Friday, September 29
Illinois coach calls for instant replay



CHAMPAIGN, Ill. -- The Big Ten said Monday that two game-turning fumble calls late in Michigan's 35-31 victory over Illinois were mistakes, and Illini coach Ron Turner called on the NCAA to use instant replay to review such plays.

Big Ten officiating coordinator David Parry said both disputed fumble rulings would have gone Illinois' way instead of Michigan's if an NFL-style instant replay system was in use Saturday.

Turner, a former assistant with the Chicago Bears, said colleges could copy the system used by the NFL in which coaches can request a replay but lose a timeout if the ruling stands.

Parry, also the national coordinator of officiating for the NCAA, called instant replay "highly, highly unlikely" because of the cost and logistics involved in equipping every stadium. Parry acknowledged the two fumbles in question from Saturday's game would have been overturned after a review of tape.

With Illinois up 31-28, officials ruled halfback Rocky Harvey fumbled when it appeared the ground jarred the ball loose. Harvey recovered, but it was taken from him in the pileup.

On the ensuing Michigan drive, tailback Anthony Thomas dropped the ball near the goal line but officials ruled him down. The replay showed otherwise, but the Wolverines kept the ball. Thomas scored on a 3-yard run on the next play, putting Illinois down four points with just 2:30 left.

"There's no question in this case that technology shows that we've had a couple fumbles that could have been officiated better," Parry said. "At normal speed, they were probably inconclusive. But when you use the technology, it does not defend the judgment of the officials."

Turner will not blame the calls for Illinois' loss, saying Michigan played well enough to win and there were many other factors in the Wolverines' rallying from a 21-7 deficit.

"You would at least like to get it right and let the players decide it," Turner said. "I'm not saying that didn't happen in our last game."




ALSO SEE
Michigan's Carr miffed by Big Ten's apology to Illinois

Wolverines survive as Illini fumble chances


VIDEO video
 Here's something the refs didn't have: replays.
avi: 1730 k
RealVideo: 56.6 | ISDN | T1






ESPN.com: HELP | ADVERTISER INFO | CONTACT US | TOOLS | SITE MAP
Copyright ©2000 ESPN Internet Ventures. Terms of Use and
Privacy Policy and Safety Information are applicable to this site. Click here for a list of employment opportunities at ESPN.com.