"I've had a quite a few opportunities tonight to put the ball in play," Norris said. "It was just good I could come up and finally get the game over with."
Norris notched his second career game-ending RBI while facing Balfour (1-4) in Oakland's eighth walkoff win.
The AL West-leading A's remained one game ahead of the Los Angeles Angels and avoided losing consecutive home games for just the second time this season.
The A's loaded the bases against Balfour, who received a mound visit before Brandon Moss stepped in with a chance at a fourth grand slam but struck out. Norris delivered with his first game-ending RBI since June 24, 2012, against the Giants.
"I just got beat by a good team tonight, plain and simple," Balfour said. "It's tough when you have to get five outs."
Rays manager Joe Maddon was ejected by first base umpire Quinn Wolcott on an "egregious" non-strike call during on Josh Donaldson's 10th-inning walk and rushed the field to argue once more.
Ryan Cook (1-1) earned the win on a night the A's stranded a season-high 18 runners.
The A's won their 11th extra-inning game, second-most in the majors behind Baltimore.
Tampa Bay had its eight-game road winning streak snapped, which matched the longest in club history, to kick off a 10-game trip. The Rays lost away from Tropicana Field for the first time since July 3 at Detroit and dropped to 23-10 overall since June 25.
In the ninth, reliever Sean Doolittle fielded Brandon Guyer's bouncing safety squeeze bunt and tossed about 10 feet to catcher Norris to tag out James Loney and save the go-ahead run. Doolittle then struck out Kevin Kiermaier.
Until Norris came through, Oakland had missed key chances with runners in scoring position. The A's loaded the bases with two outs in the seventh against Joel Peralta.
Coming off consecutive series losses for only the second time this season, the A's avoided losing back-to-back at home for the first time since May 5-6 against Seattle.
Josh Donaldson singled in the tying run in the sixth.
"It seems to be my M.O. since I've been here, I go out and throw some innings and then watch these guys put on a show at the end of the game," he said.
With six ex-Rays on Oakland's roster, Maddon has taken to calling them the "Ra-A's."
An opossum wandered into left field to watch during extra innings, right before John Jaso stepped in. He's no stranger to little creatures, having batted with a squirrel in the infield and a pigeon near the plate this year, too.
Samardzija says it's about time to make it the mascot.
"He's been out here before," the pitcher said. "We're going to have to give him a name, get him a jersey. We've got to keep feeding him."
Rays: Outfielder Wil Myers, on the 60-day disabled list recovering from a broken right wrist, went through an extensive workout and drills in Port Charlotte, Florida. He will likely do a similar session Tuesday and Maddon said the Rays could decide by the end of the week when to begin his rehab assignment.
Athletics: Center fielder Coco Crisp took batting practice and came off the bench as a pinch-hitter in the seventh after missing seven games with a strained neck. He will be back in the starting lineup Tuesday. ... Right-hander Jarrod Parker played catch out to 45 feet for his first throwing session since Tommy John surgery in the spring.
Rays: Drew Smyly (6-9, 3.93 ERA) makes his Tampa Bay debut after being traded from Detroit for David Price last Thursday. "I don't look at it as I'm replacing David," he said. "You're not going to replace David Price."
Athletics: Right-hander Jason Hammel (0-4) tries again for his first victory in five starts since being traded from the Chicago Cubs on July 4. He is one of three pitchers in Oakland history to lose each of their first four starts. AL Pitcher of the Month Sonny Gray goes in Wednesday's finale.
What's next for Rays after Montreal split-season plan is nixed?
Alden Gonzalez reports on the Rays having their proposal to split their home games between Tampa Bay and Montreal rejected by Major League Baseball.
Sources: MLB Players Association to make counteroffer to league in Monday meeting
The MLB Players Association is expected to make a counteroffer to the league on Monday, 11 days after clubs gave the union a proposal, sources told ESPN.
Robot umpires at home plate moving up to Triple-A for 2022, one step away from major league baseball
Major League Baseball is expanding its automated strike zone experiment to Triple-A, where it will deploy robot umpires at home plate for the 2022 season.
David Ortiz's Hall of Fame case
Outside the Lines looks at David Ortiz's Hall of Fame candidacy and what may be holding him back from induction.
Tampa Bay Rays say split-season plan with Montreal rejected by MLB
The Tampa Bay Rays' proposed plan to split the season between Florida and Montreal has been rejected by Major League Baseball.
One fun fact you (probably) did not know for all 30 MLB teams
From telling team numbers to surprising player stats, we find what you might have missed about your favorite squad.