Lagares robbed Andrew McCutchen of a go-ahead hit with a leaping catch at the wall in the top of the ninth inning, then Baxter's pinch-hit single in the bottom half sent the New York Mets over the Pittsburgh Pirates 3-2 on Thursday night.
"At home plate, I didn't do very well with the bat," Lagares said. "I tried to forget it and play defense."
Baxter delivered his second winning pinch-hit in three days. His 10th-inning single Tuesday beat the Chicago White Sox.
This time, Baxter batted for Lagares and won it.
"Very enjoyable. Good feeling," Baxter said.
Lagares was equally responsible for the victory. Before the game, Mets manager Terry Collins said the rookie center fielder might win a game with his defense -- he was right, maybe sooner than he expected.
Called up from Triple-A on April 23 because of his bat and glove, Lagares preserved the ninth-inning tie with his gem.
With a runner on first and two outs, McCutchen hit a loud shot into faraway right-center field. Lagares glided back, perfectly timed his leap and plucked the ball at the top of the fence as he rammed into the padded wall. It was a fantastic play, yet he seemed so under control he made it look almost routine.
"I got a good jump," he said. "I saw it all the way into the glove."
Asked if he thought the ball would've cleared the wall, Lagares said it was close. Either way, it would've at least been a tiebreaking extra-base hit.
"That was huge," Baxter said. "Lagares saves the game."
McCutchen wasn't so surprised.
"I thought he was going to catch it at the wall. I didn't think I got enough of it to get it out," he said.
It's been quite a week for Baxter, who grew up in the shadow of Shea Stadium -- just a few minutes from where Citi Field now stands.
Baxter is now 5 for 9 as a pinch-hitter this season. Not bad for someone who, before this week, might've been known solely for making a sensational catch to preserve Johan Santana's no-hitter last year.
Bobby Parnell (4-0) pitched the ninth. The Pirates have lost four of five.
Pedro Alvarez hit a solo home run with one out in the eighth off Mets reliever LaTroy Hawkins that made it 2-all. Alvarez began the day batting .168 and in a 1-for-16 rut before a single, sacrifice fly and long drive for his sixth homer.
Slumping Ike Davis put the Mets ahead 2-1 in the seventh after entering in the top half during a double switch. He took a terrible swing at a first-pitch slider, then hit the next pitch for an RBI double just beyond the reach of a sliding McCutchen deep in the right-center field alley.
Pittsburgh starter Jeff Locke left for a pinch-hitter in the seventh. He gave up three hits, all of them singles in the second inning.
Reliever Brandon Lyon avoided major trouble, yielding only a sacrifice fly by Alvarez that made it 1-all.
The Mets scored in the second on singles by John Buck and Justin Turner and a sacrifice fly by Byrd. The run ended a streak of 15 scoreless innings on the road for Locke, a span that included outings at Dodger Stadium, Philadelphia and St. Louis.
Baxter and Alvarez both played high school ball in New York City and went to Vanderbilt. ... Buck and Brown ended 0-for-14 slumps. Brown's drought began last year with Colorado. Brown scored on Davis' double. ... Martin had missed the previous two games because of a stiff neck. ... Pirates 2B Neil Walker (right hand cut) is starting a rehab assignment with Double-A Altoona. He can come off the disabled list Sunday. ... Pirates RHP Charlie Morton will throw a bullpen session Friday. He's recovering from Tommy John surgery last June, and had shoulder stiffness last week in a Triple-A rehab outing.
Late Indians outfielder/commentator Jack Graney wins Frick Award
Cleveland Indians outfielder and commentator Jack Graney has won the Hall of Fame's Ford C. Frick Award for excellence in broadcasting.
What's next for the NL West? Lockout leaves MLB's wildest division with huge question marks
The Giants lost a franchise icon. The Dodgers are missing some familiar faces. The Padres imploded and hired a new manager. And what about the futures of the Rockies and D-backs?
Tim Kurkjian is a Hall of Famer! Here's what makes him so great
As Cooperstown calls for our colleague, we share a few favorite memories of working alongside him.
ESPN's Tim Kurkjian is 2022 winner of BBWAA Career Excellence Award
Tim Kurkjian has been awarded the BBWAA's highest honor, winning the 2022 Career Excellence Award.
Time for an NBA-style signing deadline? Why MLB's free-agent frenzy should be an annual event
Last week's lockout pushed teams and players to make huge deals -- and it was FUN. Maybe baseball could learn something from all this.
Kenneth Moffett, federal mediator of 1981 baseball strike and former MLBPA executive, dies at 90
Kenneth Moffett, the federal mediator during the 1981 baseball strike who briefly succeeded Marvin Miller as the second head of the players' association, died last month at the age of 90 in Virginia.