| Player | Team | POS | Analysis |
| LaMarcus Aldridge | Trail Blazers | F | His six O-boards cleaned up sophs' rare misses. |
| Andrea Bargnani | Raptors | F | Started game with dunk but did little afterward. |
| Ronnie Brewer | Jazz | G | Passed too fancy, but made all six shots. |
| Jordan Farmar | Lakers | G | Game-high 12 assists set up several highlights. |
| Rudy Gay | Grizzlies | G | A worthy MVP if Gibson hadn't shot lights out. |
| Daniel Gibson | Cavaliers | G | Well, he was focused: MVP took 20 treys, no 2s. |
| Paul Millsap | Jazz | F | Other eight sophs scored 134; he scored two. |
| Rajon Rondo | Celtics | G | Usual pesky effort with six dimes, three steals. |
| Brandon Roy | Trail Blazers | G | Solid all-around game with 17, seven dimes. |
 |
ESPN Insider John Hollinger's grade: B+ |
