Even so, they'll take this.
"I want what they have -- a championship," Noah said. "One day, we're going to have to get through those guys."
The Heat have owned them when it counts in recent seasons.
With a healthy Derrick Rose and the No. 1 seed in 2011, Chicago fell to Miami in the Eastern Conference finals. Last year, with Rose out, the Heat knocked off the Bulls in the second round on the way to their second straight championship.
"It's still a good win," Butler said. "It gives us confidence we can beat them. But ... in the playoffs, like Thibs said, we can't go around them; you're going to have to go through them."
Dwyane Wade scored 25 for Miami, but with James struggling again, the Heat dropped their third straight to match their longest losing streak of the season.
James scored 17 points on 8-of-23 shooting and couldn't come through after Miami blew a 12-point lead down the stretch. With a chance to win it at the end of regulation, he got stripped by Butler on a layup attempt.
In overtime, it was all Bulls.
Chicago outscored Miami 9-2, starting with Augustin's 3 just under a minute in. Butler added a jumper from the wing, Noah scored on a putback and Butler hit two free throws to make it 95-86 with 1:33 left before James made a layup.
Noah also had seven assists and five blocks with his dad -- tennis great Yannick Noah -- looking on.
Butler added 16 points and 11 rebounds while containing James.
Wade tried to carry the load for Miami, particularly in the early going. Chris Bosh scored 15, but James had another rough afternoon. The four-time MVP is 23 for 59 in the three games since his career-high and franchise-record 61-point effort against Charlotte last week.
James also went without a mask from the start to protect his broken nose, after ditching it during the previous game. He said it was simply uncomfortable, so he decided to play without it even though he was not cleared to do so.
The Bulls got back into it after the Heat led by 12 late in the third quarter.
Augustin's 3-pointer and Butler's steal and two free throws put Chicago ahead 75-74 midway through the fourth.
It was 82-82 with just over two minutes left when Noah blocked a layup by James. Taj Gibson raced the other way for a thunderous dunk while getting fouled by Mario Chalmers, drawing a roar from the crowd.
James tied it again on a layup with 1:10 left. Wade then stole the ball from Butler and hit two free throws after getting fouled inside by Noah to give Miami an 86-84 lead with 29.2 seconds remaining. But Kirk Hinrich quickly scooped in a runner to knot it at 86 with 20.1 seconds left.
After a timeout, James took the inbounds pass and got stripped driving for a layup along the right side by Butler to send this one to overtime.
"I dropped the ball. It's like a double entendre," James said. "I actually dropped the ball, but I dropped the ball on my team. I had it. That's a great play. I give a lot of credit to Jimmy. He got his hand on the ball, but I had the lane. I had the layup."
Things got a bit heated between James and Butler late in the first half. They got tangled going for a loose ball near the Heat basket after James tried to corral a long pass. As they hit the court, Butler's foot hit James' nose, and James appeared to push him. Both players got technicals. "Two competitors were down there," Butler said. "Whatever happened, happened. But I don't back down." James brushed it off, saying, "Just two competitors going at it, one trying not to give an edge." ... The Bulls and Heat split the season series at 2-2.
Trae Young: Hawks building chemistry as the season goes on
Trae Young talks the Hawks' win over the Pelicans, as well as the chemistry the team is building in the young season.
John Collins soars for epic putback jam in crunch time
Trae Young's 3-pointer is off the mark, but John Collins cleans up with a slam that puts the Hawks ahead in the final minute.
Hunter locks up Ingram on Pelicans' final possession
Brandon Ingram looks to give the Pelicans the lead, but De'Andre Hunter plays great defense and forces the air ball.