That easy interception with 23 seconds left decided the game the way every other Buffalo game at Gillette Stadium has ended -- with a New England victory.
On a day of dreadful defense by both teams, the Patriots held on for a 37-31 win against the surprisingly tough Bills on Sunday despite allowing 35 first downs, Buffalo's most ever and the most ever allowed by New England.
"No matter what happens in the game, there's nothing bigger than turnovers," McCourty said. "When the game gets toward the end, those big plays change the game."
Avoiding the penalties, 14 of them, that had stymied them all game, the Bills moved to the Patriots 15-yard line before Fitzpatrick threw the ball right into the hands of McCourty while trying to hit T.J. Graham. Tom Brady then knelt down for the final play.
"The only thing you can ask for as a quarterback is a chance at the end to win the game and we had that," Fitzpatrick said, "but we weren't able to get it done."
New England is 11-0 against the Bills at Gillette since it opened in 2002 and 23-2 overall in its last 25 games against Buffalo.
The Patriots were coming off a bye that followed their best game of the season, a 45-7 win over the St. Louis Rams in London. The Bills have lost five of six and need a sharp turnaround to avoid their 13th straight nonplayoff season.
"Still a chance," coach Chan Gailey said. "I think we'll get there. I know I'm in the minority, but thank goodness I've got a group of guys in that room in there that, I think, think the same thing."
Fitzpatrick completed 27-of-40 passes for 337 yards, the second time this season he's thrown for at least 300. The other came when he had 350 in a 52-28 loss to the Patriots. He also threw two touchdowns Sunday, but his only interception ruined the Bills' upset chances.
Brady was 23 for 38 for 237.
His last incompletion, a ball thrown into the ground about 5 yards in front of the intended receiver, set the stage for Buffalo's final drive. Brady watched McCourty's interception from the sideline.
"I had an opportunity to do something about it 50 seconds before that," he said. "The defense really saved the day."
The game was closer than expected considering the Patriots led the NFL in points and yards gained and the Bills were next to last in points and yards allowed.
The Patriots extended their streak to 11 straight scoring possessions against the Bills with a field goal and three touchdowns on their first four series Sunday. In the previous meeting, New England scored on its last seven series: six touchdowns followed by a field goal.
But not even that could give the Patriots a secure lead, and they entered the fourth quarter ahead 31-24.
"They didn't really hit us with a lot of big plays," Patriots coach Bill Belichick said. "They've got an explosive group of skilled players and they got them all involved."
The Patriots led 24-17 at halftime, scoring on a 43-yard field goal by Gostkowski, touchdown runs of 1 yard by Stevan Ridley and 15 yards by Danny Woodhead, and a 2-yard pass from Brady to Rob Gronkowski, his fifth touchdown catch in three games.
Woodhead scored again, his first multi-touchdown game of his career, on an 18-yard pass from Brady. But the Bills cut the lead to 31-24 on the next possession on a 1-yard run by Jackson and Lindell's extra point.
Gostkowski's 48-yard field goal gave the Patriots a 34-24 lead 50 seconds into the fourth quarter.
On their final drive, the Bills were forced to take an injury timeout when Jackson was hit in the head area by linebacker Brandon Spikes. Earlier, Spikes was called for roughing the passer when Fitzpatrick's helmet fell off, and Fitzpatrick yelled at him.
"We're not going to back down from anybody," Fitzpatrick said. "I think he's a punk at times and took a cheap shot at Scott (Chandler) in the first game and he was doing a lot of jabbering and talking and hitting out there. Not one of my favorite players. Not high on my list."
Playing in Foxborough can't be very high, either, although the Bills were one errant pass away from a chance to win.
"The first thing that I learned when I got to the NFL is it's hard to win each week," McCourty said. "We never take that for granted."
Not even a win over a struggling team that had lost every game it played at Gillette.
"We go into every game expecting to win, but that one, I just felt like it would have been right," Buffalo wide receiver Stevie Johnson said, "but this ain't no Disney movie. This is real life and we've got to make these plays at the end of the game and win."
Running back Kevin Faulk, who recently announced his retirement after not playing this season, was honored by the Patriots at a halftime ceremony. ... Wes Welker had six receptions, extending his streak to 103 games with at least one. ... Fitzpatrick became the fifth quarterback in Bills history with at least 10,000 yards passing.
NFL trade deadline tracker: Latest rumors and deals for 2020
Here's every NFL trade since training camp, along with rumblings from across the league before the Nov. 3 deadline.
Atlanta Falcons sitting DE Takk McKinley Thursday
The Falcons are holding out defensive end Takk McKinley on Thursday night.
Houston Texans close facility after positive COVID-19 test while on bye week
The Texans have closed their facility after a player tested positive for COVID-19, the team announced Wednesday. The Texans are on their bye week after playing the Packers on Sunday.
NFL Week 8 market watch: Unbeaten Steelers are overrated
Preston Johnson offers his take on the NFL power rankings, and analyzes three Week 8 games that bettors have been jumping on.
Negated Chicago Bears sack leads to daily fantasy player losing out on $1 million prize
A stat change that took away a Bears sack during Monday's game against the Rams was costly for one daily fantasy player, who missed out on a $1 million top prize over the correction.
Cincinnati Bengals trade Carlos Dunlap to Seattle Seahawks, source says
Defensive end Carlos Dunlap has been traded to the Seahawks, a source told ESPN, after the disgruntled pass-rusher was told by the Bengals to stay home as the team sorted out his future.