think it's just wishful thinking on my part because you've been right a lot, but it makes sense to me. Thanks for your time. Craig Stewart Orange, Calif. Robin Miller: CRAIG: No, I don't think you'll ever see Unser driving for Penske again, it's a long, involved story that I can't get into at the moment. Miller wants to be at Indy and in CART, just not for as much money as years past. De Ferran wants to stay in CART (just like his crew) but it's not gonna happen unless Honda can save the day.
Here's a revolutionary idea for NASCAR. Why don't they reduce the banking of Daytona and Talladega. Instead of relying on restrictor plates to reduce speed the decreased banking would force the drivers to slow down. I know that stock cars need banking to corner but I doubt they need as much as the clunkers from the '50's and '60's did. Also why don't they bite the bullet and adopt air jacks in the cars. I doubt the systems are much more expensive than the $5,000 wonder jacks being toted by ex-NFL linemen and could make pit row safer. Chris Mashburn Cincinnati Robin Miller: CHRIS: I can't see those tracks being re-configured but if they listened to the drivers and did away with the restrictor plates, it might be just fine. Air jacks make too much sense, just like helmets for pit crews. They'll kill somebody and then make it mandatory.
Robin, your honesty is so refreshing! Please give those of us die-hard CART fans some hope! Don't you think Mike Andretti did great finishing 3rd in the points with a new team? I thought so. Keep up the great work! Kathy Doan Salt Lake City Robin Miller: KATHY: Michael isn't the guy who took our breath away 10 years ago but he's smarter and smoother than ever before. I was actually disappointed he didn't win more and qualify better. Indy was his strongest race of the year, too bad he didn't win. thanks for your support.
Do you think CART will run a race at Kansas Speedway? I loved the St. Louis races and looked forward to Texas, but we know what happened there. And I don't like street races -- too much follow the leader. John Byington Wichita , Kan. Robin Miller: JOHN: No, that's IRL/ISC territory but it's a great facility.
You sort of alluded to it in your final response in the November 12 mailbag. I've also seen references to it elsewhere. You were right last Easter when you told Dave Calabro on WTHR that Tony Stewart was going to do the "Indianapolis 500" in May 2001 for Chip Ganassi. Now I guess it's pretty much a done deal (from everything I read) that Stewart will drive for Ganassi again next May at Indy. Is it likely that Tony Stewart is going to run the full IRL series in 2003 for Ganassi, Target and Toyota? Bob Jennings Indianapolis Robin Miller: BOB: Ganassi is trying to get Stewart for 2003 but for his Winston Cup team, although I'd much rather see him come back to open wheel where he belongs. But at least he'll be back here next May for Ganassi.
You seem intent on ending the CART race at Laguna Seca. I've been a spectator at both Laguna Seca and Long Beach for years and enjoy both tremendously. Why do you think they should vacate Laguna? Dave Larson Fremont, Calif. Robin Miller: DAVE: The crowds continue to dwindle and the races are awful, nobody can pass and everyone runs the same speed - the cars have outgrown the track. It's a beautiful track but it needs a couple of passing zones. |
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
|
|