| Player | Team | Analysis |
| Rudy Gay | Grizzlies | Sweet off-stanchion dunk, but lame opener costly |
| Gerald Green | Timberwolves | Could have won; "birthday cake" one for the ages |
| Dwight Howard | Magic | Cape dunk drew raves, but lefty tap was even better |
| Jamario Moon | Raptors | Lost judges by taking off two feet in front of tape |
 |
ESPN Insider John Hollinger's grade: B- |
