In the last decade, the age of specialization has changed the way baseball views relief pitching.
Closers are now limited to an inning of work at a time and are aided by a support staff which includes long relievers, middle men, lefty specialists and set-up guys.
But one thing hasn't changed: the way baseball finds relievers. Mostly, general managers, scouts and scouting directors agree: it's still done the old fashioned way.
"Take a look at a list of the best closers," said one major-league scout. "Most of them are failed starting pitchers. They're just converted."
Indeed, the evolution at the major-league level hasn't led to a revolution at the scouting level. The object is still to uncover as many quality arms as possible -- their roles can be determined later.
"In my opinion," said another scout, "it's a major mistake to go out and peg a guy to be a closer. It's like drafting a punter in the first round -- you see it every once in a while, but not often.
"For the most part, guys become closers as a last resort."
To that degree, things haven't changed much. Goose Gossage was auditioned as a starter before finding his niche in the bullpen. So, too, was Dennis Eckersley, though Eckersley had far greater success in his first assignment, winning 100 games, enjoying a 20-win season and tossing a no-hitter, before Tony La Russa and Dave Duncan moved him to relief.
|  | | Billy Wagner started 70 games in the minors prior to becoming the Astros' closer. |
It's no different today. As recently as 1995, Mariano Rivera started 10 games for the New York Yankees. John Wetteland, Derek Lowe, and Jason Isringhausen are just a few of the closers who started first, then were shifted to the pen.
"You need innings to develop," said another scout. "If you have a kid with a good arm, you want him to start because he can be more valuable that way. Which would you rather have -- a guy who can give you 225 innings or a guy who can give you 60?"
Simple math carries the day. It's more critical to find a pitcher capable of pitching the first six innings than the final one.
Not that there hasn't been some philosophical shift. A survey of personnel experts came up with a handful of pitchers who had been selected in recent years with the express purpose of having them close -- or attempt to, anyway -- at the major-league level.
That list would be headed by Cleveland's Paul Shuey, and include the likes of Braden Looper, Matt Anderson and Ryan Bradley. Shuey, Looper and Anderson were all top draft picks expected to quickly assume closer duties. All three are in the majors but haven't developed as anticipated.
A former Houston scout recalls that when Billy Wagner was taken in the first round of the 1993 draft, some in the Astros organization figured he might someday close.
|
“ |
I've never been in
a draft meeting where someone said, 'Let's look for a closer with this
pick.' ” |
|
|
— A scout from a prominent team |
"He was a two-pitch guy," recalled the scout. "But as an organization, we wanted him to start in the minors to let him develop his pitches and give him a certain amount of innings."
But for the most part, teams don't pigeonhole young pitchers prior to the draft. Closers are born of circumstance, not selected.
"I've never been in a draft meeting," said a scout from a prominent team, "where someone said, 'Let's look for a closer with this pick.' "
Young pitchers, it's agreed, need to pitch, particularly at the lower levels. Drafting and labeling someone as a closer, by definition, limits the amount of work a young pitcher will get.
"It's a problem in the lower minors," said another scout. "A kid might not get as much opportunity. You want him to pitch and get innings. It's kind of a tough situation in A-ball or Double-A to say, 'You're going to be a closer,' because he might go four or five days without getting into a game. And the whole idea is, you want him to pitch and develop."
That's why Billy Koch, who set a rookie record for most saves in a season in 1999, was first utilized in the rotation when Toronto drafted him out of Clemson.
"The game is so hard up for (starting) pitching," said an AL scout, "that everyone would rather see a young guy work out as a starter first."
It's no different at the amateur level, where high school and college coaches want to maximize innings from the most talented pitchers.
"In college and high school," said a former free-agent scout, "the best arms are the starters. That's what you're looking for -- go get the best guys and let nature take its course."
Kansas City closer Roberto Hernandez, who has 266 major-league saves, was first a catcher at the University of South Carolina-Aiken. He later moved to the mound when his arm strength was recognized. In the minor leagues, 106 of his 107 appearances were as a starter.
There are always opportunities to move a pitcher from the rotation to the bullpen. The Red Sox alone have had three closers over the last three seasons -- Tom Gordon, Tim Wakefield and Derek Lowe. Each came to the big leagues as a starter, only to move to the bullpen out of necessity.
In a perfect world, teams would have pitchers make the transition out of season, away from the pressures of a major-league pennant race.
"The Arizona Fall League and winter ball are good developmental platforms," said a scout. "Winter ball, in particular, is a good place. If you're pitching in Puerto Rico, you're facing guys like Roberto Alomar, Pudge Rodriguez, Juan Gonzalez ... It's the perfect opportunity to try it out."
The success of pitchers like Gordon (who was 30 in his first full season as a closer), La Troy Hawkins (who was a perfect 14-for-14 last year when he was handed the closing chores at 27) and Eckersley shows it's never too late to learn.
Sean McAdam of the Providence Journal writes a major-league notebook each week during the baseball season for ESPN.com.
Send this story to a friend |
ALSO SEE
ESPN.com's Spring Training coverage
|