Neither quarterback earned a win, however.
Burrow tossed a pair of touchdown passes to Tee Higgins in regulation and Wentz dove into the end zone for the tying score in the final minute as the Cincinnati Bengals and Philadelphia Eagles played to a 23-23 tie on Sunday.
Both teams are 0-2-1.
"This is a loss to me. We didn't win, that's all it is to me," Burrow said. "If you don't win, you lose. That's the mind-set to me."
Facing an 0-3 start for the first time since 1999, Wentz drove the Eagles 75 yards in the final three minutes. He barreled 9 yards on third-and-6 to the Bengals 19 and then ran in from 7 with a head-first dive into the end zone. Elliott's extra point tied it with 21 seconds left.
Neither team could do anything in overtime.
"Tying is no fun. It's an awkward way to end a game," Wentz said.
Burrow, the Heisman Trophy winner and No. 1 overall pick, calmly picked apart the secondary in the second half, completing 31 of 44 for 312 yards. He's still seeking his first win since leading LSU to the national championship in January.
"I've never tied in my life, so it feels strange for sure," Bengals coach Zac Taylor said. 'I know it sure as hell doesn't feel like we won, that's what I can tell you for sure."
Wentz struggled again, tossing two more interceptions, before rallying the Eagles late. He finished 29 of 47 for 225 yards, one TD and ran for 65 yards and one score.
The Bengals took a 17-16 lead on their first drive of the third quarter. Burrow completed all seven of his passes for 78 yards, including a pair of third-down conversions. He finished it off with a 4-yard TD pass to Higgins for a 17-16 lead.
Wentz was picked by LeShaun Sims on the ensuing possession and the Bengals took over at the Eagles 44. They turned that into a 31-yard field goal by Randy Bullock and a 20-16 lead. Bullock hit a 25-yarder to extend the lead to 23-16 with 3:05 left.
Burrow tossed a 1-yard TD pass to Higgins for a 10-6 lead late in the second quarter. But Wentz and the Eagles answered quickly. On third-and-5 from the 26, Wentz hit a wide-open Greg Ward down the right side for a TD and a 13-10 lead.
Jalen Hurts took a snap out of shotgun with Wentz lined up wide at receiver and ran 8 yards for a first down on the opening drive of the third quarter that ended with Elliott kicking a 54-yarder to make it 16-10.
Philadelphia's opening series ended when Wentz's pass on third down was deflected at the line and picked by Logan Wilson at the Bengals 44.
Wentz has thrown multiple picks in three consecutive games. He hadn't done that in two straight games before this season. Wentz hasn't thrown more than seven interceptions since his rookie year but already has six in three games.
"I gotta be better. I know that," Wentz said.
"We just can't have a free run, a (defensive lineman) come clean every single time. That's something we've got to fix right away," Taylor said.
The Eagles have not forced any turnovers on defense through 13 quarters this season. They recovered a fumble on a punt return last week.
"We have to do better with that," Graham said.
Bengals receiver John Ross, the ninth pick in the 2017 draft, was a healthy inactive. Ross had two catches in the first two games and is scheduled to be a free agent after the season.
More AP NFL: https://apnews.com/NFL and https://twitter.com/AP-NFL
John Ross of Cincinnati Bengals eager to play, wants out if he can't
John Ross, the Bengals' former first-round pick whose role has diminished this season, publicized his trade demands Friday, saying he'd prefer a deal if he's not going to play.
Philadelphia Eagles rule out running back Miles Sanders vs. Dallas Cowboys
Eagles running back Miles Sanders has been ruled out of Sunday night's game against the Cowboys due to a knee injury that will sideline him for a second straight week.
New Orleans Saints rule out Michael Thomas, Marquez Callaway
The Saints will be without Michael Thomas and Marquez Callaway for Sunday's game against the Bears.
Source: Minnesota Vikings linebacker Todd Davis tests positive for COVID-19
Minnesota Vikings linebacker Todd Davis was placed on the reserve/COVID-19 list on Friday after testing positive for the coronavirus, a league source told ESPN's Courtney Cronin.
Cleveland Browns' Odell Beckham Jr. says ACL tear 'really tough,' promises to be back soon
Browns receiver Odell Beckham Jr., talking about his ACL tear, says "this one doesn't make much sense."
Source: Seattle Seahawks bring in free-agent running back Alex Collins to begin COVID-19 testing
The Seahawks have brought in free-agent running back Alex Collins to begin COVID-19 testing and could add him to their practice squad as early as next week, a source told ESPN.