Say what you want about the Patriots -- those of us on the couch all day
watching the game and its accompanying festivities on TV got a look at the
real winners and losers:
|
Real winners and losers of Super Bowl XXXVI |
| General category |
Specific example |
Winner/Loser |
Why |
| Halftime entertainment |
 U2 |
Winner |
They rock; would have enjoyed a few more songs. (Was I the only one who saw Bono take a spill?) |
| Halftime entertainment |
The imported crowd at the U2 stage |
Winner |
My friend Kelly put it best -- Did they make everyone grab a piece of stage or two on the hustle out in exchange for the great seats? |
| Halftime entertainment |
Playmates on "Fear Factor" |
Loser |
Even bunnies can't compete with U2. |
| Halftime entertainment |
Backdrop of victims' names from Sept. 11 |
Winner |
The most powerful moment of the night. |
| Confusion |
"What is MLIFE?" |
Loser |
Because I still don't know. Something to do with bellybuttons?
|
| Charitable contributions |
That guy who bought the Porsche from Boomer Esiason via Cris Collinsworth.
|
Winner (charity); Loser (new owner) |
Kept thinking of the Seinfeld episode where George is obsessed with owning the used car of "a Mr. Jon Voight."
|
| TV special effect |
Pregame show super-zoom from satellite to Superdome. |
Winner |
Yes, and NASA was also peeking into your Super Bowl party. |
| Fashion statement (headwear) |
Backward baseball caps |
Winner |
Brady's signature displaces the formerly trendy backwards visors. |
| Broadway Velvet |
Joe Namath at the Maxim party |
Loser |
Joe Willie looked like a pimp in Jillian Barberie's hat. |
| Scared straight |
ONDCP anti-drug ads |
Winner |
Play on Mastercard, Euro-PlayStation ads and tying drugs to terrorism -- pretty potent.
|
| Marriage |
Soldier's proposal beamed from Kandahar, Afghanistan |
Winner |
Sure makes your marriage proposal on the stadium Jumbotron seem weak.
|
| Fashion statement (jackets) |
Donald Rumsfeld's fleece vest |
Winner |
Rummy knows that layers work best both in winter and wartime. |
| Auto emissions |
The Ford Focus ad |
Loser |
Does the car inspire flatulence? |
| Musical act |
No Doubt |
Loser |
What was worse Gwen Stefani's hair or zebra-inspired dress. You pick. |
| New song "Let Freedom Ring" |
 Barry Manilow |
Loser |
Dug his 9/11 commemorative jacket, but -- yikes -- the guy's aged like a piece of rodeo saddle. |
| New song "Let Freedom Ring" |
Patti LaBelle |
Winner |
The diva shows us how it's done. |
| Historical documents |
The Declaration of Independence |
Winner |
Now that it's going on a national road trip, I want to see it on "Antiques Roadshow" -- "At auction, I think this could command somewhere around, oh, $1 billion."
|
| Historical re-enactments |
The Founding Fathers |
Loser |
With the exception of Ben Franklin, could you ID any of those figures by sight? The reading by football greats was more than enough. |
| Composers |
Aaron Copland |
Winner |
"Lincoln's Portrait" deserved the nationwide props. |
| Movie ads |
"Spider-Man" |
Winner |
So cool it got me out of my seat. Next generation "Matrix." |
| Pregame entertainment |
 Marc Anthony |
Loser |
Expected him to follow "America the Beautiful" with a cover of Corey Hart's "I Wear My Sunglasses at Night."
|
| Bling bling |
 That piece on Mariah Carey's wrist |
Winner |
With that $28 million buyout of her record contract, no wonder she can afford to drip in it.
|
| Stadium technology |
The field-cleaning tool used to pick up stray pieces of paper |
Loser |
It's 2002, and we can't come up with anything more sophisticated than a lint brush? |
| Neckties |
Roger Staubach and G.H.W. Bush |
Loser |
Polka dots were a little garish; where were the patriotic designs?
|
| New beer intro |
Sam Adams Light |
Winner |
I mean, I was kind of fooled. |
| "Old" beer intro |
Michelob Light |
Loser |
Targeting older consumers is sketchy enough. But using a song by the Soup Dragons?
|
| Britney |
 A theme-by-theme review |
'50s diner (winner); Bandstand (loser); Beach-blanket (winner); Hippie
(loser); Robert Palmer (loser); Today (winner)
|
At some point, you just forget about the fact she's selling soda. |
| Super Bowl ad |
Quizno's |
Loser |
Did they not get the memo that we're not down with violence these days? Who the hell are they anyway? |
| A riot -- and a laugh riot |
 Lipton Brisk |
Winner |
Danny DeVito was good, but the cameos by Al Roker, O'Brien, puppet Jackie Childs were captivating. |
| Animals in Ads, Part 1 |
Bud Light's "The Falcon" |
Winner |
Animal ads always get raves. |
| Oh, now I get it |
HotJobs.com |
Winner |
Delayed gratification on the mimic-turned-stenographer. |
| Rip-off |
Bud Light's "Robot Wars" |
Loser |
Isn't this an Energizer ad? |
| Athlete as endorser |
Charles Schwab's use of Barry Bonds and Hank Aaron |
Winner |
Hammerin' Hank is kind of funny; Bonds surpasses him in less than three seasons. |
| Animals in ads, part 2 |
Bud's Clydesdales in New York City |
Winner |
Perennial snoozer breaks out with touching tribute.
|
| Putting the "ass" in "fantastic" |
Bud's "Your Daughter's Tushie" |
Winner |
That kind of happened to me with my girlfriend's parents. |
| Six degrees of ... |
Kevin Bacon |
Winner |
Visa finally brings the country's favorite underground pop-culture game to the mainstream.
|
| Best use of primate |
E*Trade Financial |
Winner |
Self-referential "worst Super Bowl ad ever" moment. And the clever use of women pulling up their flowing dresses to communicate product attributes. Subliminal? Hardly. |
| Fresh legs |
Bud's "How You Doin'? Goes Country" |
Winner |
Bud's best franchise finds new life poking fun at people from the South.
|
| Celebrity ad directors |
The Coen brothers |
Losers |
Surprise -- they couldn't turn taxes into "Fargo."
|
| Gender relations |
Bud's "The Card Store" |
Winner |
It's funny because it's true. |
| Must-have car |
The Cadillac Escalade EXT |
Winner |
Tom Brady drives one now. And it holds a smaller car in the back! |
| Facial hair |
Three-week growth |
Winner |
Hey, if it works for Vinatieri, it works for me. |
| Pregame player introductions |
Patriots forgoing individual intros for team intro |
Winner |
Set new bar in professional sports for selflessness. No wonder they won.
|