| Player | Team | Analysis |
| Andre Iguodala | 76ers | Back-of-board reverse a classic, but ran out of tricks |
| Nate Robinson | Knicks | Spud spike electric, but got gift from judges at end |
| Josh Smith | Hawks | Defending champ's tape takeoff fell flat |
| Hakim Warrick | Grizzlies | Underdog needed to hit second dunk on first take |
Roll over player name for grade
