Wysh List: Ovechkin, the Sharks and the NHL's other biggest disappointments of 2026-27

play
Alex Ovechkin nets his first goal of the season for Capitals (0:40)

This NHL season has been filled with memorable moments and outstanding achievements. The offensive wizardry of Connor McDavid and Cutter Gauthier. The dominance of teams such as the Edmonton Oilers and Minnesota Wild. Matthew Schaefer, boundless joy in human form, finding new levels as superstar defenseman.

Balancing all of that out: a series of crushing disappointments and embarrassments for players and teams, 10 of which we'll now chronicle in this week's edition of the Wysh List. Enjoy!

Alex Ovechkin's Farewell Tour

I've been thinking a lot about Jaromir Jagr lately when it comes to Alex Ovechkin, and not just because Jagr announced his bodily retirement -- if not a formal retirement -- from hockey during Ovechkin's last NHL season.

The two share some unique history. Were it not for Jagr's dreadful tenure in Washington, the Capitals might not have gone into a gut renovation that helped them win the 2004 draft lottery and select Ovechkin, who would then spend the next 22 years leading the franchise to unprecedented success on and off the ice.

During that time, Ovechkin would break Wayne Gretzky's career goals record (894). One of hockey's greatest "what ifs" is whether Jagr (766 career goals) would have broken it first were it not for the 2004-05 lockout and his three-season side quest in the KHL from 2008 to 2011.

But Jagr ended his NHL career with a whimper, a forgettable coda to an unforgettable 24 seasons. The then-45-year-old scored one goal in 22 games with the Calgary Flames before they mercifully allowed him to leave for HC Kladno of the Czech 1 league, the team Jagr owned overseas.

Ovechkin, sadly, is ending with a similar whimper. At least so far.

I don't think Alex Ovechkin will duck out of his final season with the Capitals for Dynamo Moscow, but I do think there's a parallel here with Jagr's final NHL campaign in how suddenly two ageless wonders were humbled by Father Time.

After Tuesday's loss at the Tampa Bay Lightning, Ovechkin has one goal in 19 games. It's the first time Ovechkin has scored fewer than five goals in his first 19 games of a season. His 14 straight games without a goal also tied his longest career drought. His average ice time (13:39) would be the lowest of his career by nearly four minutes per game. His 1.7 shots per game would also be a career worst.

The sense I get around the Capitals is that they don't view Ovechkin as a liability on the ice despite his lack of goal scoring. Checking the box score, they're also putting him in situations where he won't become one. He's not playing in their top six. He's not guaranteed the same power-play time as in the past. He's played 49 seconds with the Capitals' opponent's net empty, which is a truly stunning number for the NHL's all-time leader in empty netters (72).

I think there's been some hesitation to make Ovechkin's scoring woes a capital T "Thing" among fans and media. Mostly because he's a 41-year-old skating toward the final curtain, but also because Ovechkin has made us all look foolish in the past after slumps.

"You think he's done and then he scores like eight goals in nine games and finishes with 30," one NHL team executive told ESPN.

That would be a remarkable feat, given that he's on pace for four.


Chicago's Hometown Remix jersey

I still can't believe the Chicago Blackhawks had a chance to "remix" their jerseys and decided to basically just release the St. Patrick's Day sweaters they wore in warmups for several seasons. They added some stripes and collar laces, deleted the shamrock from the front, wiped their hands and said, "Our work here is done."

Again, look at all the creativity in these Hometown Remix jerseys from around the league. Even the ones that miss -- looking at you, Boston -- are interesting. But even other lazier efforts at least had some ingenuity. And by that, I mean the Devils at least color-swapped their Stadium Series sweaters for the Remix.

But Chicago? Green, like they wore for years for St. Patrick's Day. And they had three other more interesting feathers to choose from in their logo!


Sergei Bobrovsky
G, Toronto Maple Leafs

The Leafs' new regime of GM John Chayka and senior adviser/franchise icon Mats Sundin has gotten off to an auspicious start. The team is in an absolute spiral, losing nine of their past 10 games, all in regulation. That includes a winless six-game homestand in which they couldn't at least proactively lose in overtime or a shootout once or twice. Apparently these Leafs are so decrepit that even charity points have turned their backs to Toronto.

There are calls to fire coach Jim Hiller, which would be a hasty admission of a personnel mistake just a few months into the executives' tenure. But sometimes hasty corrections of mistakes can be beneficial. Which brings us to Bobrovsky.

He has been atrocious. An absolute sieve at even strength with a .868 save percentage, the worst for any goalie with at least 10 appearances this season. The Leafs' top-10 penalty kill has kept Bobrovsky's public analytics from cratering. Pull back the curtain and you'll see that he has an elephantine minus-11.4 goals saved above expected at 5-on-5, via Money Puck. There isn't another goalie who has played 10 games and has a negative-goals saved above expected larger than minus-4.

Bobrovsky has a 3-9-2 record, which means the Leafs are 5-4-0 when he's not the goalie of record. He's having the kind of season where the only excuse to keep playing him is to benefit a rebuild, but no one can accuse the Leafs of that, since Bobrovsky's ineptitude benefits only Boston or Philadelphia, whoever owns their first-rounder this season.

Chayka recently offered his own excuse for Bob: "Given his body of work, we think it's deserved and prudent to give him the benefit of the doubt and allow him to get back in the net and stop the next puck."

But the thing with Bobrovsky, 38, is that he hadn't earned the benefit of the doubt with his recent body of work. He lifted the Stanley Cup on June 17, 2025. The next season, he was underwater at 5-on-5 (minus-12 goals saved above replacement), building on an established reputation as a middling regular-season goalie.

Florida decided not to meet his free agent price point this summer despite his previous body of work, which should have been a pulsating red light given the quality of the front office and goalie department. Instead, the Leafs gave Bobrovsky a three-year, $21 million deal, and he has given them some of the worst goaltending in the league this season.

I think Chayka and Sundin have been unfairly maligned so far. Yes, Hiller was a specious hiring and approaching one-and-done status, but several of the depth player acquisitions they made have been solid. I think Darren Raddysh has been fine, despite the minus-11. The Kirill Marchenko move was stellar -- it's no coincidence that the Leafs' offense started derailing during his time out of the lineup with an injury.

That's why the Bobrovsky thing always struck me as weird. It didn't seem in keeping with the vision Chayka and Sundin had for the first of their acquisitions. Was there a push from other parts of the corporation? Did AI suggest signing Bobrovsky? Please recall that Keith Pelley, the president and CEO of Maple Leaf Sports & Entertainment, had to push back on a report that he consulted an AI model for Leafs trade deadline advice.

However Bobrovsky ended up in the Six, Toronto has to find a way to limit his impact or move on from him to salvage this season. And for Bobrovsky, the sooner would be the better, for his own legacy's sake.


San Jose's offense

Both the San Jose Sharks and the Anaheim Ducks are part of that grand tradition of dynamic young offensive teams that try to outscore their defensive failings.

Anaheim did that just enough last season to make the playoffs for the first time since 2018. Through 22 games this season, the Ducks have scored 3.86 goals per game -- thanks, Cutter Gauthier! -- and have given up 3.86 goals per game, which is an astonishing bit of hockey symmetry.

San Jose has been slightly better defensively (3.50 goals against per game), although one wonders how long it will take for that balloon to pop when the Sharks are 32nd in expected goals against at 5-on-5. More concerning is that San Jose hasn't been able to outscore its problems, because its offense has oddly sputtered.

The Sharks are 28th in the NHL in goals per game (2.58), down from their 3.04 goals per game last season. They've seen a dip in expected goals and scoring chances at 5-on-5, but the real culprit is their shooting percentage: just 7.4% at even strength, the second-lowest shot conversion rate in the NHL this season.

The great Macklin Celebrini isn't immune to that downturn, having seen his shooting percentage drop from 15.7% last season (when he scored 45 goals) to just 9.7% this season, having scored nine goals in 22 games.

The good news for the Sharks is that this offensive malaise hasn't led to them getting lapped by the field in the Western Conference standings. The better news is shooting percentage is an inherently elastic stat. The pucks will start going in eventually. Then it's just a matter of scoring more than they surrender.


Josh Doan
RW, Buffalo Sabres

The Sabres ended the longest playoff drought in NHL history last season. As an encore, they became the Buffalo Sabres again.

Doan, 24, is far from the only Sabres player whose stats and effectiveness have plummeted year over year. But there was an ascendance to his game last season, with 25 goals and 27 assists in 82 games. That has turned into a pretty severe regression with four goals and two assists in 21 games. He shot 14.7% last season and 11.1% this season so far. He's on pace for 16 goals and 24 points.

A lot has happened to Doan in the past several months. He signed the richest contract of his career back in January (seven years, $48.65 million). He became an untouchable player on a burgeoning contender.

He had a lower-body injury earlier this season, so maybe that's a factor. But watching Doan this season is watching a player passing where he used to be shooting, and a player who went from third in goals scored above replacement last season to last on the Sabres this season.


Porter Martone
RW, Philadelphia Flyers

The 20-year-old Flyers winger earned his preseason hype. He had 10 points in nine games last season after making the leap to the NHL from Michigan State. In Philadelphia's surprising postseason run, he had two goals and three assists in 10 games. Martone entered this season as the favorite to win the Calder Trophy because he was already playing like a five-season veteran.

After Tuesday night's games, there are 14 rookies who had played at least 10 games and had a higher points-per-game average than Martone -- including Cole Knuble, his rookie teammate on the Flyers. He has three goals and six assists in 24 games, shooting a paltry 8.3%. The sixth overall pick in 2025, Martone has one assist in his past seven games. He's a main character that has somehow morphed into an NPC.

The Flyers have been a disappointment of soap operatic proportions this season, from the Matvei Michkov trade drama to fans buying billboards and private plane banners to demands for the removal of coach Rick Tocchet a scant seven months after he coached them to the second round of the playoffs.

Martone's struggles are symptomatic of that, but also of a larger concern for the Flyers: Their younger stars were unable to properly process last season's unexpected success, which led to a bad preseason, which led to a bad start, which led to someone like Porter Martone becoming a Calder Trophy also-ran a quarter into the season.


Injuries, injuries, injuries

The Colorado Avalanche are down both Nathan MacKinnon and Cale Makar. The Blackhawks had 15 games with Connor Bedard before they lost him to another shoulder injury and have had Bowen Byram -- their huge offseason swing -- for only six games.

The Florida Panthers have been down both Aleksander Barkov and Brad Marchand, which means they're not really the Florida Panthers. The New York Rangers are thriving despite losing one of the best goalies in the world (and quite a goal scorer!) in Igor Shesterkin. The Stanley Cup champion Carolina Hurricanes were without their Conn Smythe winner Jordan Staal for all but seven games. Utah has missed forward Dylan Guenther.

That's a quick summary of key injuries this season. There have been many more. And they always stink.


Utah Mammoth goaltending

The Mammoth spent the first 10 games of the season outscoring their goaltending problems and then spent the next 12 games being unable to do so, dropping from a Central Division playoff seed to the Thunderdome of the Western Conference wild-card battle.

Utah made the playoffs last season because of Karel Vejmelka, who led the NHL with 64 appearances. That included 19 out of 25 starts after the Olympic break, in which he posted a .883 save percentage and a 3.14 goals-against average but went 11-6-1.

He matched that goals-against average through 16 starts this season, but with a .872 save percentage. His crease-mate Sebastian Cossa, whom they acquired from Detroit for a first-round pick as a project with upside, was worse with a .863 save percentage and a 3.56 goals-against average.

Both goalies are well underwater analytically. Among public metrics, Vejmelka had a minus-7 goals saved above expected in 16 games, while Cossa was at minus-5.2 in eight games, per Money Puck. Evolving Hockey had both in the negative in wins above replacement as well.

"They're way at the bottom of the list. So that's not good enough," former NHL goalie Martin Biron of TSN told me recently.

Biron said the best virtue of Vejmelka is that he loves to play a lot. "But now he's kind of hitting a little bit of a speed bump here and there and you can't continue to play him if he's not performing," he said.

Given the talent in front of the crease, one might wonder why the Mammoth weren't more aggressive in trying to trade for Connor Hellebuyck before the New Jersey Devils did. According to my sources, the ask from Winnipeg was for Logan Cooley or Dylan Guenther coming back the other way from a division rival. So wonder no more. That wasn't going to happen.


Matthew Wood
RW, Nashville Predators and Seattle Kraken

The breakout player that went bust.

Of Wood, ESPN's Rachel Kryshak had said, "One of the key players of Nashville's rebuild enters his second season primed for a much bigger opportunity." That opportunity? Playing alongside Nashville star forward Filip Forsberg, with whom he had good chemistry last season.

Wood had 17 goals and 13 assists in 71 games last season and projected to be a strong power forward with a net-front presence. Kryshak predicted that Wood could hit 55 points this season.

Instead, he hit the next flight to Seattle out of Nashville, as the Predators turned a key building block into trade bait to land center Shane Wright from the Kraken.

Wood became available because he couldn't recapture the magic with Forsberg. They skated just over 92 minutes together at 5-on-5 and produced a measly 1.3 goals per 60 minutes while on the ice. Wood was moved off that line and saw his overall ice time dramatically dip after eight games. He had only one goal and two assists in 14 games before the Predators traded him. Wright equaled that point total in Nashville after just five games. In his first four games in Seattle, Wood had one assist.

He's only 21 years old and has all the tools to thrive in the NHL. But playing his way out of Nashville lands him on this list.


Finally, the refusal to pad Connor McDavid's stats

McDavid remains on pace for at least 200 points this season, having scored 55 points in his first 23 games for the surging Oilers. As we touched on in last week's Wysh List, McDavid is trying to become the first player not named Wayne Gretzky to break 200 points and is in range of Gretzky's single-season points record of 215 set in 1985-86, which, given how much harder it is to score in today's NHL, is just astonishing.

If McDavid is going to get to 200 points, he's going to need some help.

Not from the Oilers. From NHL scorekeepers.

McDavid recently factored into two Oilers goals -- against the Rangers and the Flyers -- where he helped create offensive opportunities but wasn't credited with assists because opponents touched the puck before Edmonton players put it in the net.

By the rulebook, this might have been the correct scoring, but I have little time for the rulebook when I have a craven desire to see the best hockey player in the world shatter a seemingly unreachable record in my lifetime.

To my friends in the scorekeeping community, and also the ones behind the NHL's puck and player tracking: Help a guy out, will you? We should be adding assists to his total, not subtracting them! Be generous. Use the same multiplier they used at Nassau Coliseum for Cal Clutterbuck's hits. Together, we can make history ... and there's nothing disappointing about that.

Jump ahead:
Winners, losers of the week
Favorite on-ice moment
Must-see games
Puck headlines

WINNERS AND LOSERS

Winner: Cutter Gauthier scoring

The Ducks forward is having one of the greatest goal-scoring months in NHL history. He became the first player to record four hat tricks in a calendar month and the first player in more than 103 years to record four hat tricks in a span of nine games. He's scored 14 goals in 14 games, joining Gretzky as the only players age 22 or younger to do so. Gauthier now has 17 goals in November, putting him within reach of the NHL record for most goals in a month (20).

It's Cutter Gauthier's November; we're just living in it.

Loser: Cutter Gauthier conjecture

The better Gauthier does, the more revisionist history is dispensed around his decision not to play for the Flyers, the team that drafted him. The latest: GM Danny Briere refuting a report that his front office broke a promise to Gauthier about turning pro. He called it "nonsense" in a radio interview.

"This is just people trying to rehash things that happened in the past. We talked about it two years ago when it happened," Briere said. "It never came to my ears that there was any kind of promises."

Well, I'm sure that's the last we'll hear of this ...

play
2:15
Cutter Gauthier extends goal streak to 10 games with hat trick for Ducks

Winner: Mortality

The Athletic's Dan Robson had a remarkable story about the mental health challenges of goaltenders this week. Calgary Flames netminder and amateur philosopher Devin Cooley was featured and revealed how he would sometimes process bad goals he'd given up: By scanning the crowd for "elderly people" and "thinking about how that person likely would die before him -- and therefore, no one would remember the bad goal he'd just given up." Goalies, man.

Loser: Fragility

What an absolute bummer it was to see Connor Bedard injured off a faceoff on Tuesday night. Grabbing his shoulder, tossing his stick, knowing the potential severity. He has 18 points in 15 games. It's horrendous we don't get to watch more of him.

Winner: Utah Mammoth

Utah's Winter Classic jersey is an instant classic, from the vivid blue to the faux throwback Mammoth.

Chris Armstrong, the team's president of hockey operations, told me it's a Top 3 Winter Classic jersey. He might not be wrong.

Loser: IIHF website

The International Ice Hockey Federation's website was hacked this week, as someone posted an image of Ilya Kovalchuk and the headline "Scared To Face Russia?" after the IIHF removed Russia from the upcoming world junior championship.

The IIHF website is now being rebuilt, with a temp site currently up. Suggestion: Don't make the admin password "hockey" next time.


FAVORITE ON-ICE MOMENT

If goalie interference is the NHL's ultimate Rorschach test, goals scored on kicked pucks is right behind it for divergent perceptions. This one by the Devils' Connor Brown counted, with the NHL Situation Room ruling that "a puck that deflects into the net off an attacking Player's skate who does not use a 'distinct kicking motion' shall be ruled a goal."

I'm torn in this one. It's clearly a kick that propels the puck into the net and shouldn't have counted ... and yet it's an impressive bit of skill from Brown to knock that puck into the Capitals' net. It remains a little absurd that players are allowed to kick the puck to their stick or their teammate or out of the zone or anywhere that's not over the goal line.

So, in summary: This shouldn't have been a goal ... but I'm happy it was.


FAVORITE OFF-ICE MOMENT

At an Edmonton Save-On-Foods, giant depictions of Oilers stars Connor McDavid and Leon Draisaitl were created out of cases of soda. Put it in the Louvre.


MUST-SEE GAMES

Edmonton Oilers at Carolina Hurricanes

Sat., Nov. 21, 1 p.m. ET | ESPN+

The top two teams in the NHL entering Thursday night's games. Their last meeting in Edmonton on Oct. 22 was a bonkers 6-5 shootout win for the Oilers that saw Connor McDavid and Leon Draisaitl both post five-point games. This time, however, the Hurricanes will have Jordan Staal in the lineup.

Ottawa Senators at Florida Panthers

Wed., Nov. 25, 7 p.m. ET | ESPN+

Brady Tkachuk welcomes some old friends from Ottawa down to Sunrise after their contentious reunion up north last month.

San Jose Sharks at Anaheim Ducks

Wed., Nov. 25, 10 p.m. ET | ESPN+

Cutter Gauthier vs. Macklin Celebrini. NorCal vs. SoCal. Sharks vs. Ducks. There will be goals.


PUCK HEADLINES

Dateline: Pittsburgh

With the Penguins at 7-11-2 and playing wildly inconsistent hockey, Sidney Crosby's future is again becoming a topic of conversation around Pittsburgh.

GM Kyle Dubas met the media on Wednesday and discussed the "unique circumstance" he faces with Crosby, Evgeni Malkin and Kris Letang. Two members of that trinity are unrestricted free agents after this season: Crosby and Malkin. Letang is signed through 2027-28.

Dubas said Crosby's situation is as unique as it gets.

"He's owed all the respect in the world," Dubas said. "If he wants to be here, that's great, and that's obviously what we would love as well."

But Dubas is a realist. If the Penguins don't turn things around, there will be trades of veterans for "future-oriented" returns. That shift in focus is as much a factor for the Penguins' three legends as their own advancing age.

"They're at an age where it's not just a given that they're always going to continue to play, either," Dubas said. "There's so many different variables, [like] our team performance, how they're feeling about things. I know we all wish them to play forever, but at some point the time comes."

Dateline: Detroit

A quick update on the ongoing Dylan Larkin and Simon Edvinsson drama:

1. The Detroit Free Press reported that the Red Wings are seeking "an established 30-goal scorer, preferably a center" in exchange for Larkin. Well ... it's good to want things, one supposes.

I can report that the Red Wings are open to other trade packages. One team that checked in on Larkin had Detroit asking for a young cornerstone center that could score 30 goals in the NHL but hadn't yet.

Ultimately, this remains a game of chicken. The Red Wings are waiting things out in the hopes that Larkin expands his trade list to teams that are willing to ante up in ways teams on his current 10-team list are not. Larkin is waiting in the hopes that Detroit eventually takes the best deal available, like Winnipeg did with the Devils' deal for Connor Hellebuyck -- and that the best deal is the one from the Minnesota Wild, his desired destination.

Who blinks? All we know is that Larkin's salary losses due to his suspension are due to cross $1 million this weekend.

2. Edvinsson has his own deadline. The restricted free agent must sign a contract by Dec. 1 at 5 p.m. ET, or he'll be ineligible to play in the NHL for the remainder of the 2026-27 season. The 23-year-old defenseman has been linked to the Boston Bruins, who have multiple first-round picks and a deep prospect pool. The San Jose Sharks have been circling Edvinsson, and Max Miller of Sharks Hockey Digest noted that Detroit assistant GM Kris Draper was scouting the Sharks recently.

One team that I believe is keeping an eye on Edvinsson is the Edmonton Oilers. It makes a ton of sense from an age perspective and the role he'd play. Edvinsson helped form one of the best defensive pairing in the league with Moritz Seider last season. Imagine him holding down the fort defensively next to Norris Trophy contender Evan Bouchard in Edmonton.

The clock keeps ticking ... who steps up to land Edvinsson?