MIAMI GARDENS, Fla. -- With the Miami Dolphins needing any kind of score to end a four-game losing streak, two points were plenty.
On third-and-10 from his 8, Dalton retreated to the goal line and was tackled by Wake coming up the middle for the third overtime safety in NFL history.
The officials immediately signaled the score, which was upheld following a replay review.
"You just have to do whatever you can to get to the quarterback," Wake said. "It couldn't have come at a better time. How much better could it have been than to have a D-lineman seal the deal?"
The Pro Bowl end totaled three sacks, and Cincinnati committed four turnovers that might have meant a difference of 17 points.
Bengals coach Marvin Lewis disputed the safety call in his postgame news conference, saying the "ball was out of the end zone."
"But I don't get it, I don't know," Lewis said. "That's a quick look at the board. They got a little better resolution to look at it than I do."
NFL vice president of officiating Dean Blandino, speaking later in an interview with NFL Network, confirmed the call was correct.
"We had a great look at it, a look right down the goal line," Blandino said. "And when Wake first makes contact with Dalton, the ball is breaking the plane of the goal line. If any part of that ball is breaking the plane when the contact occurs, and he's driven back into the end zone, that's a safety."
The Dolphins (4-4) won for the first time since their 3-0 start and snapped a four-game winning streak by the Bengals (6-3).
"You never want to lose four games in a row," Miami coach Joe Philbin said, "and we had an excellent football team coming in town. It was time for us to step up, and we had to make a decision -- what are we going to be? And I thought they answered the bell pretty well tonight."
The Bengals still enjoy a two-game lead in the AFC North, but their ranks are rapidly thinning. Defensive tackle Geno Atkins left the game in the second quarter with a knee injury, and Lewis said the injury appeared to involve the All-Pro's ACL, which could be season-ending. A Bengals source told ESPN's Bob Holtzman that Atkins tore his ACL but will have an MRI on Friday to confirm the diagnosis. Atkins was on crutches after the game.
The teams traded punts to start overtime. After Cincinnati's Terence Newman was called for a 38-yard pass interference penalty, the Bengals dug in and forced another punt that pinned them deep, setting up the safety by Wake.
"My eyes were downfield, and he was there pretty quick," Dalton said, adding he thought he was out of the end zone.
"I don't think anyone expected the game to end on a safety," Miami quarterback Ryan Tannehill said.
The Bengals lost despite totaling 28 first downs and 465 yards while holding Miami to three third-down conversions. They could have tried a 56-yard field goal in overtime but punted instead.
"We had a chance, maybe," Lewis said, "but we felt better about pinning them down."
Lewis made another decision that backfired, at the end of the first half. When the Bengals started from their 15 with no timeouts and 45 seconds left, he decided against running out the clock.
Mike Nugent kicked a 54-yard field goal with 1:24 remaining in regulation to put the Bengals ahead, but Miami answered with a 50-yard drive, and Sturgis made a 44-yard field goal with 11 seconds left to force overtime.
Brent Grimes returned an interception 94 yards for a touchdown to put the Dolphins up 17-3 midway through the third quarter, but they squandered a two-touchdown, second-half lead for the second time in five days. On Sunday in a loss at New England, they were outscored 24-0 in the final 24 minutes.
Cincinnati's Giovani Bernard scored on an electrifying 35-yard touchdown run that covered perhaps twice that much ground to tie it in the third quarter. He started right, doubled back left, weaved up the sideline, cut back across the middle and somersaulted into the end zone, leaving Dolphins sprawled in his wake along the way.
The run took 16 seconds. At least four defenders had shots at him, including Grimes, who missed twice -- once in the backfield as the play unfolded.
Cincinnati's Marvin Jones was kept out of the end zone four days after he caught four touchdown passes. Dalton's 50-yard touchdown pass to Jones was negated by a holding call against Jermaine Gresham as the Bengals sputtered four days after scoring 49 points in beating the New York Jets.
The Bengals drove 64 yards for a field goal in the second quarter to take a 3-0 lead and mounted an 80-yard drive for a touchdown in the third quarter. But Grimes' interception represented a potential 14-point swing, because the Bengals were at the Miami 10.
Bernard bruised his ribs in the fourth quarter, but the injury wasn't believed to be serious. ... Miami G Richie Incognito left the game in the second quarter with a neck injury, and CB Nolan Carroll suffered a concussion, also in the second quarter. ... The Dolphins improved to 6-0 on Halloween.
Information from The Associated Press was used in this report.
Experts predict NFL Week 8 upset picks, fantasy football sleepers and flops, plus trade deadline offers
Which players could get traded soon? Is it time to panic for the Patriots? Our insiders answer six big questions.
Patriots ready to provide slumping Cam Newton the support he needs
QBs coach Jedd Fisch and coordinator Josh McDaniels believe practice reps and playing to Newton's strengths will get their starter back on track.
Johnny Hekker's punting master class draws raves, hugs from Rams teammates
Punters usually don't get much praise, but the Rams were more than happy to laud Johnny Hekker after the clinic he put on against the Bears.
Colts' undrafted, productive tight ends share underdog bond
Trey Burton, Mo Alie-Cox and Jack Doyle are each solid complementary pieces for the Colts, giving Philip Rivers more than just safety valve
Washington excited about Antonio Gibson's future at running back
The explosive rookie, who is learning the position on the fly in the NFL, is making big strides as he adjusts to NFL speed and blocking schemes.
49ers' YAC Bros the latest addition to Bay Area's fraternal scene
Falling in line behind the Bash Brothers and Splash Brothers, San Francisco's YAC Bros lead the NFL in both yards after catch and yards after contact.