ESPN.com - MLB Playoffs 2001 - Torre favors Justice over O'Neill in Game 1

Friday, October 26
 
Torre favors Justice over O'Neill in Game 1

Associated Press

PHOENIX -- History won out over loyalty when New York Yankees manager Joe Torre made out his lineup for Game 1 of the World Series.

Game 1 lineups
Yankees
LF -- Chuck Knoblauch
SS -- Derek Jeter
RF -- David Justice
CF -- Bernie Williams
1B -- Tino Martinez
C -- Jorge Posada
2B -- Alfonso Soriano
3B -- Scott Brosius
P --Mike Mussina

D-Backs
SS -- Tony Womack
2B -- Craig Counsell
LF -- Luis Gonzalez
RF -- Reggie Sanders
CF -- Steve Finley
3B -- Matt Williams
1B -- Mark Grace
C -- Damian Miller
P -- Curt Schilling

Torre opted to start David Justice in right field for Saturday's opener against Arizona's Curt Schilling instead of one of his favorite players, Paul O'Neill.

"I'm very loyal to him but in fairness to the other 24 guys my first loyalty has to be to the team and the players that might be the better matchup," Torre said Friday. "Paul O'Neill has been very dear to me."

O'Neill, described by Torre as the "heart and soul" of the Yankees' dynasty, is likely in his final days before retirement. But George Steinbrenner's warrior won't be in the starting lineup for either of the first two games with nasty left-hander Randy Johnson slated to start Game 2.

"To say I'm not disappointed, I'd be lying," O'Neill said. "But winning the World Series is the important thing. We're looking to do what the Yankees want to accomplish, not make someone happy."

The idea of O'Neill sitting out a World Series game for the Yankees is difficult to fathom, especially against a right-handed pitcher. He has played all but one Series game for the Yankees and usually only sits against the toughest of lefties.

But Torre bypassed O'Neill in the opener because of Justice's success against Schilling and the lack of a designated hitter in the National League park. Justice is 10-for-28 (.357) with four homers in his career against Schilling, compared to O'Neill's .211 average with no homers.

"Obviously I should have taken those at-bats against Schilling more seriously," he said.

O'Neill, 38, has taken everything seriously since joining the Yankees after the 1992 season in one of the most important moves in building the dynasty. Known for intensity and equipment throwing as well as his hitting, O'Neill batted over .300 six times for New York and brought a professionalism to a clubhouse that lacked it in the early '90s.

He played through injuries in the postseason in 1996 and 2000 and his father's death in 1999, helping lead the Yankees to titles. He missed much of the final month of this season with a broken foot and was benched for two games in the first round against Oakland's tough lefties.

O'Neill regained his stroke in the ALCS, hitting .417 with two homers against Seattle. But he won't get another start until next Tuesday in Game 3.

"You look forward to going and playing in the World Series," O'Neill said. "He made a decision. It's not like it hasn't happened before. There have been games I haven't played."

Torre will bench another regular for Game 2 against Johnson. Randy Velarde, who has a .452 career average against the Big Unit, said Torre told him he would start at either third or first base. That would send either Scott Brosius or Tino Martinez to the bench.

The Yankees will have one of their toughest World Series tasks in recent memory facing Schilling and Johnson in the first two games.

A team that prides itself on working the count, fouling off pitches, and wearing down the opposing starter might need to find a different strategy against a pitcher with the impeccable control, overpowering heat and endurance that Arizona's aces have.

"These two guys have a custom of putting people in slumps," New York's Bernie Williams said.

But the Yankees have beaten Greg Maddux, Tom Glavine, John Smoltz, Kevin Brown, Mike Hampton and Al Leiter in winning four of the last five World Series.

"When you get to the World Series you're going to face some bad boys," Justice said. "Each year it's the same. The names might change."

While the Yankees wore down those pitchers, it might not be as easy to do that against Schilling, who has nine complete games this season -- including three straight in the playoffs.

Taking pitches isn't necessarily the best strategy against a pitcher with Schilling's control and stuff. He walked only 39 batters in 256 2-3 innings this season -- the second best rate in the NL -- and got tougher the deeper into the count he went.

"If they try to be more patient with him, I'm sure Curt can make an adjustment and do what he has to do to be equally effective against that kind of a lineup," Arizona manager Bob Brenly said.

According to STATS, Inc., batters who put the first pitch in play hit .429 against Schilling as opposed to .210 for those who waited.

Falling behind 0-1 left hitters pretty much defenseless as Schilling had the option of using his overpowering high heat or his splitter that drops off the table. When Schilling started ahead in the count, he held hitters to a .174 average.

"If I'm on tomorrow, there will be a lot of 0-1, 0-2 counts quickly in the game," he said. "I throw a lot of first-pitch strikes and if they are taking that will work to my advantage."






Series Page


 More from ESPN...
Hershiser: Scouting reports vital to success
ESPN's Orel Hershiser says ...

Wojnarowski: Out of nowhere
How Mariano Rivera became the ...

Klapisch: Scouting gives Yanks another edge
An elaborate system of ...

Special, patriotic balls will be used for Series
Special balls with a ...

D-Backs: A little money, lots of luck
How were the expansion ...

Showalter: Systems that go
Buck Showalter on the systems ...

 ESPN Tools
Email story
 
Most sent
 
Print story