At the annual Boston Baseball Writers Dinner earlier this month, Red Sox manager Jimy Williams welcomed the addition of free agent David Cone, signed to a contract only an hour before the dinner began.
"Now," said Williams wryly, "we only have 10 starters."
Williams knows the Red Sox will have quanity. If things go right, he'll have quality, too.
But less than a month before the start of spring training, the Red Sox pitching situation is as unsettled as any club in the league. That's not unusual for a team like Minnesota or Baltimore or Kansas City, clubs that are hoping to rebuild.
It is for a club expected to contend for a playoff spot.
|
For starters
|
|
Statistics from last season for each pitcher (both as a starter and a reliever) who could be a part of the starting rotations for the Yankees and Red Sox in 2001:
|
|
Boston
|
Games
|
Innings
|
ER
|
ERA
|
|
Martinez
|
29
|
217
|
42
|
1.74
|
|
Arrojo
|
32
|
172.2
|
108
|
5.63
|
|
Nomo
|
32
|
190
|
100
|
4.74
|
|
Castillo
|
25
|
138
|
55
|
3.59
|
|
Ohka
|
13
|
69.1
|
24
|
3.12
|
|
Cone
|
30
|
155
|
119
|
6.91
|
|
Wakefield
|
51
|
159.1
|
97
|
5.48
|
|
Combined
|
212
|
1101.1
|
545
|
4.46
|
|
Yankees
|
Games
|
Innings
|
ER
|
ERA
|
|
Mussina
|
34
|
237.2
|
100
|
3.79
|
|
Clemens
|
32
|
204
|
84
|
3.70
|
|
Pettitte
|
32
|
204.2
|
99
|
4.35
|
|
Hernandez
|
29
|
195.2
|
98
|
4.51
|
|
Gooden
|
27
|
105
|
55
|
4.71
|
|
Combined
|
154
|
947
|
436
|
4.14
|
The Sox will score runs, particularly with the addition of RBI king Manny Ramirez and expected bounce-back seasons from the likes of Jason Varitek and John Valentin.
But the Red Sox will succeed or fail on the strength of their starting pitching, and right now, few can accurately forecast how good that will be.
Williams wasn't exaggerating -- the Sox really do have 10 candidates for the rotation.
But a more realistic head count might view the competition this way: seven pitchers for two spots.
Pedro Martinez is the acknowledged staff ace, and Rolando Arrojo and Hideo Nomo are virtual locks for the second and third spots.
That leaves these pitchers fighting for the final two slots: David Cone, Bret Saberhagen, Tim Wakefield, Pete Schourek, Tomo Ohka, Paxton Crawford, and Frank Castillo.
Cone and Saberhagen are the most intriguing of the field. Together, they've won three Cy Young Awards, 350 games and six World Championship rings. Neither, however, is guaranteed a spot on the staff.
Cone endured his worst season last year, losing 14 games and compiling an unsightly 6.91 ERA. But Williams and pitching coach Joe Kerrigan watched Cone three weeks ago in Florida and had any doubts resolved.
"In my estimation," said Williams, "he's healthy. I really believe that. He's changed his delivery and simplified it."
The Sox are also banking on Cone's desire for redemption. A proud man and intense competitor, he doesn't want his nightmarish 2000 season to be his legacy.
In a sense, the same can be said about Saberhagen, who missed all of last year after undergoing shoulder surgery -- his third such procedure -- in November of 1999.
"I expect that if my arm feels good, I will have one of the spots in our rotation this spring," Saberhagen said recently. "But right now, I'm not concentrating on having or not having a spot in the rotation. I'm concentrating on getting my shoulder sound."
|  | | Bret Saberhagen has a 25-15 record with a 3.80 ERA in three seasons ('97-'99) with the Red Sox. |
Last year, Saberhagen boldly predicted that he would be ready to start the season in the rotation. When that didn't happen, he aimed at the All-Star break. From there, he tried for the final month. Eventually, he ran out of time.
"I'm being the opposite this year, as far as being not completely optimistic," he said. "This time, a year has passed, my shoulder has healed, I've done my strength work and if it doesn't work, we'll take it from there. I hope everything falls into place. We just have to wait and see. I really don't know what will happen, but I should know in a relatively short period of time."
Castillo may be a free-agent bargain. He didn't qualify for the ERA title -- he threw 138 innings and needed 162 -- but fashioned a 3.59 ERA, which would have placed him second among AL starters behind only Martinez.
Of course, the reason Castillo didn't pitch the requisite number of innings for the Blue Jays was because of a balky elbow in the second half. The Red Sox are satisfied that it won't be a lingering issue, but that fear exists.
Wakefield, who averaged nearly 15 wins in his first four seasons in Boston, is more likely to be used in a swing role -- capable of the occasional spot start, but utilized chiefly out of the bullpen. Either way, Wakefield's versatility -- he was 15-for-18 in save chances when Tom Gordon went down in 1999 -- is invaluable.
Schourek, like Saberhagen, is a physical question mark. He gamely pitched in pain last season, forgoing elbow surgery until he could no longer throw. Schourek has undergone nearly a half-dozen procedures on his elbow over the course of his career and there are still some problems in his shoulder.
Signed to a Triple-A deal with an invite to spring training, Schourek is by no means a sure thing. But the club loves his competitiveness and could use a lefty in the rotation if he's physically capable.
That leaves Ohka and Crawford. Understand that the Sox haven't developed a pitcher who's won double figures in the majors since Aaron Sele, and the team's track record for bringing young arms to the big leagues under GM Dan Duquette is, frankly, atrocious.
Ohka has promise. In 13 games last year -- 12 of them starts -- he went 3-6. But his 3.12 ERA is far more indicative of his promise. Like Martinez, he was the victim of poor run support -- in his six losses, the team averaged a run per game.
Had not the Sox added Nomo, Castillo and Cone, Ohka almost certainly would have won a job in the spring. But now, thanks to veterans with track records -- to say nothing of guaranteed contracts -- his fight will be decidedly uphill.
"No one said life is fair," Williams admitted.
Crawford won nine games in 20 starts between Double-A and Triple-A, but has just four major-league starts on his resume.
There had been some talk that the Red Sox would be willing to experiment with the configuration of the rotation, which might have included the concept of a "floating starter" -- not unlike what the Yankees tried with Cone in the final month of the 1999 season, when they arranged their rotation to have him pitch once a week (rather than once every five days) and fit everyone else around him.
But that was in September, when expanded rosters allowed more flexibility. Using a sixth starter from April though August almost certainly would have required a 12-man staff, or at the very least, pulling Wakefield in and out of the rotation on short or long rest to accommodate others.
"It would be unique," conceded Williams of the theory. "But during the season, you need continuity. I think you have to solidify things. You need to establish five guys and set them up. We're going to do our darndest to find those five."
How successful they are may well determine the team's fate for the 2001 season. If it's true there's strength in numbers, the Sox could be mighty strong.
A few well-kept secrets
From the perception-becomes-reality department:
On a short list of the best home run ballparks, Boston and Baltimore would figure to rate pretty high.
But in data compiled by Stats, Inc., Camden Yards, over the last three seasons, is seventh in the AL in homers per at-bat and Fenway Park, astonishingly, is second worst in the major leagues.
Fenway, as many have correctly stated, is not the homer haven it once was, and hasn't been since the ballpark underwent a facelift after the 1988 season.
It may be a great doubles park, and it's certainly a great park for scoring (fifth best in the AL over the last three seasons). But it's not, as everyone from Mo Vaughn to Nomar Garciaparra would confirm, a great home run ballpark.
So what's the best homer-happy place in the AL?
Try The Ballpark at Arlington, which might explain why Ken Caminiti, Andres Galarraga and Alex Rodriguez landed in Texas.
The third best in the AL is Comiskey Park, which might seem like news to the White Sox themselves, since they're bringing the fences in.
In the NL, after Coors Field and the one-year old Enron Field -- where adjustments are being made -- the place to mash is Busch Stadium, which probably comes as a shock to Whitey Herzog, who spent the decade of the 1980s compiling rosters with plenty of speed.
Sean McAdam of the Providence Journal writes a major-league notebook each week during the baseball season for ESPN.com. Send this story to a friend | |
ALSO SEE
Hot Stove Heaters: Red Sox
Red Sox minor-league report
Season in review: Boston Red Sox
|