Yankees vs. A's | Mariners vs. White Sox | Braves vs. Cardinals | Mets vs. Giants
Monday, October 9
Gardner's at-bat snuffs out shot at rally
ESPN.com news services

NEW YORK -- When the San Francisco Giants had their one and only chance to make things interesting, manager Dusty Baker made a questionable choice: He didn't take the bat out of pitcher Mark Gardner's hands.

Rather than send in a pinch-hitter, Baker allowed Gardner to bat for himself in the fifth inning Sunday when the Giants had the bases loaded with two outs trailing 2-0.

Dusty's troubles
Here are arguably the 10 biggest games of Dusty Baker's managerial career:

Final game of 1993 season: Loss
Tied with the Braves for the NL West lead, the Dodgers pound the Giants 12-1 while the Braves win to clinch the division.

1997 DS vs. Marlins: Loss, Loss, Loss
The Giants lose 2-1, 7-6 and 6-2. The first two losses come in the bottom of the ninth. Rod Beck, who had 37 saves that year, didn't appear in either game (although Roberto Hernandez was also serving as closer by season's end).

Final game of 1998 season: Loss
Needing a win to clinch a wild-card berth, the Giants blow a 7-0 lead to the Rockies. Neifi Perez wins it 9-8 with a homer off Robb Nen in the bottom of the ninth.

1998 wild-card tiebreaker: Loss
The Giants lose 5-3 to the Cubs to lose out on a trip to the playoffs.

2000 DS vs. Mets: Win, Loss, Loss, Loss
The Giants lose Game 2 in 10 innings with Nen, the season's best closer, not appearing in the game. They lose Game 3, blowing a 2-1 lead in the eighth (Nen didn't come on until the tying run was on base). And they lose Game 4.

By our count, that puts the Giants at 1-9 in these 10 games.
-- ESPN.com

After flailing weakly at the first pitch and taking the second pitch for a ball, Gardner popped out to second baseman Edgardo Alfonzo to end the inning.

Just one-third of an inning later, Gardner was knocked out of the game -- making Baker's decision look even worse.

"I don't regret it," Baker said, explaining that he thought it was too early to turn to a bullpen that had been depleted the day before in a 13-inning game. "If you don't have a full bullpen, you don't have a full bullpen."

Baker will have all winter to think about it after the New York Mets ended San Francisco's season. Jones pitched a one-hitter to defeat the Giants 4-0, and the Mets won the best-of-5 series 3-1.

Gardner was a .116 hitter during the regular season, getting only five singles in 43 at-bats and striking out 22 times. He is a career .128 hitter in 10½ seasons.

Had Baker chosen to send up a pinch-hitter for Gardner against right-hander Bobby J. Jones, his choices included switch-hitter Felipe Crespo, who batted .315 left-handed -- including .333 (13-for-39) as a pinch-hitter.

"My job at that time is to be ready, whether he decides to put someone in or not," Crespo said. "I'm not there to decide. That's not my job."

Other pinch-hitting candidates included Ramon Martinez, a .302 hitter during the regular season, Armando Rios, Russ Davis or Calvin Murray, who was 3-for-8 during the regular season as a pinch-hitter.

"At that point we thought we were going to get (Jones) on the ropes again," Gardner said. "It was early in the ballgame, it was only 2-0. Usually when that happens and the pitcher is taken out, that might be your last chance to score runs and I don't think he felt that way."

The bases-loaded threat represented the only time the Giants got even close to scoring against Jones.

Baker, meanwhile, said he wants to return to the Giants and hopes to have a new contract negotiated "before the end of the World Series, to tell the truth."

Giants owner Pete Magowan said, "for the 11,000th time, I want it written 11,000, I want Dusty Baker back here with the team next year."

As much as both sides say they want to continue the relationship that began when Baker was hired to replaced Roger Craig in November 1992, there are some financial ramifications to be considered.

Baker turned down a two-year, $2.7 million extension to the contract that paid him $750,000 in 2000, 14th among major-league managers, even though he is fourth among managers in continuous service behind Tom Kelly of Minnesota, Bobby Cox of Atlanta and Lou Piniella of Seattle.

With the Giants' elimination Sunday, Baker's asking price figures to come down some -- there was speculation he had his sights set on the $3 million a year that Joe Torre is being paid by the Yankees.

He, however, is going to command more than the four-year, $5.2 million Don Baylor received a year ago from the Cubs.

"I certainly hope he will be our manager next year," Magowan said in the somber visiting clubhouse at Shea Stadium following Sunday's 4-0 loss to the Mets. "I think he truly wants to be here, and it's been our goal all along."

While Baker admitted frustrations from a Division Series in which the Giants won the opener, but then lost back-to-back games in extra innings before being one-hit by Jones, the experience only reinforced his feelings for the team.

Baker could be among the most coveted free agents in an off-season that will feature the likes of outfielder Manny Ramirez, shortstop Alex Rodriguez, and pitchers Mike Hampton and Mike Mussina.

There already are managerial openings in Los Angeles, Pittsburgh, Philadelphia, Cincinnati and Arizona.

Mets manager Bobby Valentine, whose team opens the NLCS at St. Louis on Wednesday, and Piniella, whose Mariners open the ALCS on Tuesday, also are in the last year of their contracts.

And as a high-placed major league official said, "if Dusty put himself out there I'm sure there would be opportunities that nobody anticipates right now."

Baker isn't interested.

"I like where I am," said Baker, a native of Sacramento, where his parents still live. "I like working with Brian (Sabean, general manager). I like the attitude of the people. We have a good core of guys.

"I can't unequivocally say I'm going to manage the Giants next year. I can't unequivocally say I'm going to be alive. I'd like to be here, yes. We have work undone. We have some unfinished business. Now that (the season) is over it's easy for us to concentrate on what we have to do to get it done."



ESPN.com:HELP | ADVERTISER INFO | CONTACT US | TOOLS | SITE MAP | JOBS AT ESPN.COM
Copyright ©2000 ESPN Internet Ventures. Terms of Use and Privacy Policy and Safety Information are applicable to this site. Click here for a list of employment opportunities at ESPN.com.



CLUBHOUSES
Mets
Giants

ALSO SEE
Mets eliminate Giants on Jones' one-hitter

Shea it isn't so -- Bonds' postseason ends poorly

MULTIMEDIA

NL playoff analyst Chad Kreuter on Dusty Baker's decision to let pitcher Mark Gardner hit with the bases loaded.
wav: 1614 k Real: 14.4 | 28.8 | 56.6