The Dallas Cowboys did, too.
Stafford's 1-yard lunge over a pile of linemen with 12 seconds left and Johnson's 329 yards receiving lifted the Detroit Lions to a 31-30 win over Dallas on Sunday.
"I was yelling that I was going to spike the ball," Stafford recalled. "But their linebackers were just standing there."
The Cowboys weren't just standing around letting Johnson make catch after catch, but he made them look helpless.
Johnson almost broke an NFL record, and could celebrate the feat because of a comeback from a 10-point, fourth-quarter deficit that some people who entered Ford Field didn't see because they had left.
"Even our fans didn't think we could pull this one out," he said. "They were leaving, but we knew we could do it."
Johnson's total trails only the 336 yards receiving Flipper Anderson had for the Los Angeles Rams against New Orleans on Nov. 26, 1989, in a game that went into overtime.
The Cowboys dared Detroit to throw to Johnson with a lot of one-on-one coverage. They usually asked cornerback Brandon Carr to do the improbable by defending him by himself, and sometimes attempted to slow him down with a zone.
"He had his way," Carr said. "And, we couldn't find a way to keep him from rolling."
"It was crazy," he said. "We had a lot of one-on-one coverage today, and we were able to take advantage and hit some deep balls. Matt made some great throws to me."
Tweeted Lions teammate Reggie Bush after the game:
Calvin Johnson is the greatest receiver in the history of the NFL! #dropsthemic
— Reggie Bush (@ReggieBush) October 27, 2013
The Lions (5-3) overcame four turnovers without forcing a turnover, becoming the first team to do that and win since New England did against Miami in 2007, according to STATS.
On their last drive, Stafford threw a 22-yard pass to Johnson to set up the winning score. The quarterback caught at least some Cowboys by surprise, including linebacker Sean Lee, who appeared to expect him to spike the ball to stop the clock.
"He kind of caught us off-guard," defensive tackle Jason Hatcher acknowledged.
Dallas (4-4) seemed to set itself up to win three straight for the first time this year to build a bigger lead atop the NFC East when Tony Romo threw his second touchdown -- and third of the game -- to Dez Bryant with 6:45 left to take 27-17 lead.
The Cowboys, though, allowed Bush to cap an 80-yard drive with a 1-yard TD with 3:33 left. They also had to settle for Dan Bailey's third field goal with 1:02 left after Tyron Smith was flagged for holding on third down, a mistake that stopped the clock even though Detroit declined the penalty.
"If we don't get called for a penalty, I think they probably had 20 seconds or so left," Romo said.
With no timeouts, the Lions went from their 20 to the Cowboys end zone thanks in large part to a 17-yard pass to Johnson, a 40-yard connection with Kris Durham and Johnson's 14th reception that gave them the ball at the Dallas 1.
Instead of spiking the ball, Stafford took the snap and leaped with his arms extended to beat the team he rooted for growing up in Highland Park, Texas.
"I was just as fooled as the defense was," Lions offensive guard Larry Warford said.
Stafford was 33 of 48 for 488 yards -- his second-highest total -- with a 2-yard TD pass to Johnson in the first quarter and two interceptions. Bush had 92 yards rushing and a score.
Romo was 14 of 30, failing to complete half his passes for the first time since 2009, for 206 yards without a turnover.
Late in the first half, Romo threw two straight passes to Bryant -- after not making him the intended receiver once -- and he caught the second one with his left hand, pinning it against his shoulder pad for a go-ahead, 5-yard TD with 46 seconds left in the first half.
Despite leading by six in the third quarter, Bryant didn't look happy. He flapped his arms and screamed at Romo on the sideline. After the loss, Bryant insisted his demonstrative actions were a result of his positive passion.
"People who have a problem with me are the people that don't understand what is going on," he said.
Lions DE Ezekiel "Ziggy" Ansah (left ankle), WR Ryan Broyles (Achilles tendon) and CB Bill Bentley (knee) and Cowboys RG Brian Waters (triceps) were hurt during the game. ... The Lions have a bye next week while Dallas plays on the road against the New York Giants.
Information from The Associated Press was used in this report.
NFL training camp updates: QBs take to podiums, including Justin Herbert, Aaron Rodgers, Jalen Hurts and more
From chatting with fans at Chargers camp to discussing the Packers' future, QBs had a day on Wednesday. Check out the notable quotes and COVID-19 notes from the NFL.
Volatile Packers' odds settle with Rodgers back
After odds drifted back and forth due to the uncertainty of Aaron Rodgers' future in Green Bay, the Packers have settled in among the favorites.
Aaron Rodgers transcript: Everything he said about return to Packers
From pondering retirement to his future beyond this season, Rodgers had a lot to say after his first practice. Here is the complete transcript.
Dak Prescott leaves Dallas Cowboys' practice early with arm soreness, 'did not want to push it'
Dallas Cowboys quarterback Dak Prescott left practice early Wednesday, after feeling some soreness in his right throwing arm, and the veteran simply "did not want to push it," the team said.
Newton makes a Pats fan's day with a gift
Cam Newton tosses a football to a fan in the crowd and lets him keep it.
Texans coach says Watson has not been a distraction
Texans coach David Culley says Deshaun Watson has not been a distraction despite the QB's trade request and Watson facing 22 active lawsuits.