ACC roundtable: Helping league perception

Florida State is the only unbeaten team in the nation, but the Seminoles are not seeded No. 1 in the College Football Playoff. While its close victories are a big reason why, conference affiliation also has played a role. The ACC is viewed as the weakest Power 5 conference, even though the Noles are the defending national champions and 11 teams have made bowl games in back-to-back seasons.

There is a clear perception problem here. So what can the ACC do to gain respect and start gaining more credibility nationally?

ACC reporters Andrea Adelson, David Hale, Matt Fortuna and Jared Shanker weigh in with their thoughts.

What does the league need to do to gain respect around here?

MF: The answer is fairly simple: The ACC needs more good teams to get better, and more bad teams to get good. Florida State winning it all last year helps. If the Seminoles could somehow do it again, that would be huge … though ACC detractors would surely find a way to chalk up a potential 31-game winning streak to poor competition, fairly or not. Alabama's last two title teams, remember, both lost. This year's Tide team has, too, and it is in the playoffs as the No. 1 seed. Regardless, the ACC needs Clemson to keep it up. The Tigers potentially winning 10 games this year in what could be qualified as a "rebuilding" year is huge for the trajectory of that program. And the ACC could really use the brand names — ahem, Miami and North Carolina —to provide the Coastal some flavor and create for a much more balanced conference. Louisville's 9-3 inaugural ACC campaign is a nice start, too.

JS: Well, there are a lot of complicated answers that involve money being pumped into the football programs, but the easiest way to gain respect is to not only keep winning but to have several teams do it. The league needs to have multiple teams in the playoff conversation every season. Florida State was basically the last playoff contender for the league by midseason. Nonconference rivalry and bowl game wins have a shelf life about as long as a glass of milk left on the counter. Spending weeks at a time toward the top of rankings and in the national conversation will do much more.

DH: The long-term key for the league is establishing depth beyond the top of the conference. The SEC saw the Mississippi schools rise up this year, and that has burnished the narrative that no game is easy. The same isn’t said for the ACC, where close games for Florida State were viewed as if they were losses. The onus is on North Carolina, Miami and Virginia Tech to emerge from their 6-6 seasons to become players nationally if the ACC is going to earn consistent respect.

AA: The facts are out there. Nobody wants to hear them, or believe them. As much as I respect John Swofford and the way he has begun to turn this into a football conference, he needs to take a page out of the Jim Delany/Mike Slive handbook and start shouting about his league’s strengths from every mountaintop he can find. That might not be his style, but enough is enough. He cannot sit idly by while everybody continues to trash his league. Especially given the way Florida State has been disrespected this year.

The bowl slate has been dramatically improved, with eight games against Power-5 teams. Which bowl do they absolutely have to win?

MF: Aside from the obvious ones, the playoffs and the Capital One Orange Bowl? Clemson cannot afford to lose a four-loss Oklahoma team. Louisville beating Georgia would be very big, too, as it would make the ACC 2-1 against the Bulldogs this season. Here's one that might indirectly help, too: Notre Dame beating LSU in the Franklin American Mortgage Music City Bowl. The five-loss Irish had a disappointing season and yet almost knocked off FSU. And though that almost label can be applied to several teams this year, a pseudo-ACC team beating a brand-name SEC team on national TV will be good for perception moving forward. Especially next year, when the Irish play six ACC teams.

JS: It would behoove Georgia Tech to beat Mississippi State for personal and conference reasons. Georgia Tech is a team that rarely gets the recognition in the years the Jackets are strong, and they are quick to be criticized in down years because of a combination of a surly Paul Johnson and offense ridiculed as antiquated. The Bulldogs were media darlings through much of the season and had a Heisman candidate in Dak Prescott. Any major bowl game against the SEC is a must win for the ACC. Honestly, I don’t know if Tech winning would do much nationally for the league because Mississippi State has faltered late in the season. A Bulldogs win would allow the SEC to pound its chest, though, and the ACC just can’t have that.

DH: There’s no question it’s the Rose Bowl. It’s nothing new for Florida State to carry the torch for the conference, but this year it’s particularly true. FSU was knocked all season long for playing close games against supposedly weak competition, but a win over Oregon would certainly prove that even the middle of the ACC was better than most people thought, and it would put FSU — and the conference — in position for a second straight national title.

AA: First, a winning bowl record is a must. Since 2005, the ACC has posted a winning bowl record just twice. The priority has to be the Florida State game, and then all the games against the SEC, the league it is compared to the most. Going 4-0 in rivalry weekend is great, but the league has to keep building momentum there -- especially since it has a chance to post a winning record against the SEC for the first time since 2003.

Speaking of the SEC, will the ACC ever be on the same footing as the league still regarded as the best in the country?

MF: That's tough to say, especially given the size of the schools and their potential fan bases. Wake Forest is the smallest Power 5 conference school that plays football. The ACC has several private schools as well. And as historic as Boston College and Syracuse's programs are, allow this Northeast native to say that football fandom in that corner of the country isn't exactly what it is down south, where all of the SEC schools are. (As opposed to just some of the ACC schools.) I can't see the SEC's popularity ever really sinking. The population shift in that region, coupled with the enhanced stakes via expansion, TV deals and facilities upgrades, should ensure that football is always very, very important. That shouldn't stop the ACC from cashing in on those factors, though. Many of its programs — and especially its top ones — are well-positioned from a real-estate standpoint to recruit well and continue to grow. Whether that means it has programs on an annual basis that can go toe-to-toe with the Alabamas and LSUs of the world remain to be seen. What makes the SEC so great, though, is that even when some of those bluebloods are down (Florida, Tennessee), others seem to step up in their place (Mississippi State, Ole Miss).

JS: On the field or in the public eye? They might not be that far off right now on the field. Let’s start with the facts that the once beleaguered ACC was brutal on the big stages for several years. The numbers the last two seasons tell a different story, though. Florida State won the national title and is now in the playoff, the conference won two of the final BCS games and has two in New Year’s Six bowls this season and went a collective 4-0 against the SEC on rivalry weekend and 10-7 in nonconference Power-5 games. Why is important to mention the SEC? Because in a regional sport that’s where the game means most and audience and financial numbers attest. Eye balls are drawn to the SEC, so even though King SEC died last season, it’s easy to keep up the charade in a sport in which off-field conversation can trump on-field performance. The ACC doesn’t have the fan bases to generate conversation for all 14 teams, so each member has a responsibility to make its pro-ACC pitch on the football field. The old football axiom is winning cures all, though, and if the ACC keeps chipping away and generating playoff conversation, the respect should come.

DH: The SEC has the full package — the biggest stadiums, the die-hard fan bases, the top recruits, the highest-paid coaches and the most lucrative TV deal. That’s a combination that ensures long-term success, and that league has been forward-thinking about growing its brand. The ACC has been more of a work in progress, and while some programs are clearly making strides — FSU, Clemson, Louisville — to compete with the best of the best, the overall conference has a lot of catching up to do, and the SEC doesn’t seem poised to slow down any time soon.

AA: I don’t think it’s as much about being on equal footing, as making sure it has a more well-rounded middle. The ACC does well in recruiting; it does well with TV payouts; and it continually sends players to the NFL at a rate greater than any league but the SEC. But that talent does not necessarily translate into wins-and-losses across the ACC. Miami and North Carolina are perennial underachievers in that regard. I go back to the points we made earlier. The ACC has to continue to schedule aggressively in nonconference and win those games, and it needs six teams ranked on an annual basis, just like the SEC. When that happens then minds will start to change.