TORONTO -- David Price got the Blue Jays off to a winning start in Toronto's most important series of the season.
Price improved to 8-1 in 10 starts with Toronto since being acquired in a July 30 trade with Detroit.
"Unbelievable," Blue Jays manager John Gibbons said. "Trades don't always work out right. This one has worked out right."
Toronto stretched its lead in the AL East to 3 1-2 games in the opener of a three-game showdown between the division's top teams.
With 13 games remaining, Yankees manager Joe Girardi didn't downplay the importance of the final two games of the series.
"I think they're as important as any games we've played all year when you talk about trying to win the division," Girardi said.
The Blue Jays snapped a two-game losing streak, avoiding their first three-game skid since July 8-10.
Facing the Yankees for the fourth time since joining the Blue Jays, Price improved to 3-0 with a 1.71 ERA against New York with Toronto.
"That's a very good team, one of the most storied franchises," Price said. "They're tough to pitch against, so it's always fun to beat them."
Price (17-5) got a scare when Jacoby Ellsbury led off the game with a liner right back at the head of the star left-hander. Price managed to snare the liner, and smiled in relief as he flipped the ball to third baseman Josh Donaldson.
"It kind of caught me," Price said.
Toronto jumped on Adam Warren (6-7) with a three-run first. Ben Revere singled, Donaldson was hit by a pitch and Bautista grounded an RBI single to center before the runners advanced on a wild pitch. Donaldson scored on Edwin Encarnacion's RBI groundout and Justin Smoak capped the rally with an RBI double.
Warren said he was "too amped up" in the opening inning.
"I was trying to make the best pitch in the world instead of trusting my stuff," he said.
New York used an error, a single and a walk to load the bases with one out in the third. Alex Rodriguez struck out on a 3-2 pitch after narrowly missing a two-run double on a ball that landed just foul in right, and Price ended the inning by getting Brian McCann to fly out.
"(Price) made his pitches when he had to," McCann said. "He was good tonight. He was working both sides of the plate, cutting it and sinking it to both sides and keeping guys off balance."
Those were the first two in a stretch of 14 consecutive outs by Price, who finished his outing by fanning Chase Headley and Bird, then applauded the sellout crowd of 47,648 as he walked off the field.
Aaron Sanchez walked Didi Gregorius to begin the eighth, then left after Dustin Ackley's single advanced Gregorius to third. Brett Cecil came on and gave up an RBI single to Ellsbury, but escaped the jam by striking out Brett Gardner, Rodriguez and McCann. Cecil called them the three biggest outs of his career.
"You can't give him enough credit," Gibbons said of Cecil. "He's one of the better relievers in baseball."
Limited to 85 pitches, Warren left after striking out Kevin Pillar to begin the fourth. He allowed three runs and five hits, walked one and struck out five.
The Blue Jays won for the first time since Aug. 16 when scoring fewer than five runs.
Yankees: RHP Nathan Eovaldi still has inflammation in his right elbow and won't be able to resume throwing until next week, Girardi said. The delay means Eovaldi's hopes of being part of a potential playoff rotation are in doubt, but he could pitch out of the bullpen about a week after he resumes throwing. ... RHP Masahiro Tanaka (right hamstring) worked out and played catch at Yankee Stadium and remains on track to rejoin the rotation next week, Girardi said.
Yankees: RHP Luis Severino (4-3, 3.12 ERA) will be facing the Blue Jays for the third time in seven starts. He's 0-2 with a 9.72 ERA in his previous two meetings with Toronto.
Blue Jays: RHP Marco Estrada (13-8, 3.14 ERA) pitched eight shutout innings to beat Atlanta in his most recent outing. He's 1-2 with a 4.09 ERA in four starts against the Yankees this season.
Carter Stewart ditched the MLB draft to pitch in Japan; then came the coronavirus
The 20-year-old's gamble shook baseball last year. Now he's faced with an unexpected twist -- he gets to pitch, but doesn't know when he'll get to see his family again.
MLB players on how they've had to adapt, from no fans in the stands to no couches in the clubhouse
Watching from the stands instead of the dugout, staying in the hotel on road trips and missing the roar of the crowd -- nothing is routine in 2020.
Jays' Pearson ready to face Braves in second start
The visiting Toronto Blue Jays will send their top pitching prospect to the mound on Thursday in the rubber game of the best-of-three series against the Atlanta Braves.
Surprising Marlins chase sweep of Orioles
Baltimore Orioles left-hander Wade LeBlanc, who turns 36 on Friday, will be hoping for an early birthday present when he faces the red-hot Miami Marlins in the finale of a four-game series on Thursday.
Phillies seek bullpen answers while ending series vs. Yanks
The Philadelphia Phillies continue to receive strong performances from their starting pitchers.
Angels expect Ohtani back as DH for finale vs. M's
Shohei Ohtani is expected to be back in the Los Angeles Angels' lineup when they wrap up a three-game series Thursday afternoon in Seattle.