The big right-hander gave up Jeter's 2,998th hit but little else, B.J. Upton homered and drove in three runs, and the Tampa Bay Rays beat the New York Yankees 5-1 on Thursday night to start strong in a long stretch of games against their biggest division rivals.
Back in September 2009, Niemann allowed Jeter's 2,721st career hit -- which tied Lou Gehrig for the Yankees record. That was on his mind in this game as he held the New York captain to a first-inning double.
"He already tied one record off me," Niemann said. "I knew I already had that one under my belt, so I didn't want him to have any more milestones off me for a while."
Ben Zobrist homered, tripled and singled for Tampa Bay, which tagged Bartolo Colon early in one of the worst outings of his surprising comeback season. Evan Longoria had an RBI single and the Rays won the first of 11 straight games against New York and Boston, the two teams they trail in the AL East.
"I really believe it brings out the best in us. We were really up for that game tonight," Tampa Bay manager Joe Maddon said. "That's like playing the first game of a playoff series."
The Yankees fell out of first place by a half-game when the Red Sox beat Baltimore.
With a chance to hit for the cycle in the ninth, Zobrist walked for the second time in the game. The leadoff man reached safely in all five plate appearances.
Jeter is trying to become the 28th major leaguer -- and first with the Yankees -- to reach 3,000 hits, one of baseball's biggest milestones. He doubled on Niemann's first pitch, then grounded out his next four times up and ended the night two short.
With two runners on, Jeter made the last out of the game on a bouncer to third against ex-Yankee Kyle Farnsworth.
"After the first one, I'd be lying to you if I said I didn't think it was attainable today," Jeter said. "Early on, I thought I'd get a few."
Rookie right-hander Jeremy Hellickson pitches for the Rays on Friday night.
Niemann (4-4) went a season-high 7 1/3 innings, yielding only a homer by Robinson Cano in the sixth. The 6-foot-9, 260-pound righty gave up six hits and walked two, improving to 3-0 in four starts since missing six weeks with a strained lower back.
Before going on the disabled list, he was 1-4 with a 5.74 ERA in six starts.
"Him getting that deep in the game was really big for us. The Yankees have a tendency to wear out bullpens," Maddon said. "That was Jeff Niemann prior to the injury last year. That's what I saw."
Colon (6-4) entered 4-0 with a 1.00 ERA in his past four starts, but he ran into trouble right away in his second outing since coming off the disabled list (strained left hamstring).
The 38-year-old right-hander allowed five runs and a season-high 10 hits in 5 2/3 innings, dropping to 9-3 in 19 starts against Tampa Bay. He also matched a season high with four walks.
"He didn't have his good fastball. He didn't have the command he usually has," Yankees manager Joe Girardi said. "He just wasn't sharp tonight and you're going to run through starts like that."
New York had won five straight home games and 11 of its last 13.
Jeter, who came off the disabled list Monday in Cleveland, played his first game at Yankee Stadium since injuring his calf June 13, when he was six hits short of 3,000.
Needing three to reach the plateau Thursday in the opener of a four-game series that leads into the All-Star break, it appeared a few things were lined up in his favor.
Jeter began the night 5 for 9 (.556) in his career against Niemann, including three hits on the night he tied Gehrig. And the New York captain got off to another rousing start in this one.
With a host of friends and family members in attendance, including his parents, Jeter smacked the first pitch he saw into left-center for a double, bringing a roar from the sellout crowd of 47,787.
Charged-up fans rose to their feet and cameras flashed for each subsequent at-bat, but Jeter couldn't come through again and finished 1 for 5. Rays third baseman Sean Rodriguez made two nice plays to help deny Jeter.
"Everyone knows what's going on. There's no secret," Niemann said. "You really kind of have to bear down because no one wants that to be them."
Niemann is 3-0 in six starts against the Yankees. He threw a season-high 114 pitches on a humid, 79-degree night. ... Rays RHP Wade Davis was placed on the 15-day DL because of a strained forearm. An MRI didn't reveal anything serious. RHP Brandon Gomes was recalled from Triple-A Durham. ... DH Johnny Damon was held out after leaving Wednesday's game with a bruised left hand when he was hit by a pitch from Twins LHP Francisco Liriano. ... Longoria was the DH, giving his sore left foot a bit of a break. ... Yankees closer Mariano Rivera said he was available to pitch, though he is skipping the All-Star game Tuesday because of soreness in his right triceps. Rivera hasn't pitched since Sunday, when he blew a save against the Mets. ... Colon had thrown 12 2/3 scoreless innings over his previous two starts.
Red Sox place Andrew Benintendi on IL due to strained rib cage
Red Sox outfielder Andrew Benintendi, who is hitting just .103 in 52 plate appearances this season, was placed on the 10-day IL on Wednesday after suffering a strained right rib cage on Tuesday.
Closer Keone Kela to return to injury-ravaged Pirates on Thursday
Closer Keone Kela, who surprisingly tested positive for COVID-19 when he arrived at summer camp, will join the injury-ravaged, last-place Pirates on Thursday for a four-game series in Cincinnati.
Baseball Hall of Fame opens 2020 Inductees Exhibit featuring Derek Jeter, Ted Simmons, Larry Walker, and Marvin Miller
The Baseball Hall of Fame's class of 2020 has to wait a year to get inducted because of the coronavirus pandemic, but the careers of Derek Jeter, Ted Simmons, Larry Walker and Marvin Miller are already being celebrated at the shrine.
Rays' Andrew Kittredge on 45-day IL with elbow issue
The Tampa Bay Rays placed Andrew Kittredge on the 45-day injured list Wednesday after he was diagnosed with a sprain of his right ulnar collateral ligament.
Machado's grand slam sends Padres over Dodgers, 6-2
Manny Machado slugged a grand slam after two consecutive errors by the Dodgers in the third inning, Garrett Richards won for the first time in two years, and the San Diego Padres defeated Los Angeles 6-2 on Tuesday night.
How Dylan Bundy changed his fantasy baseball prowess
Changing teams isn't the only reason the former No. 4 overall draft pick has excelled on the mound this season. Here's why he looks like a new pitcher for 2020.