When the Orioles got their third look at the sinkerballer, things changed in a hurry.
Baltimore sent 10 batters to the plate during a five-run sixth inning and beat the Red Sox 5-3 on Wednesday night to move a game ahead of Tampa Bay for the top AL wild-card spot.
The Orioles trailed 2-0 before rallying against Cook, who fueled the uprising with a throwing error on a potential inning-ending, double-play comebacker. The miscue led to three unearned runs and saddled Cook (3-6) with his fourth loss in five starts.
"When you get the ground ball you have to cash in there," said Boston manager Bobby Valentine, who was ejected in the eighth inning. "We're in the dugout if he makes the play."
Cook allowed only a pair of walks through the first five innings and got 13 of 15 outs on grounders. The first out in the sixth also came on a groundball, and then the trouble began.
"He started to get it up," Baltimore's Adam Jones said. "You start to see somebody three times, you get him."
Nick Markakis walked and J.J. Hardy lined a single to left. Nate McLouth hit an RBI single, and with runners on the corners, Jones hit a bouncer to Cook, who threw wildly to second as Hardy scored the tying run.
"It's a play I've made a 100 times," Cook said. "I just didn't get my feet set. We lost because I made an error."
Matt Wieters put the Orioles in front and chased Cook with an opposite-field, ground-rule double to left. Andrew Miller got Chris Davis to hit a grounder to drawn-in second baseman Dustin Pedroia, who threw home. Jones lowered his left shoulder and ran hard into catcher Jarrod Saltalamacchia, who applied the tag for the second out.
"It was fun. It was awesome," Jones said of the collision. "It was much needed."
"I feel like we just don't give up," Hardy said. "We know that at any point we can go out there and score runs."
Baltimore is alone in second place in the AL East and making a run at the postseason, but manager Buck Showalter says it's too early to get excited.
"There's so much baseball to be played and so many (teams) involved in this that I think it's counterproductive to dwell on it because things can change so quickly in a week's time," he said.
Rookie Miguel Gonzalez (5-2) allowed two runs and six hits in six innings for the Orioles, and Jim Johnson worked the ninth for his 35th save in 38 tries. The game ended with rookie third baseman Manny Machado making a diving stab of Nick Punto's liner down the line.
Carl Crawford had two RBIs for the Red Sox, who have lost six of eight to fall four games under .500 (57-61) for the first time since May 13.
Cleanup hitter Adrian Gonzalez and Valentine were both ejected in the eighth inning for arguing with home plate umpire Mike Everitt.
Both contended that Orioles reliever Pedro Strop threw a quick pitch to Gonzalez, who bounced out to second.
"I wasn't even set," Gonzalez said. "I was just sitting there waiting for him to come set so I can get into my stance. We're trying to win a game. I'm the leadoff hitter, down two runs, trying to get on base."
Crawford got Boston to 5-3 in the seventh with a run-scoring groundout, but Boston went down in order in the eighth and ninth.
The Red Sox are 3-8 against Baltimore this season and have lost five of the past six series between the teams dating to last season.
Limited to two singles and a walk through four innings, Boston grabbed a 2-0 lead in the fifth. After Scott Podsednik and Punto singled, Jacoby Ellsbury doubled in a run and Crawford followed with a sacrifice fly.
Omar Quintanilla made the first and last outs in the Baltimore sixth. ... Boston DH David Ortiz was told to stop running for a few days as he attempts to return from a right Achilles strain. He's been on the DL since July 18. ... Orioles INF Wilson Betemit will have an MRI performed on his sore right wrist "to see if there's anything more than tendinitis," Showalter said. ... Boston RHP Clay Buchholz pitches in the series finale against Baltimore's Chris Tillman. All three of Buchholz's career shutouts have come against Baltimore. ... Orioles DH Jim Thome, who's on the DL with a herniated disk, served as an assistant scout Tuesday night while pitching prospect Dylan Bundy threw for Double-A Bowie. ... Ellsbury has a 38-game hitting streak against Baltimore dating back to April 17, 2009.
Sources: MLB Players Association to make counteroffer to league in Monday meeting
The MLB Players Association is expected to make a counteroffer to the league on Monday, 11 days after clubs gave the union a proposal, sources told ESPN.
Robot umpires at home plate moving up to Triple-A for 2022, one step away from major league baseball
Major League Baseball is expanding its automated strike zone experiment to Triple-A, where it will deploy robot umpires at home plate for the 2022 season.
David Ortiz's Hall of Fame case
Outside the Lines looks at David Ortiz's Hall of Fame candidacy and what may be holding him back from induction.
Tampa Bay Rays say split-season plan with Montreal rejected by MLB
The Tampa Bay Rays' proposed plan to split the season between Florida and Montreal has been rejected by Major League Baseball.
One fun fact you (probably) did not know for all 30 MLB teams
From telling team numbers to surprising player stats, we find what you might have missed about your favorite squad.
Deaths of woman, 2-year-old son in fall at San Diego Padres' Petco Park ruled suicide, homicide
San Diego police said Wednesday that a woman who fell to her death at Petco Park while holding her 2-year-old son died by suicide and that the boy's death was classified as a homicide.