Rumblings and Grumblings

Keyword
MLB
Scores
Schedule
Pitching Probables
Standings
Statistics
Transactions
Injuries
Players
Power Alley
All-Time Stats
Message Board
Minor Leagues
MLB en espanol
CLUBHOUSE


THE ROSTER
Jim Caple
Peter Gammons
Joe Morgan
Rob Neyer
John Sickels
Jayson Stark
SHOP@ESPN.COM
TeamStore
ESPN Auctions
SPORT SECTIONS
Friday, January 25
Updated: April 17, 5:52 PM ET
 
Expos fiasco will only get worse

By Jayson Stark
ESPN.com

At this point, only people who believe in the Easter Bunny believe the Montreal Expos won't be playing baseball this year.

But it's hard to figure out if that's the good news for this sport or the bad news -- because the Expos will be playing baseball unlike any team has ever played it in modern times.

The reason for that, of course, is that their owner won't be named Loria, Brochu, Steinbrenner, Colangelo or even Youppi. Their owner will be named Major League Baseball.

And let's just say there is growing discomfort around the game over the mess that could result from a team being owned and operated by a sport that mostly wants it to just go away.

Where could this bizarre experiment go wrong? Let us count the ways:

1. What's the deal?
The fundamental question here is: How can this operation possibly be run like a real baseball team when it may have a shorter life expectancy than "The Chamber?"

Suppose, for example, the Expos decide to trade Vladimir Guerrero to the Yankees? Even worse, suppose they were to decide to deal Javier Vazquez to the Brewers? How suspicious would those deals look?

This, after all, is a team with no big picture to look at. It can't justify trading established players for prospects because the team figures to cease to exist before those prospects ever have their name announced in French at Stade Olympique.

Yet this is a team that obviously has no short-term agenda, either. It made no trades of any kind all winter. And it signed exactly one major-league free agent -- Masato Yoshii, who was a free agent only because he'd previously been released by these very same Expos.

So this clearly is no normal baseball operation. The Expos don't need a general manager. They need a maintenance man.

"Seems to me," said one baseball man, "all they can do is just keep the grass mowed and keep the weeds off the field."

Nah. They don't even have to do that. They play on plastic.

2. What's for dinner? Lame duck
Whether this team is contracted, sold or shifted to the New York-Penn League next year, it doesn't change the fundamental question for this year: How motivated could anyone running it possibly be?

Their manager, whoever he is, will be a lame duck. Their coaching staff, whatever it is, will be 100 percent lame ducks. Their entire front office will be made up of temps from the MLB branch of Kelly Girls. (OK, sorry, it's now Kelly Temporary Services.)

We're sure all these folks will try hard and all that. But how can their motivation possibly be the same as a normal team's staff, working toward the postseason now or a brighter tomorrow? And what loyalty could their players possibly feel toward a group they know is just passing through on the way to oblivion?

3. Show them the money
Here are three words we can bet you won't hear around the Expos' front office: "Money's no object."

This team had a $34-million payroll last year, and it didn't exactly add Jason Giambi this year.

It averaged 7,500 fans a game last year, and its marketing campaign to pump up business this winter went something like: "Come Watch Us Contract."

Its TV-radio deal essentially consists of a couple of guys yelling into a megaphone.

And the folks paying the bills this year at MLB Central are already writing about $30 million in revenue-sharing checks to this team out of the Central Fund. So we don't see them trying to tie up Guerrero for the next 10 years with the spare change lying around Bud Selig's desk.

In other words, there will be enough money thrown into the checking account to pay the electric bill. But not enough to provide any other form of electricity, if you catch our drift.

4. There's no "I" in team, but there's an "I" in "equipe"
Say you're a player on a team like this -- a team literally going nowhere, and not just in the standings. What motivation would you have?

There are more people in your family room than there are in the stands. There is no roar of the crowd to inspire you to magical heights, or even to stay awake. There is no reason to play to open the eyes of a lame-duck coaching staff. Your team's only long-term goal is to disappear.

So what would you play for if you worked for a team like that? Yourself. Period.

You would play to get a real job on a real team next year. To get a paycheck now and a bigger paycheck down the road. To try to survive in a sport that could lose 50 major-league jobs in contraction.

So don't start dumping on these guys if they don't give themselves up to move a runner some night when they're 37 games out of first, playing in front of 126 fans. What's in it for them to sacrifice their stats when their team is one big human sacrifice?

5. Keep your balance
Oh, it's only for one year, remember. That's the justification for all this. Isn't it?

In a year, this team will either go the way of the Cleveland Spiders (and become permanently defunct) or go the way of the Seattle Pilots (and move to allegedly greener pastures).

So what's the big deal? Relax. Mark all this down as just a temporary necessary evil of a strange and unsettled time. That's what we'll be told as this potential debacle unfolds.

Except in the meantime, a real season is going to be played. And the Expos will be playing real games against real teams trying to make the real playoffs. They've got 57 games ahead against the Braves, Mets and Phillies. Those games are going to have a real impact on a real NL East race and a real NL wild-card race.

In an era when we're being told competitive balance is baseball's biggest concern, how's that going to affect competitive balance?

You don't want to ask these questions. You don't want to know these answers.

We know everyone means well here, and everyone will do their best to make a bad situation remotely tolerable. But if you thought baseball in Montreal was a fiasco before, just wait a couple of months. The true fiasco could be loosening up in the on-deck circle as we speak.

Miscellaneous Rumblings

  • Now that Bud Selig has officially acknowledged that relocation is back on baseball's long-term radar screen, we can resume debating the burning question: Where in the world should teams be moving if they relocate?

    To help determine that answer, devoted reader David Hallstrom analyzed the biggest markets in America that don't have a major-league team to determine potential attendance for a future club.

    That's essentially impossible, of course. But at least Hallstrom employed an actual scientific formula. He broke up markets into small, medium, large and extra-large categories, then computed attendance based on a population/attendance ratio generated by current teams in those market categories. Here's what he projected:

    Washington, 3,034,783
    Portland, Ore., 2,217,336
    Sacramento, 1,758,871
    Orlando, 1,609,795
    Las Vegas, 1,530,234
    Indianapolis, 1,573,504
    San Antonio, 1,558,720
    Norfolk, 1,536,361
    Columbus, 1,507,598
    Charlotte, 1,467,598
    New Orleans, 1,309,446
    Salt Lake, 1,305,715

    These estimates obviously don't measure baseball fever, corporate interest or any other intangibles. But if they're at all accurate, then clearly there aren't a lot of places teams can move. On the other hand, every one of these cities would double, triple or practically quadruple the Expos' attendance in Montreal. So what the heck are they still doing playing there?

  • Contractual clause of the week: One month after getting non-tendered (or, basically, released) by the Rangers, Rick Helling got these perks from the Diamondbacks: membership in a country club of his choice and a luxury box at Bank One Ballpark.

    Posada
    Posada

  • The remarkable thing about this year's arbitration filings is how unremarkable they are. Only four players filed at asking prices of $5 million or above -- Jorge Posada ($7.75 million), Shawn Estes ($7.1 million), Dmitri Young ($6.15 million) and Neifi Perez ($5 million). And that's no accident.

    More high-profile players were non-tendered this winter than ever before (including Helling, Pokey Reese, Jimmy Haynes, Scott Hatteberg, Ricky Ledee, Ruben Rivera). And that was clearly part of a concerted effort by management to use the system to its own advantage instead of sitting back and getting flattened by the arbitration steamroller.

    "I think you'll see non-tenders become more normal down the road," says one club official. "With the (salary) numbers being what they are, those interchangeable-parts kind of guys are going to be out there more and more."

  • Insurance costs have long been a sore subject in baseball. And they're only getting worse. Premiums reportedly have doubled, and even tripled in some cases, since Sept. 11.

    So one constructive idea we've heard is that baseball follow the lead of the other major sports and consolidate all its insurance business with one company to reduce premiums. Right now, every club is on its own in finding insurance carriers. Hence, no group discounts. And in these tough times, how much business sense does that make?

  • The Phillies have taken a lot of heat this winter -- here and elsewhere -- for adding just one major-league player (Terry Adams) to a club that didn't get eliminated until the final weekend last year. But GM Ed Wade says it wasn't from lack of trying.

    For one thing, the Phillies spent the entire winter meetings talking about potential Scott Rolen deals that never happened. And Wade says that until the Phillies had a feel for A) whether they were or weren't going to trade Rolen and B) what they would get back if they did, they didn't even know what their needs were.

    Once they concluded they were keeping Rolen, Wade says they turned their attention to upgrading their starting pitching. They targeted Aaron Sele and Terry Adams, lost out on Sele and wound up signing Adams.

    Now they're working on upgrading their bench (John Mabry?) and bullpen (Ron Villone?). And they plan to be aggressive in spring training on trading to fill those needs. But Wade says he understands the frustration his fans feel, because he's frustrated himself he couldn't get more done.

    "I know it creates the impression of inactivity, or a lack of interest in doing things," he said. "But that was far from the case. Through the entire Christmas 'break,' the only day I wasn't on the phone was Christmas Day. ...

    "I understand that fans want 'names.' And there were a lot of 'names' going back and forth in New York this winter, which creates a different set of (expectations). If we'd been able to do one or two of the major things we were chasing, I think we would have satisfied that aspect. But I also understand that if you don't bring those things to fruition, you don't get the credit for the effort you put in."

    Nevertheless, Wade expects his club to be very good, with the return of Mike Lieberthal, a full season of Brandon Duckworth and continued progress by Randy Wolf, who held left-handed hitters to a lower average (.171) than any left-handed starter in the big leagues. And the GM has every reason to think Rolen, Pat Burrell and Bobby Abreu can be better offensively.

    If all that works out and Jose Mesa wasn't a mirage, there's no reason the Phillies won't contend. (They did score more runs than any team in the NL East last year.) The question is: Is merely contending enough to inspire a skeptical fan base?

    Adams
    Adams

  • Rumors continue to swirl that Adams failed physicals this winter with both the Braves and Red Sox. But Wade says he was assured by agent Alan Hendricks that Adams underwent just two exams this winter -- one by Dr. James Andrews, the other by the Phillies' medical staff.

    "So those flunked physicals never happened," Wade said, "because he never had those physicals."

    Nevertheless, the very structure of Adams' contract tells you there are health concerns. Only the first year of his three-year deal is guaranteed, and the option for 2003 vests only if Adams pitches 170 innings this year and does not finish the season on the disabled list with shoulder or elbow problems.

  • Then again, the Mets' rotation might have more health questions than the Phillies' rotation.

    Three GMs told us this winter they backed off Pedro Astacio because he never had surgery to repair a partially torn labrum. Jeff D'Amico has never made more than 23 starts in any season (and has made 33 in the last four years combined). And a number of scouts say that Shawn Estes' velocity dropped so much last year, they question how sound he is.

  • But despite those questions, no GM worked harder or more creatively to reshape his club this winter than Steve Phillips. It would be easier to memorize all the transactions on the New York Stock Exchange than to keep track of all of the Mets' maneuvers. So we finally tallied them up.

    7 trades
    2 waiver claims
    1 cash deal (purchase of Gary Matthews Jr.)
    8 free agents signed from outside the organization
    2 free agents re-signed
    42 players involved in this three-month tornado (counting David Justice only once)

    Remember, the Mets didn't just finish last in the majors in runs scored. They scored fewer runs (642) than any National League team since the '93 Marlins scored 581 in their first year on the planet. So here's the math on how much offense the Mets added (if you count Mo Vaughn's 2000 numbers):

    112 home runs
    428 RBI
    466 runs scored
    100 stolen bases

    Meanwhile, here are the totals of the nine position players the Mets subtracted:

    61 home runs
    272 RBI
    292 runs scored
    38 stolen bases

    So the net gain:

    51 home runs
    156 RBI
    174 runs scored
    62 stolen bases

    That'll work.

  • With every day that goes by without the completion of the Marlins sale, the once-humorous scenario of manager Jeff Torborg and his coaching staff starting spring training with the Expos and finishing it with Florida becomes at least slightly more plausible.

    "I have this vision of Jeff Torborg changing uniforms in the middle of a game," quips one scout. "Maybe he'll wear Max Patkin's old uniform -- with the questions marks on it."

    Triviality
    Only four players who changed teams this winter have averaged 30 homers and 100 RBI over the last five seasons. Can you name them? (Answer at bottom.)

    Useless Information Dept.
    Nobody gets around like Todd Zeile. The Rockies will be his ninth team since just 1995. But that's not all bad. Assuming he hits a home run for the Rockies (which is kind of like assuming someone in Colorado will see a snowflake this year), at least he will tie a prestigious modern record:

    Zeile
    Zeile

    Most teams homered for in a career (nine).

    The current record holders since 1900 -- according to the Sultan of Swat Stats, SABR's David Vincent -- are Tommy Davis and a man who caught him last year with way too little fanfare, Dave Martinez.

    And if Zeile pulls even with them, he can then demand to get traded and shoot for the all-time leaders from not-so-modern times -- Dan Brouthers and Downtown Tom Brown, who homered for 10 teams before 1900.

    Here's the rundown on the clubs those four nomads homered for, courtesy of the Sultan:

    Tom Brown (10)
    Baltimore AA (American Association), Columbus AA, Pittsburgh AA, Indianapolis NL, Boston NL, Boston PL (Players League), Boston AA, Louisville NL, St. Louis NL, Washington NL.

    Dan Brouthers (10)
    Troy NL, Buffalo NL, Detroit NL, Boston NL, Boston PL, Boston AA, Brooklyn NL, Baltimore NL, Louisville NL, Philadelphia NL.

    Tommy Davis (9)
    Los Angeles NL, New York NL, Chicago AL, Seattle AL, Houston NL, Oakland AL, Chicago NL, Baltimore AL, California AL.

    Dave Martinez (9)
    Chicago NL, Montreal NL, Cincinnati NL, San Francisco NL, Chicago AL, Tampa Bay AL, Texas AL, Toronto AL, Atlanta NL.

    Zeile, by the way, is one of 14 players who have homered for eight teams.

  • Actually, maybe we shouldn't assume a Zeile home run in Denver is so automatic -- since one of the guys he was traded for proved last season that it is indeed possible for a player to not homer at Coors Field, even if you have half a season to do it.

    The man who pulled that off was Alex Ochoa, who will be heading for Milwaukee via the Mets. And could it really have been just one offseason ago -- following a season in which Ochoa hit 13 homers in only 244 at-bats with the Reds -- that he was being regarded as a hitter who had finally figured it all out?

    OK, maybe not. Ochoa wound up getting traded to the Rockies in July and then proceeded to do the impossible. In 110 at-bats at Coors as a Rockie, he managed to hit no home runs. He didn't hit any in 14 at-bats at Coors as a Red, either.

    According to the Elias Sports Bureau, only two other players -- Walt Weiss and Juan Pierre (twice) -- ever have had seasons in which they got more than 100 at-bats at Coors and went trotless. But they were slightly different kinds of players than Ochoa, who was once regarded as a future star. At any rate, here's the entire roster of Coors' rarified 100-Zero Club:

    1995: Walt Weiss, 217 AB, 0 HR.
    2000: Juan Pierre, 108 AB, 0 HR.
    2001: Juan Pierre, 299 AB, 0 HR.
    2001: Alex Ochoa, 124 AB, 0 HR.

  • According to the Hall of Fame's official statistics, Ozzie Smith is the Cardinals' 15th Hall of Famer -- because he'll go in wearing a Cardinals cap. But David Vincent decided to compute this a different way.

    If a Hall of Famer wore the uniform of any team, even for one game, Vincent gave that club credit for him in the team Hall of Fame standings. By that measure, Smith was the Cardinals' 39th Hall of Famer -- tying them with the Yankees (surprisingly, for fourth place).

    Using the Vincent scoring system, here are the teams with the most and fewest Hall of Famers. (We left out the four post-1993 expansion teams.)

    Most
    Giants, NL, 58
    Braves, NL, 52
    Dodgers, NL, 46
    Yankees, AL, 39
    Cardinals, NL, 39
    Reds, NL, 36
    Cubs, NL, 35
    Pirates, NL, 35

    Fewest (post-1961 expansion teams)
    Expos, NL, 1
    Mariners, AL, 1
    Blue Jays, AL, 2
    Rangers, AL, 3
    Brewers, NL, 4
    Royals, AL, 4
    Padres, NL, 4
    Astros, NL, 6
    Mets, NL, 7
    Angels, AL, 7

    Fewest (original francises)
    Tigers, AL, 20
    Twins, AL, 21
    Orioles, AL, 22
    White Sox, AL, 24
    Indians, AL, 24
    Red Sox, AL, 28
    Phillies, NL, 32
    Athletics, AL, 33

  • Rating the set-up men.

    No baseball species on earth gets less attention than set-up men. So let's rank how the set-up crew did last year in three revealing categories (minimum: 40 IP).

    Fewest hits per nine innings
    National League
    Felix Rodriguez, S.F., 5.94
    Chad Fox, Mil., 5.94
    Steve Kline, St. L., 6.36
    Octavio Dotel, Hou., 6.77
    Josias Manzanillo, Pit., 6.78

    American League
    Jeff Nelson, Sea., 4.13
    Juan Moreno, Tex., 4.79
    Danys Baez, Cle., 6.08
    Arthur Rhodes, Sea., 6.09
    Randy Choate, N.Y., 6.33

    Most strikeouts per nine innings
    National League
    Octavio Dotel, Hou., 12.43
    Kyle Farnsworth, Chi., 11.74
    Scott Sauerbeck, Pit., 11.35
    Mike Remlinger, Atl., 11.16
    Chad Fox, Mil., 10.80

    American League
    Dan Plesac, Tor., 13.50
    Jeff Nelson, Sea., 12.12
    Jay Witasick, S.D.-N.Y., 12.08
    Paul Shuey, Cle., 11.60
    Arthur Rhodes, Sea., 10.99

    Fewest baserunners per nine innings
    National League
    Felix Rodriguez, S.F., 9.07
    Greg Swindell, Ari., 9.89
    Josias Manzanillo, Pit., 10.28
    Steve Kline, St. L., 10.32
    Giovanni Carrara, L.A., 10.34

    American League
    Arthur Rhodes, Sea., 7.81
    Eddie Guardardo, Min., 9.59
    Norm Charlton, Sea., 9.63
    Buddy Groom, Bal., 10.09
    Steve Karsay, Cle., 10.13

    If names like Moreno, Fox, Baez or the still-unemployed Manzanillo shock you, it just shows how easy it is to overlook men who do this job -- even those who do it well.

  • An unknown Jeromy Burnitz claim to fame: No player in either league scored 100 runs via fewer hits than he did last year (104 runs, 141 hits). Next-fewest: Troy Glaus (100 runs, 147 hits), Trot Nixon (100 runs, 150 hits) and Jim Thome (101 runs, 153 hits).

  • But the best runs-per-hit ratio in the big leagues, for players who scored 50 runs or more, belonged to (surprise) Reds phenom Adam Dunn (54 runs, 64 hits, .844 runs per hit). Rest of the top five:

    Barry Bonds (129 runs, 156 hits, .827)
    Rickey Henderson (70 runs, 86 hits, .814)
    Tom Goodwin (51 runs, 66 hits, .773)
    Burnitz (.738)

  • There's no stat more entertaining than batting average (or lack thereof) by pitchers. So we're excited to report that nine pitchers got at least 20 at-bats last year and failed to hit .050. Here they come:

    Tony McKnight, Hou.-Pit., 0 for 24, .000
    Mark Gardner, S.F., 0 for 21, .000
    Mike Thurman, Mon., 1 for 42 (with 27 strikeouts), .024
    Jason Marquis, Atl., 1 for 31, .032
    Albie Lopez, T.B.-Ari., 1 for 24, .034
    Shawn Chacon, Col., 2 for 47, .043
    Ron Villone, Col.-Hou., 1 for 22, .045
    Bronson Arroyo, Pit., 1 for 21 (with 16 strikeouts), .048
    Ryan Dempster, Fla., 3 for 61, .049

    McKnight, for future reference, is now 0 for 37 lifetime, putting him within reach of what we believe to be the modern record for worst start to an offensive career -- 0 for 57, by Joey Hamilton in 1994 and '95.

    Thurman
    Thurman

  • Thurman, meanwhile, is up (or down) to a mind-warping 4 for 131 lifetime (.031), with 93 strikeouts. And that moves him into the heralded No. 2 hole -- behind only the official Worst-Hitting Pitcher Who Ever Lived, Ron Herbel (.029) -- for the lowest average of modern times among pitchers who batted at least 100 times.

    With the help of loyal reader Lee Sinins' tremendous new Sabermetric Encyclopedia (available through baseball-encyclopedia.com), we've computed the entire top (or bottom) 10:

    Pitcher Avg. AB H SO
    Ron Herbel .029 206 6 125
    Mike Thurman .031 131 4 93
    A. McGaffigan .048 126 6 80
    Ed Klepfer .048 125 6 46
    Bill Butler .051 117 6 79
    Taylor Phillips .053 113 6 55
    Glendon Rusch .055 110 6 44
    Bill Trotter .055 109 6 63
    Don Carman .057 209 12 75
    Mark Clark .058 242 14 106

    Best we can tell, Thurman also has struck out in a higher percentage of his at-bats (71 percent) than any pitcher since 1900. Butler was next, at 67.5 percent, followed by McGaffigan (63.5), Dean Chance (63.4), Herbel (60,7) Bob Bowman (60.4) and Willie Blair (60.1).

    Yet the most shocking news of all is that this same Mike Thurman is currently unemployed (after being non-tendered by the Expos last month). Hard to believe there isn't a team out there that couldn't use a proven .031 hitter.

  • Finally, the current edition of Newsweek includes results of a poll asking which sports figure was most capable of running the country.

    The winner: Michael Jordan, at 33 percent (you were expecting maybe Dan Snyder?)

    Runner-up: Joe Torre, at nine percent.

  • The all we-can't-believe-they're-still-unemployed team Believe it or not, nearly 90 free agents remain unsigned, less than three weeks before spring training. Here's an All-Star team of the most surprising names on that list:

    Starting pitchers
    Ismael Valdes, David Cone, James Baldwin, Pete Harnisch, Gil Heredia.

    (Kevin Tapani is probably retiring. Otherwise, he'd also be on there.)

    Relief pitchers
    Jeff Shaw (may retire), Josias Manzanillo, Alan Mills, Russ Springer, Ron Villone.

    Starting lineup
    1B: Andres Galarraga
    2B: Pokey Reese
    SS: Rey Sanchez
    3B: John Valentin
    LF: Rickey Henderson
    CF: Kenny Lofton
    RF: Ricky Ledee
    DH: Jose Canseco
    C: Sal Fasano

    Bench
    Ron Coomer
    Deivi Cruz
    Mike Lansing
    Gary DiSarcina
    Dante Bichette
    Troy O'Leary
    Devon White

    Manager
    Buck Showalter

    General manager
    Doug Melvin

    Trivia Answer
    Jason Giambi (32-114), Juan Gonzalez (36-125), Jeromy Burnitz (33-102) and Tino Martinez (30-115).

    Jayson Stark is a senior writer for ESPN.com.







  •  More from ESPN...
    Off Base: Baseball's ownership mess
    From the Red Sox sale to ...
    Jayson Stark Archive

     ESPN Tools
    Email story
     
    Most sent
     
    Print story