Off Base

Keyword
MLB
Scores
Schedule
Pitching Probables
Standings
Statistics
Transactions
Injuries
Players
Free Agents
Offseason Moves
Message Board
Minor Leagues
MLB en espanol
CLUBHOUSE


THE ROSTER
Peter Gammons
Rob Neyer
Jayson Stark
Jim Caple
John Sickels
SHOP@ESPN.COM
TeamStore
ESPN Auctions
SPORT SECTIONS
Friday, January 25
 
Musical ownership bad for baseball

By Jim Caple
ESPN.com

Baseball hasn't been this confusing since Harry Caray was in the broadcast booth.

Let's see. Pitchers and catchers report to spring training in three weeks and there is no basic agreement between the owners and the players, the Marlins do not have a manager or a general manager, the Expos do not have an owner and neither of those teams knows where its spring training camp will be. And commissioner Bud Selig still maintains his ludicrous claim that baseball will eliminate two teams by Opening Day, even though two judges ruled otherwise.

On the other hand, the Angels have new uniforms.

This entire winter's moves smell as bad as a player's lucky jockstrap after the final game of a 35-game hitting streak. Baseball's solutions are worse than its supposed problems. And the biggest problem to musical ownership is that when the music stopped, the ones without chairs were the fans.

Ever since free agency, the offseason's greatest challenge (and occasional appeal) was figuring which players were with which teams. But this winter has been even more complex, not unlike figuring out what alternate jerseys the Diamondbacks are going to wear next. Not only do we need to keep track of the players and managers, we must also follow the moving owners, who are changing teams more often than Pokey Reese.

Not to suggest baseball has reached a new low, but its newest game of musical owners is without precedent in any league that does not hold an annual draft in a basement with team owners drinking Miller Lite while leafing through old copies of the Sports Illustrated swimsuit issue. Baseball may have thought the Fritz Peterson-Mike Kekich wife-swap gave the game a back eye, but that's nothing compared to this team-swapping debacle.

Let's begin with the Montreal Expos, who either will cease to exist in April or who will be run from New York City by major league baseball, most likely the latter. While the league running the Expos is a recipe for disaster -- perhaps only Youppi! would survive the July trade deadline -- the saddest part is it would be an improvement over Jeffrey Loria's awful tenure as owner.

True, Loria took over a troubled franchise in 1999, but make no mistake -- his bungling exasperated the situation and probably doomed the franchise.

Complain all you want about the Canadian dollar and Olympic Stadium, it was Loria who decided not to air Expos games on an English language radio station two years ago. It was Loria who spent two years alienating fans with his demands for a new stadium. It was Loria who spent more energy trying to take over another team rather than improve the one he had.

And yet baseball owners are not only rewarding him by buying his team for significantly more than it's really worth, they're giving him the Florida Marlins so he can run them into the ground as well. Or, at least, further into the ground.

Meanwhile, Marlins owner John Henry, who has hardly been successful in Florida, is buying the Red Sox along with Tom Werner. You remember Werner. He's the man who brought Roseanne onto the field to sing the national anthem in San Diego while dumping Gary Sheffield and Fred McGriff in one of baseball's most notorious fire sales.

Now, if you or I were running baseball, we wouldn't sell Werner a ticket to Fenway Park, let alone give him ownership of one of the game's crown jewels. Yet, baseball not only approved the Henry/Werner bid for the Red Sox, it did so even though the bid was at least $75 million less than the highest offer.

Giving Werner and Loria new teams is like inviting the CEOs of Enron and K-Mart to sit on the board of directors at Disney and Microsoft. Tough luck with those recent bankruptcies, boys, but maybe you'll have better luck with these companies.

Look, I know there are problems in Montreal. And maybe moving the team to the Washington D.C. area next year is a reasonable solution at this stage (certainly, it's better than eliminating them altogether). Fine. But why let the man responsible for their problems anywhere near another team? Why let a man who nearly ruined the Padres a crack at the Red Sox?

More importantly, what do the ownership swaps say about the integrity of competition? If Loria and Henry were angling for other teams, how hard could they have been trying to win with the teams they already owned?

Loria is ready to take his front office to Florida, but supposedly the owners will draw the line at letting him take his best players as well. There is, after all, a limit to what even the owners will approve these days. Or is there? We've already listened to plans for eliminating two teams, allowing owners to swap teams and the league running a team this winter, so I don't know that anything is too offensive to rule out anymore.

This entire winter's moves smell as bad as a player's lucky jockstrap after the final game of a 35-game hitting streak. Baseball's solutions are worse than its supposed problems. And the biggest problem to musical ownership is that when the music stopped, the ones without chairs were the fans.

Although I'm sure owners would be happy to sell them a personal seat license.

Jim Caple is a senior writer for ESPN.com.






 More from ESPN...
Stark: Rumblings & Grumblings
Baseball in Montreal. Make ...
Jim Caple Archive

 ESPN Tools
Email story
 
Most sent
 
Print story